No Bookmarks Exist.
At this time, I'd like to call to order the February 10th the Floyd County Planning Commission. At this time, we'd like to stand 00:00:13
and honor our flag, please. 00:00:17
United States of America. 00:00:23
And to Republic, for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. 00:00:26
OK, at this time I'd like to have a roll call. 00:00:36
Here. 00:00:39
Present. 00:00:44
Yeah. 00:00:46
Here. 00:00:47
Here. 00:00:50
Here. 00:00:51
Here. 00:00:53
Alrighty, one shorter board member. That's eight of us, correct? 00:00:55
All right. 00:00:58
At this time. 00:01:01
We'd like to have the minutes of the December. 00:01:03
Fruit. I'm going to take a look at those and make a motion. 00:01:07
I make a motion that we approve the December Planning Commission. 00:01:15
Minutes. All right. Thank you. I have a. 00:01:18
Motion any second. 00:01:21
Awesome. Go ahead. 00:01:24
I got a second, but John any. 00:01:25
Conversation. 00:01:27
Discussion. 00:01:29
At that time, we take a motion all in favor. 00:01:30
Aye, those opposed likewise. Thank you. Approved. Thank you. 00:01:33
All righty. We have no old business. Is that correct, Nick? 00:01:36
OK, this time we'd like to agenda number item number one, we have have to have the election of officers. 00:01:42
And at this time, we need some recommendation emotions. 00:01:49
I nominate Mr. Hunter for the president. 00:01:54
All right, we got a motion for president. We need a second. 00:01:57
Second. All right, we've got a second all in favor. 00:02:00
Aye, those opposed likewise. Thank you. 00:02:03
All right, now we need somebody for Vice President. 00:02:06
Needed somebody to. 00:02:09
Volunteer piece. 00:02:11
For a motion or a motion, there you go. Make somebody make a motion. That'll work. 00:02:16
Frank, are you willing to do it? 00:02:22
Take care. All right, so somebody needs to make a motion for Frank. 00:02:26
I'll make a motion, Frank. 00:02:29
For vice president. 00:02:31
All right, we have a motion a second all any discussion? 00:02:33
All in favor signify by. 00:02:37
Those opposed likewise. All right. Thanks. Thanks a lot. 00:02:39
All right. Next thing is the plant review committee. 00:02:42
Right now I've show that's Larry. 00:02:46
Chris Welch, Gina. 00:02:48
John Brankworth and myself as everybody still willing to serve. 00:02:50
I am OK Larry is John. 00:02:54
Gina and we called Chris and I'm willing to do that. So that takes care of that, OK? 00:02:58
All right. Next Adam is the Adam agenda item number two, FC-01. 00:03:03
Hold on. So you guys need to vote on that. 00:03:08
On which someone on the plant review, so I'm sorry, we need a vote on the plant review. So I need a motion to accept those 5 00:03:10
members. 00:03:13
Make a motion. All right, we have a motion. I need a second. 00:03:18
All right, all in favor signify by. 00:03:22
Likewise opposed. Thank you all right now. 00:03:24
All right. Now we're going to go to agenda item number 2. 00:03:29
FC-01-25-01, Administrative Subdivision. 00:03:32
Nick will give us his staff report. 00:03:37
This is an. 00:03:40
Minor subdivision application for four lot subdivision. The petitioner is ASB LLC. The zoning district is agricultural 00:03:41
residential. 00:03:45
They are requesting A4 lot subdivision with frontage on Nippleton Road. 00:03:50
The property currently has a home and two barns on it. 00:03:54
There is an identified floodway and floodway fringe on the South and. 00:03:58
Side of the property. 00:04:01
The plaque committee for this was cancelled due to a lack of quorum. 00:04:03
Staff comments is that the plat as submitted does comply with lot size standards. Lots are minimum of two acres with 100 foot. 00:04:07
Road frontage plate I submitted does comply with streets. 00:04:15
Standards There are no new streets provided. The plat as submitted does comply with easement standards with conditions. 00:04:19
Stated below, the driveway easements are needed. 00:04:25
For every two lots, one driveway easement is required. 00:04:30
Unless that requirement is waived by the. 00:04:34
Flat as submitted does comply with the block standards. There are no blocks proposed. 00:04:38
The plat as submitted does provide St. improvements as required. Again, no streets proposed. 00:04:44
The plat, as submitted does comply with Water Supply Standards Board and tri-county Regional Water has provided a service letter 00:04:51
for the new lots. 00:04:55
3 inch inch line is available for service. 00:04:59
This line is not adequate to provide Fire Protection. 00:05:02
The plot as submitted is suitable for sewage and wastewater containment because they have soil provided soil testing. 00:05:07
And has been completed by the Floyd County Health Department. 00:05:14
Reviewed in by the Floyd County Health Department and provided septic system requirements for suitable systems. 00:05:19
Staff Recommendations. 00:05:26
Would be to require joint driveways. 00:05:28
In easements to be added to the plat for lots. 00:05:31
I believe we said it was one and two, unless that is waived by the Planning Commission. 00:05:37
Add note on. 00:05:42
Flat that prior to development, the Owner shall consult with Highlander Fire Protection District. 00:05:44
On driveway placement. 00:05:50
All right. That's our staff reporting by having questions for Nick at this time on the board. 00:05:53
None. All righty. Thank you, Nick. 00:06:01
OK, at this time we'd like to call the applicant to come. 00:06:04
Forward and presenter. 00:06:06
Good evening. State your name and address. Yes, Sir. Brad Benson with ASB 720 Rolling Creek. 00:06:10
Drive the Ste. 106 in New Albany. 00:06:16
I know you all have blacks in your file there, but I've got a couple bigger ones if anyone would like. 00:06:19
You want to walk on. 00:06:24
Not a problem. 00:06:25
Yes, please. 00:06:29
So the staff report pretty much. 00:06:41
Pretty clear on what it is. It's a 20 acre parcel located at 688. 00:06:44
0 Mapleton Rd. 00:06:48
It is a R. 00:06:50
The tracks are. 00:06:51
For Track 1 is five acres, Track 2 is five acres, Track 3 is 2 acres. 00:06:53
Track 3 is the one with the house on it that will remain. 00:06:59
Track 4 is the 8 acre parcel. 00:07:02
He's correct on the ordinance allows for. 00:07:06
A minimum of two acre lots, so it applies with that. The road frontage is 100 square or 100 feet. 00:07:09
So we could play with that. 00:07:15
One element that he did say that. 00:07:16
It does not meet. 00:07:18
The board has. 00:07:20
So the Commission has the ability to. 00:07:22
Waive the right for an access easement between these lots. 00:07:24
We would ask that that be waived for all four parcels. 00:07:28
Track 3 already has a house on it. Our goal with this is that we're not. There's no plans for this right now. We're going to let 00:07:33
it sit. 00:07:36
May list it and sell it and let somebody out. 00:07:40
Build a house on it. We are home builder so hopefully it's us. 00:07:42
We may end up holding. 00:07:45
Family member, but right now there's no plans. 00:07:47
So with these big, Big Lots, we're hoping that you know you're. 00:07:51
State style houses big, lots big. 00:07:55
You know, big entrance in there. 00:07:58
If the Commission were to require a. 00:08:00
The access easement. 00:08:03
I would ask that it only be on. 00:08:05
Lots 1 and 2. 00:08:07
Those are the two bigger ones on the. 00:08:09
If you're looking at the fly on the bottom side. 00:08:11
It's only because lot 3 already has a drive. 00:08:14
Lot 4 would then be a separate drive as well. 00:08:17
If that is not an option and Commission would require the. 00:08:21
Access easements on all of them. 00:08:26
Then I would ask that the approval tonight be conditioned upon us supplying those. 00:08:28
I believe it's 50 feet wide along those property lines. 00:08:33
And we'll submit that proper paperwork. 00:08:37
For Nick for approval. 00:08:39
So just to clarify real quick on the excess easements. 00:08:40
Are they are they not using the road frontage to access their properties or will they need to go across the other tracks? No they 00:08:46
will. They all have proper Rd. frontage along Naples and road. So our hope would be that we would have drives off of Napleton. 00:08:52
That would not be able to. 00:08:58
Access easement will not be needed. 00:09:00
So you still got these the site provisions for one for #1 Yes, there is. So the minimum is 100 feet and. 00:09:04
There's 100 on all. 00:09:13
Yeah. 00:09:18
Fall from there and Associates, 301 E Chestnut St. Court in Indiana. 00:09:21
Your administrative subdivision requirements have have a have a requirement for joint driveways for every two lots. That's what 00:09:24
Mr. Benson is describing. 00:09:28
I understand the limit the need is to limit access to county roads. 00:09:34
But when you have Big Lots like this, especially one that has an existing House of drive, it makes it difficult to Co locate those 00:09:38
drives. 00:09:42
And even though the ordinance requires it, it still creates a maintenance problem. 00:09:46
Because you have two homeowners fighting over. 00:09:49
Who's going to maintain that joint driveway? 00:09:51
It's it's in my opinion to everyone's best interest to separate those travelers. 00:09:53
OK. Any other questions? 00:10:00
None. 00:10:05
All right. At this time, we'd like to open up to anybody that like to speak in favor of this project. 00:10:06
Come forward now. State your name and your address for the record. 00:10:13
See that there's none stepping forward. 00:10:19
Now we open up to those who want to oppose. Are you come in favor, Sir? 00:10:21
OK, OK. Well. 00:10:26
Yeah, anybody wants coming against it, coming forward. 00:10:28
State your name and your address for the record please. 00:10:31
James White. 00:10:38
Everybody got that gotcha. 00:10:39
OK, I live at 314 Tuscany Drive. 00:10:41
And if they open all that up there and that's going to open our street up to. 00:10:44
Them coming more traffic down through there, right? 00:10:50
Sir, I think you're about the wrong. You're on the wrong project. Sir, this is on Napleton Road. 00:10:53
I'm sorry. 00:10:57
You're in the right church, Wrong Pew. 00:10:59
All right, so. 00:11:05
You he got a jump on you guys. 00:11:09
All right, at this time everybody will speak in opposition. 00:11:13
To the administrative subdivision. 00:11:17
On naval Tarot come forward, state your name and address. 00:11:20
Mike Gatton. I live at 6975 Napleton Rd. 00:11:24
And my property overlooks this property. 00:11:27
And. 00:11:31
The traffic is already bad due to Cutter Smith woodworking. 00:11:32
Huber's all that and to divide this out and put four more houses on there. 00:11:36
Just opens it up for more development and. 00:11:42
There's a second. 00:11:44
Lot that is not involved in this to the left of it and it's going to open that up for more development. 00:11:45
We moved out there to be in the county. I've lived there 23 years. We don't want to be in the city. 00:11:52
The traffic, The busing. 00:11:56
School buses, things like that. 00:11:58
The trucks it's already bad enough we. 00:12:01
Preferred the county to state county. 00:12:03
That's why we're there. 00:12:06
Thank you. 00:12:09
Have some more time for anybody else to come forward. State your name and address for the record. 00:12:14
And take the films. 00:12:20
And I live at 7200 Mableton Rd. 00:12:22
Our property also looks through. 00:12:25
Mr. loops backyard. 00:12:27
Over to this property. 00:12:29
Like he said, the traffic is already so terrible. We have. 00:12:31
Multiple wrecks with semis on. 00:12:35
Our Rd. every year that drive off the roads hit trees. 00:12:37
It is. 00:12:42
So busy. 00:12:43
Adding this is. 00:12:44
Taking away all of our country, all of our farmland. 00:12:46
I I had somebody build a house behind me a couple years ago and I now have no deer in my yard. I mean like there's literally no 00:12:50
wildlife except for comedies. If anybody knows about my coyote issue, but. 00:12:56
There is. 00:13:01
Like nothing coming in our property more because everybody's building and scaring them out and. 00:13:02
That's why we moved there. We moved to begin the country. We have farm animals. 00:13:07
And dogs and. 00:13:11
Horses and goats, and that's what we moved there for and. 00:13:13
I mean you all all moved out there for the same reason. I know where most of you live and you move to those areas for. 00:13:16
That in. 00:13:22
You're turning it around. There's another piece of land. 00:13:23
I know the same person bought on Ableton road and if you all approve this. 00:13:26
It's just gonna turn around and get approved for him as well, and that's. 00:13:30
Down by the cows. 00:13:33
So like, that's our landmarks. We turn at the cows you go to. 00:13:35
This farm and that farm and you're just turning it away. 00:13:39
Everybody asked me every day. 00:13:43
Do you know anybody that has 5 acres for sale? 00:13:44
No, because somebody buys it and puts a whole bunch of houses on it. 00:13:47
That's not what we want. 00:13:51
So just consider that. 00:13:52
Thank you. 00:13:54
Good evening, Troy Durham. 00:14:03
7222 Napleton Rd. 00:14:05
I'm also as a crow flies less than a mile from this development potential development. 00:14:07
I don't chagrin anybody for China. 00:14:12
Exercise their free enterprise and do business as they see fit. They have the freedom to do it. 00:14:14
My two cents as much like these other people who spoke. 00:14:20
It's too crowded on the road. It's too busy. 00:14:24
And uh, uh. 00:14:26
To be frank. 00:14:28
I don't like the discomfort I already have fearing for my. 00:14:29
Home and those within it from vehicle. 00:14:33
Thanks. We've had semis in our front yard. 00:14:36
In the past. 00:14:38
And I just think it's too much on the road. 00:14:41
Too much development. 00:14:43
This would maybe be a domino. 00:14:44
Of continuing the domino effect of what's already happened with the. 00:14:46
Development further out to the county. 00:14:50
I don't wish to see it. 00:14:52
For my $0.02. 00:14:54
And where I lived. 00:14:56
And chose to live. 00:14:57
For rural reasons. 00:14:59
There's something. 00:15:00
Alluring to being out in the country. 00:15:01
And I think that would be spoiled. 00:15:03
Thank you very much. Thank you. 00:15:05
Anybody else? 00:15:08
All right, at this time we get. 00:15:12
Nobody else in opposition. We open the floor back to the petitioner to rebut. 00:15:15
Anything that was discussed. 00:15:19
Thank you. I'll make it short here. The only thing I would like to point out is we are this is administrative flat. 00:15:23
We comply with the ordinance. The only issue would be the access easement. 00:15:29
I said I would ask that you waive that right here because of what we're trying to do with this. 00:15:34
We are not looking to divide this property. It is an AR which is a. 00:15:39
Two acre lot minimum. 00:15:42
So hypothetically we get coming forth with a plat for 9 acres in that zone. 00:15:44
We're not looking to do that. 00:15:49
Worth looking just for four. 00:15:50
They're Big Lots, A2 acre. The smallest one is one with the house on it. They'll remain. 00:15:52
And then the 55 naked SO. 00:15:57
All right. Thank you. 00:15:59
At this point where we looking for a ballot? 00:16:03
I have a ballot. 00:16:07
Subdivision named Ableton Place DACA. 00:16:08
FC 01/25/01. 00:16:11
After careful review, the fact committee finds that one. 00:16:15
Plant as submitted does comply with the lot size standards. 00:16:18
Because the new lights are all a minimum of two acres with more than 100. 00:16:22
Foot of Rd. frontage #2. 00:16:26
The plan has submitted does comply with the street design standards. 00:16:29
Because no streets, no new streets are proposed. 00:16:33
#3. 00:16:36
The plan has submitted does comply with the easement standards because with the conditions below, driveway easements. 00:16:37
Or required. 00:16:43
#4 the plat as submitted does comply with the block standards. 00:16:45
Because there are no blocks required or proposed. 00:16:48
#5 the plat as submitted does. 00:16:52
Provide St. and. 00:16:55
Improvements as required by the ordinance. There are no new streets provided. 00:16:56
Number six, the Plat as submitted does comply with the water supply standards because. 00:17:01
Board and Tri Water Regional. 00:17:06
Water has provided a service letter for the new. 00:17:09
Lots. A three inch line is available for service. Note this line is not adequate for bad Fire Protection. 00:17:13
#7 the plat as submitted is suitable. 00:17:19
Pursuage and wastewater contain. 00:17:21
Containment because soil testing has been completed. 00:17:24
And Floyd County Health Department has provided septic system requirements for suitable systems. 00:17:27
The plant is accepted upon completion of the following condition at a joint driveway and easement to the plat for Lots 1 and 2. 00:17:33
Adding note to the plat. 00:17:40
That states the following. Prior to development, the owners shall consult the Highlander Fire Protection District for Fire 00:17:41
Protection requirements. 00:17:45
Due to the lack of adequate water supply. 00:17:48
Decision the Floyd County Planning Commission hereby grants the. 00:17:51
Primary approval. 00:17:55
For this administrative subdivision at the meeting held on the 10th of February, 2025. 00:17:56
That completes my ballot. 00:18:02
All right, we have a ballot. We're looking for a second. 00:18:04
I'll second. We have a second. 00:18:09
All in favor signify any discussion. Any discussion. 00:18:11
Any discussion? 00:18:15
All in favor signify by aye aye, those opposed likewise. 00:18:17
It passes. Thank you. 00:18:22
Did they sign down? 00:18:31
OK, at this time we like to move to Well, first of all, we want to ask the petitioner. 00:18:34
If they're OK with us putting. 00:18:40
Agenda items 3 through 6 and hearing them at the same time. 00:18:43
Mr. Craft, you OK with that? 00:18:47
All right. 00:18:50
Yes, separate ballots on everyone. Yes, Sir. 00:18:52
OK. OK. At this time, we'd like to ask Nick Creeby. 00:18:55
I'm a non voting member but I'll be recused recusing myself for the rest of the meeting. All right, thank you. 00:19:00
At this time, they could give a staff report. 00:19:09
So this is for docket items number FCO 1/25/02. 00:19:13
CO125. 00:19:18
Three FC 24. 00:19:20
504. 00:19:23
In FC. 00:19:27
1/25/05. 00:19:31
Petitioner Here's the Thing Group LLC. The location is 5031 through 5053 Old Vincent's Road. 00:19:38
The requests are for a zoning map amendment. 00:19:45
A major subdivision. 00:19:50
A PUD map amendment. 00:19:53
In detailed development. 00:19:56
They are all pertaining to the same project. 00:19:59
The current zoning is for general commercial. 00:20:03
Underlying zoning request is for multi family and then a multi family PUD. 00:20:07
The petitioner is seeking a planned unit development for mixed-use, multi family residential and commercial use. 00:20:13
This proposal will consolidate 4 parcels into two building lots, 3 points 64 and 2.334 acres. 00:20:19
The lots will be separated by through St. known as Knobs Landing Blvd. 00:20:28
Connecting Tuscany Drive in Trevor Rd. 00:20:33
Lot 1 will front will Vincennes Road and is the larger lot and will include two building. 00:20:36
Two buildings, A mixed-use commercial multifamily building. Building 1. 00:20:42
In a separate standalone commercial. 00:20:46
Retail building with drive through. 00:20:49
Which is proposed bank building 3 threes. 00:20:51
Lot 2 will have a single multi family building. 00:20:54
In a building 2. 00:20:58
Building 1 at the north of the property in the fronting Old Vincennes Rd. 00:21:00
Will be a three story structure with the ground floor area of 25,092 square feet. 00:21:05
The building will include 7717 square foot of commercial retail space. 00:21:11
Clubhouse leasing office. 00:21:17
And 59 multifamily units, 21 of those will be two-bedroom, 38 one bedroom. 00:21:19
Building 3 at the east side of the property will be near the corner of Shriver and Old Vincent's. 00:21:26
It will be a thirty 3600 square foot retail building with drive through that is the proposed bank. 00:21:31
Building 2, located at the South of the property on Lot 2, will be a three story multi family structure with ground floor area of 00:21:40
23,679 square feet and 66 units. 00:21:46
The property will also have. 00:21:52
Pool and outdoor recreation games area. 00:21:54
Neat foot masonry wall. 00:21:57
We'll buffer the residents on the West side of the development. 00:22:00
Villas of Floyd's knives. 00:22:03
Adjoining properties to the West. 00:22:05
Is the residential urban zone subdivision buildings of Floyd's Knobs to northwest across Tuscany. Dr. is a vacant general 00:22:07
commercial property. 00:22:12
Across Old Vincennes Road to the north is undeveloped general commercial. 00:22:16
To the northeast is Highlander Point development. 00:22:20
General commercial zoned. 00:22:23
The East Across River Rd. is general commercial. 00:22:26
To the South is residentially urban zone property with two acre single family lot. 00:22:29
In small section of the Highland subdivision. 00:22:34
Which is residential urban. 00:22:37
The current base zone for the proposal is general commercial. 00:22:39
Commercial. 00:22:43
Part of Floyd County Zoning Ordinance Section 7.04 GA Base Commercial Zone may not designate more than 30% of the proposed 00:22:44
development per square footage for residential. 00:22:49
Therefore the applicant is requesting the base zone be changed to multi family. 00:22:55
A traffic impact study was conducted for the proposal and determined that the intersections impacted by the development. 00:23:01
Will continue to work at an acceptable level of service. 00:23:07
Technical Review Committee was held on December 18th, 2024 for this development. 00:23:17
Summary report was attached to your staff report. 00:23:23
The technical review committee provides. 00:23:27
Recommendations to the Planning Commission. 00:23:30
On that. 00:23:33
Are the utility providers. 00:23:34
Public Safety. Sheriff Fire. 00:23:37
School. 00:23:40
As well as county staff, storm water engineering and planning. 00:23:42
The reason? Staff finds that the rezoning of the subject property is consistent with the Floyd County Comprehensive Plan. 00:23:47
Because the Floyd County Comprehensive Plan identifies the area as a commercial growth area. 00:23:54
Proposed. 00:23:59
The mixed-use featuring a commercial element yours to the frontage. 00:24:00
Additionally, rezoning is consistent with smart growth principles identified in the plan. Specifically mixed land uses compact 00:24:04
building design. 00:24:08
Creating a range of housing opportunities, directing development towards existing communities and preferring. 00:24:12
And thus preserving open space, farmland, natural beauty, and critical environmental areas. 00:24:18
As this is an infill development. 00:24:23
The rezoning of the subject property is consistent with the. 00:24:27
Conditions of the character of the current structures in the. 00:24:30
And uses in the area. 00:24:34
Because the commercial use is in the front of the lot are consistent with the original general commercial zoning. 00:24:36
The multifamily uses our appropriate transitional uses between general commercial and urban residential uses. 00:24:42
Voting facade materials are brick and Hardy board. 00:24:48
The structures are within the height limits of the zoning ordinance. And there are. 00:24:52
There is another three story building in the vicinity that is the Chase Bank. 00:24:56
The rezoning of the subject property is necessary for the most desirable use of. 00:25:01
The land because. 00:25:06
The rezoning follows smart growth principles already noted. 00:25:08
It has also provided. 00:25:12
Additional housing identified as needed in the Purdue Housing Report the county had completed in 2020. 00:25:14
It is mixed-use infill in commercial growth area. 00:25:20
The rezoning of the subject property will not be interest to the values of other properties in the area because. 00:25:24
Commercial uses are consistent with the neighborhood commercial zoning. 00:25:30
Excuse me? 00:25:34
The general commercial zoning. 00:25:35
Inappropriate adjacent and residential urban zoning. 00:25:38
And uses the addition of the multifamily component. 00:25:41
Will support local business customer base. The development will increase the value of the lots itself and expected that positive 00:25:44
impacts on neighboring commercial lots. 00:25:48
Buffer yard. 00:25:53
Along adjacent residential lots is provided on the West. Additional buffering is recommended for the properties on the South. 00:25:54
The rezoning of the subject property will support responsible growth and development in the area. 00:26:03
Because rezoning follows the objectives of small smart growth outlined in the Floyd County Comprehensive Plan. 00:26:08
Higher development is directed towards existing infrastructure. 00:26:15
Provider letters indicate ability to serve and the development is identified. Commercial growth area. 00:26:18
It is an infill development staff has favorable recommendations for the reason. 00:26:24
Written commitments recommended would be buffer yard 2 standards met. 00:26:30
For all adjoining residents. 00:26:34
Drainage will meet Floyd County stormwater standards as approved by the Stormwater Board. 00:26:37
And if phased, lot 1 will be developed first in a schedule for completion of the project will be provided. 00:26:43
Onto the subdivision application. 00:26:51
I will not repeat the. 00:26:54
Outline of the. 00:26:58
Project. 00:26:59
On staff review, the Petitioner has provided compliant preliminary plan for the project, including preliminary plat. Petitioner 00:27:01
has provided certification that all drainage and environmental requirements will be complied with and that there are no known 00:27:06
outstanding issues concerning IDAM. 00:27:11
Geotechnical report is not required for the property and staff. The traffic study has been completed by strained associates. 00:27:17
In the phase one environmental is not required. 00:27:25
Lots meet the size and frontage standards of the zoning ordinance. 00:27:28
General, commercial and multifamily districts. 00:27:31
Knobs Landing Blvd. is proposed as a through St. between Tuscany and Schreiber Rd. Dimensions and layout. 00:27:35
Subdivision control ordinance requirements. 00:27:43
Multiple entrances from Schreiber Rd. Knobs Landing Blvd. in Tuscany Dr. is provided. 00:27:46
Sidewalks are provided. 00:27:52
Certification to meet county drainage and stormwater standards have been provided final approval of the drainage plan. 00:27:54
Will be required prior to secondary approval. 00:28:01
The petitioner has provided willingness to serve. Letters from Floyd Knobs Water, Georgetown. 00:28:05
Township Fire Protection District, Harrison RC, New Albany Wastewater Charter and AT&T. 00:28:09
The wastewater will be provided by New Albany Storm Water. 00:28:16
Our wastewater is not. 00:28:19
Staff recommendations are just that, the. 00:28:21
Final approval of drains stormwater plans be required prior to secondary improvement. 00:28:24
For the PUD application. 00:28:30
I'll go over the PUD process. 00:28:32
So part. 00:28:34
Planned unit development is a design special district that can be pursued by an applicant. The purpose of the planned unit 00:28:36
development is to courage the flexibility to develop or redevelop land in an effort to promote appropriate uses. 00:28:42
Maintain unique character features such as natural or historic resources. 00:28:49
Promote innovative design concepts. 00:28:53
It is also designed to facilitate the economies of scale in relationship to infrastructure, public services, encouraging field 00:28:56
development. 00:28:59
PUD process. 00:29:03
Petitioner meets with staff. 00:29:05
For a conceptual step. 00:29:07
Sketch playing and playing conference, which they did on. 00:29:09
October 23rd, 2024. 00:29:13
Petitioner then submits a detailed development plan for review. 00:29:16
And submits a PUD application for Employment Commission. 00:29:19
The Plan Commission can then. 00:29:23
Provide umm. 00:29:25
A recommendation to the county commissioners. 00:29:26
In a favor favorable recommendation. 00:29:29
An unfavorable recommendation or no recommendation? 00:29:32
The county commissioners will then review the rezoning petition within 90 days and may approve or disapprove the request. Upon 00:29:36
approval, the property is officially resumed. 00:29:41
The PUD will then return to the Planning Commission for secondary approval. 00:29:46
Of the detailed development plan. 00:29:50
No additional public hearing will be required. 00:29:52
Safra views of the pod. 00:29:56
But very significantly from the zoning. 00:29:58
In subdivision control ordinances in a few areas. 00:30:01
1st. 00:30:08
It is unclear the minimum. 00:30:09
Unit size of the units. 00:30:10
We have an 800 square foot. 00:30:13
Minimum. So I would just like. 00:30:15
The applicant provide that information. 00:30:17
Density. They're requesting approximately 20.9 dwellings per acre. 00:30:20
Our multi family standard is. 00:30:25
Currently 8 is the allowed maximum. 00:30:28
We do have several developments in the county. 00:30:31
That have. 00:30:34
19 to 20, that's not built. 00:30:35
And Gateway villages has about 15. 00:30:39
Dwelling units breaker. 00:30:41
Parking 2 1/2 spaces are required per dwelling unit. 00:30:44
They have provided 1.8 for lot 1 and 1.92 for lot 2. 00:30:48
And then the buffer yard. 00:30:55
South side of the property. 00:30:56
Would require. 00:30:59
Buffer Yard 2 standards. 00:31:00
The proposed land in the in. 00:31:03
Land uses in the PUD are. 00:31:06
Are not in conflict with the spirit and intent. 00:31:08
Of the comprehensive plan, surrounding land uses and zoning districts. 00:31:11
The comprehensive plan. 00:31:16
It shows that the area is a commercial growth area. High density should be directed towards adequate infrastructure and public 00:31:18
services. 00:31:21
Proposal can be served by all utility providers without expansion. 00:31:24
In multi family style density should consider mixed land uses which is studs. 00:31:29
Zoning and surrounding land uses. The proposal is currently in the general commercial district with residential urban. 00:31:34
General commercial adjacent. 00:31:40
The proposed blood does provide adequate public service, light, air traffic control, open and more common. 00:31:43
Space and recreation. 00:31:49
The proposal does include adequate services, as evidenced. 00:31:52
Service provider letters. 00:31:55
Proposal includes reasonable traffic circulation plan. 00:31:58
Traffic impact study has been conducted. 00:32:01
And the proposal provides recreational space in the form of a pool and outdoor games area. There's also green space within the 00:32:04
development. 00:32:07
The proposed PUD is compatible with adjacent properties and surrounding neighborhood. 00:32:12
Commercial use is consistent with general commercial uses in the Highlander point in the zoning of adjacent properties, 00:32:17
multifamily residential. 00:32:21
Is appropriate with mixed uses and should be buffered from adjacent. 00:32:24
Residential uses. 00:32:29
The proposed BUD will not interfere with the use or diminish the value of adjacent properties. 00:32:31
In surrounding neighborhood. 00:32:35
Improvements on the land are expected to have positive impacts on neighboring property values. 00:32:37
Mixed retail, commercial and multi family will not diminish the use of neighborhood properties with adequate public services 00:32:42
provided. 00:32:46
Appropriate offering is required to adjourn. 00:32:50
Residential properties. 00:32:53
HUD will not diminish the level of service for roadway systems in the vicinity. 00:32:55
As the traffic impact study. 00:33:00
Concluded. 00:33:03
The proposed PUD can be immediately and adequately served by the existing public facilities and services. 00:33:05
As evidenced by the. 00:33:11
Service letters. 00:33:13
The proposed POD does preserve natural and historic. 00:33:15
Resources to every extent possible. The existing cycles of single family structure used as a commercial office. 00:33:18
The site will be cleared and new plantings consistent with the zoning ordinance Landscaping will be installed. 00:33:24
There are no known historic resources on the site. 00:33:30
Proposed PUD will not be interest to the health, safety and general welfare. The proposed plot is consistent with planning 00:33:35
documents for this area. Adequate public infrastructure is available. 00:33:40
For the development as our public services. 00:33:46
Drainage will be approved by County Stormwater consistent with their requirements. Staff recommendations are favorable 00:33:49
recommendation with the following commitments and conditions. 00:33:53
Written commitments will be phased. Phase one will be Lot 1 funding or Vincents Road and the schedule for completion of all phases 00:33:59
will be provided. 00:34:03
To the Planning Commission. 00:34:07
Prior to secondary approval. 00:34:08
Provide additional screening of dumpster on lot 1 between dumpster and roadway. 00:34:11
Provide light at entrance locations where there are none and meet Buffer Yard 2 standards for adjoining residential use to the 00:34:16
South. 00:34:20
That is the staff report for these 4. 00:34:24
Applications. 00:34:27
All righty. Thanks, Nick. Any any questions on the board? 00:34:30
You have a question. 00:34:34
Nick, you indicated. 00:34:36
There that strange associates conducted a traffic study for the project and then an acceptable. 00:34:37
Loss or level of service was was found. Those law studies typically indicate like a grade between A and F Do you have any idea 00:34:42
what the grade was for the particular project? 00:34:47
B i.e. and beyond. 00:34:53
The the level of service indicated. 00:34:57
Which is. 00:35:01
Deemed acceptable as the current level of service. 00:35:03
So any other? 00:35:09
Any other questions? 00:35:11
For Nick. 00:35:14
And they if. 00:35:16
We had a TRC on this right, a technical review committee. 00:35:17
Can we explain just a little bit to the board? 00:35:20
What came out of that meeting? What's the purpose of that meeting? Yes, the tier the plans provided to the TRC were. 00:35:24
A little bit different than what we finally have here. 00:35:30
The alignment of the site had the bank on the opposite side on Tuscany Drive. 00:35:34
Dumpster was located closer to the roadway on Knox Landing or Knox Landing Blvd. 00:35:42
There were more multifamily units. 00:35:48
So the parking. 00:35:51
Ratios were. 00:35:53
Less. 00:35:55
And there was number buffer yard. 00:35:59
For the residential. 00:36:00
Properties to the West. So they didn't make all those modifications for this final application, OK. 00:36:02
All righty. 00:36:11
So they've already adjusted. 00:36:14
The original application, is that correct? 00:36:16
At the TRC. 00:36:19
Thank you. 00:36:21
Are any other questions for Nick? 00:36:22
OK. At this point, let me go through just a little bit of a housekeeping here. 00:36:24
Because of the sensitivity of this project and the number of. 00:36:29
Agenda items we have. 00:36:34
We're going to increase the time that we allow. 00:36:36
For the applicant to present his. 00:36:38
Project and then we're going to double the times. 00:36:43
That we have for people to speak in favor, to speak in opposition, and then we will then give the applicant 5 minutes to rebut 00:36:46
anything that was so said. So just let the board know that that's what we're going to do because of the. 00:36:52
The sensitivity of this project so. 00:36:58
If the applicant would like to come forward, state his name and address. 00:37:01
We appreciate it. 00:37:05
For the record, John Craft with the law firm of Young Lind Anderson Kraft, 126 W Spring Street in New Albany. 00:37:14
Appearing on behalf of the applicant. 00:37:21
Along with the engineer which would be Jason Copper White with Paul Primavera and Associates. 00:37:23
Jackson Theneman is with me as well from Phenomenon. 00:37:28
Group LLC. 00:37:32
And then likewise Daniel Moriarty. 00:37:34
Who has designed the? 00:37:36
Project from the standpoint of the architectural piece of that. 00:37:38
So ultimately. 00:37:42
Four of us will present. 00:37:44
I'll cover first of all, as indicated, there are four items before you this evening. 00:37:47
Two of which are rezoning. 00:37:51
Which means ultimately, those two rezoning issues come to you for a recommendation. 00:37:53
Not an approval tonight, but merely. 00:37:59
A request as it relates to those zoning requirements. 00:38:02
Going forward to the county commissioners with a favorable. 00:38:06
And unfavorable or no recommendation at all. 00:38:09
Under those two elements, and again, we'll talk a little bit about each one, but under each of those elements. 00:38:13
You have to pay due consideration and these are the same considerations the commissioners will look at in order to make a 00:38:20
determination. 00:38:23
On the passage of these two ordinances. 00:38:27
Primarily, Indiana Code 3674603 covers those five elements. 00:38:30
Those five elements deal with the Comprehensive Plan and. 00:38:35
You'll hear on a. 00:38:38
PowerPoint, you'll hear Mr. Copper Weight go through those issues with regards to compliance with the current comprehensive plan. 00:38:41
Current conditions and character of current structures and uses in each district. 00:38:48
The most desirable use for which land in each district is adapted. 00:38:53
Conservation of property values throughout the jurisdiction. 00:38:57
And responsible development and growth. 00:39:01
You've probably heard a number of items covered by Mr. Creepy when he spoke. 00:39:03
Pertaining to the staff report. 00:39:07
And this is a growth area in the county? 00:39:09
Certainly, again, Mr. Copper weight will cover that more fully. 00:39:12
The piece as it relates to. 00:39:16
The change from GC, which if you look at the current zoning ordinance in Floyd County, there are 91. 00:39:18
Uses that could be put there as a matter of right. 00:39:27
Including, uh. 00:39:30
Big box commercial. 00:39:31
Including smaller units, but it is a GC in their actual 91 uses that could be put there as a matter of right. 00:39:32
One of the things that you'll hear this evening is when Mr. Feenman looked at this project. 00:39:40
He looked at it from the standpoint of dealing with. 00:39:45
Walkability. 00:39:49
Specifically, individuals as well as commercial uses don't want to go in an area now just where they're putting a commercial use. 00:39:51
They want the possibility of residents that can use that commercial area and also look at the possibility of walking to and from 00:39:58
their residence to those commercial uses. 00:40:04
When we look at the issue from a GC to the MF. 00:40:10
The multifamily. 00:40:14
Under the terms of a normal change of zoning. 00:40:16
When taking it to an MF that would allow any type of. 00:40:19
Multifamily use on this property. 00:40:23
Provided it meets the development standards of the multifamily. 00:40:26
But the other piece of the rezoning request this evening? 00:40:29
Is taking that multifamily to a PUD. 00:40:33
And the purpose of a PUD first and foremost is to deal with mixed uses. 00:40:36
On a given property. 00:40:41
But most importantly to you as well as the county commissioners as well as the community. 00:40:43
When you take a. 00:40:48
Change to an MF that allows, as long as it meets the requirements, to go as deep and as dense as you desire to do on this 6 plus 00:40:50
acres. 00:40:54
But with the change to a planned unit development district. 00:40:59
What it requires, and you heard Mr. Creevy, again go through the process because the process is one of those that if both zoning 00:41:04
changes are forwarded to the commissioners with favorable recommendations and again the commissioners passed those. 00:41:11
That ultimately. 00:41:19
The PUD must then return to you as the Plan Commission for secondary review. 00:41:20
So it's not a matter that we're getting a blank check. 00:41:26
For a change to multifamily and do what we desire to do. 00:41:29
The project itself. And that's the 4th element you'll see this evening. 00:41:33
Is the development plan. 00:41:37
But under the terms of a planned unit development district. 00:41:39
It is established by way of ordinance. So ultimately. 00:41:42
Commissioners pass that ordinance. 00:41:45
They will then adopt specific. 00:41:48
Definitions of what you may do. 00:41:50
Much again as indicated. 00:41:53
We went to the. 00:41:55
Technical Review Committee on December 18th and walk through this project in order to make certain that what we would do and what 00:41:57
the development plan would cover would be in order that we can move forward with it. 00:42:03
So it's not a matter that by granting an MF. 00:42:08
In that instance, it's a matter of granting an MF with a planned unit development district. 00:42:12
It will then designate exactly what can be put on that parcel. 00:42:17
That will then be brought back to you as the Plan Commission for secondary review. 00:42:21
Once that secondary review is granted. 00:42:26
Then from that standpoint, what you end up with is a situation of having to abide. 00:42:30
By that plan that you see in front of you. 00:42:36
If that is the secondary approval plan. 00:42:39
And as a result of that, it allows you as well as the commissioners the ability. 00:42:41
To determine what planned documentation. 00:42:47
And you heard Mr. Creedy's report, some of those elements of what needs to be provided. 00:42:50
In order to move this forward. 00:42:55
Provided. 00:42:57
It changes from MF. 00:42:58
To the PUD. 00:43:00
Those two come together. 00:43:02
And again, those would be adopted by way of an ordinance by the county commissioners. 00:43:03
The other two pieces of it. 00:43:08
Provided. 00:43:10
Those two zoning changes come forward. Those other two pieces then become ministerial in nature. 00:43:12
And that is the subdivision. 00:43:19
And as long as the subdivision meets the requirements of the subdivision control ordinance. And again when listening to the report 00:43:21
of Mr. Privy, and I'm sure you've read it. 00:43:26
Specifically, uh. 00:43:31
We meet those requirements if in fact those two zoning changes come about. 00:43:32
The other piece of it. 00:43:37
Would be the development. 00:43:39
And once again, provided that development plan meets all of the elements as to setbacks and otherwise for this zoning district. 00:43:40
With the planned unit development district. 00:43:48
Then likewise, that is a ministerial action as well. 00:43:51
We're here this evening asking specifically that these 4 dockets. 00:43:55
Be approved. 00:43:59
Two of which were asking for favorable recommendation. 00:44:00
To the county commissioners. 00:44:04
Certainly your recommendation is what the county commissioners are going to listen to. 00:44:05
The county commissioners do not have to follow your recommendation. 00:44:10
But certainly from the standpoint it in my experience over 40 plus years. 00:44:14
Most times and most often, they will follow that recommendation. So we're here this evening asking for favorable recommendation 00:44:19
on. 00:44:23
The zoning change from. 00:44:27
Our two MF from. 00:44:30
The GC as well as asking that MF be limited by way of a PUD. 00:44:33
And ask that that likewise be forwarded. 00:44:39
With a favorable recommendation. 00:44:42
I'm gonna call on. 00:44:44
Jason to go through the elements with regards to the plan itself and touch on those elements under the comprehensive plan you 00:44:46
should have in front of you. If not, it'll be on the screen a power. 00:44:51
PowerPoint presentation regarding that. Thank you. 00:44:57
All right. Thank you. How are we doing on time? 00:45:01
How much? 00:45:08
Two, he had 20. He had total 20 minutes. 00:45:09
12. 00:45:13
He got 1212 minutes. I'll try to be quick. 00:45:15
There you go. 00:45:18
Good evening, Jason Copper. Wait again with Paul from Avera and Associates. 00:45:19
I'll try not to repeat anything. 00:45:22
Mr. Creeby said, or Mr. Kraft said, though there are probably slides that you repeat that information. 00:45:24
I'll try to gloss over those if I can. 00:45:28
Again, this is knobs landing mixed-use development. 00:45:30
Located at 5031 through 50. 00:45:33
53 Old Vincennes Rd. 00:45:35
The next slide, that's the aerial of the site. 00:45:38
I don't know that anyone's actually showing you that when they were talking, but it's the southwest quadrant of the intersection 00:45:41
of Shriver Rd. 00:45:43
And open sense you can see to the West as villas of Floyd Knobs. 00:45:46
To the South as a single family residence and the Highlands that's still developing NE is Highlander Point. 00:45:50
Just to the east of this Planning Commission may remember. 00:45:56
You've approved a bank development plan at that site. 00:45:59
Don't know when that will be developed, but it's coming. 00:46:02
This is the zoning map for the area. The red is general commercial GC. 00:46:04
The orange is residential urban. 00:46:08
Are you? 00:46:10
These are the four applications that have been talked about already. 00:46:12
This is an artist rendering that Mister Moriarty prepared for the site. 00:46:17
You can see. 00:46:21
Prize and help you, but there are two buildings on the north lot. 00:46:23
One building on the South with some amenities together on the north lot. 00:46:26
This is the. 00:46:31
My engineering version of his color rendering which shows a little bit more detail. It has turned 90°. Apologize for that. 00:46:32
But again, it's just a little bit more detailed. 00:46:40
So it is 6.4 acres. It will be. 00:46:43
The plan is to divide it into two lots. 00:46:46
Mr. Creepy went through the particulars. Just to highlight those, Building 1 is 7717 square foot of ground floor retail. 00:46:49
With a leasing office, clubhouse. 00:46:57
59 multifamily dwelling units, 21 of which are two-bedroom, 38 of which are one bedroom. 00:46:58
Google and other outdoor amenities are proposed there. 00:47:03
Building 2 is 66 multifamily dwelling units, 24 two-bedroom and 42 one bedroom. This that's on the South lot and building 3 is a 00:47:06
3600 square foot. 00:47:11
Bank Retail. 00:47:15
With a drive through. 00:47:17
These are the zoning. 00:47:20
Change characteristics that Mister Kraft talked about earlier. 00:47:22
So I took excerpts from your comprehensive plan that I that I felt showed that this site. 00:47:28
Met the requirements. 00:47:33
As Mr. Creeby said, smart growth, it's kind of buzzword throughout your comprehensive plan. 00:47:35
Smart Growth is a planning theory designed toward the efficient use of land, resources and existing urban infrastructure. 00:47:40
And your in your comp plan list. 00:47:45
10 smart growth principles, of which we probably meet 8. 00:47:48
Mixed land uses where appropriate. 00:47:52
Take advantage of compact building design. 00:47:54
Create a range of housing opportunities throughout the jurisdiction. 00:47:56
Create walkable communities. You'll see the pedestrian infrastructure we're proposing. 00:47:59
Preserve open space. Now you could say this is not preserving open space. 00:48:06
But what this does is it brings people to a developed area where there is infrastructure that allows remaining properties to the 00:48:09
county to remain. 00:48:13
To remain open and undeveloped. 00:48:17
Strengthen development Development toward existing communities. 00:48:20
Again at Highlander Point. 00:48:23
We're at Highlander Point. 00:48:25
And then? 00:48:28
Encourage community and stakeholder collaboration. 00:48:30
You have a very interactive process, as you know with TRC meetings. 00:48:33
We took that TRC meeting and those comments from that TRC meeting to heart. 00:48:36
And made very significant changes to the plan. 00:48:40
The original proposal was, I think, about 156 multifamily dwellings, dwelling units. 00:48:43
And a comparable number of retail. 00:48:48
The developer shrunk that to 125, split the bank out, per TRC comments. 00:48:51
Added the buffering we'll talk about. 00:48:55
So he's listening is the point. He's listening and adapting. 00:48:58
Theme places to live a lot again, a lot of those. 00:49:02
Objectives from the goals meet this this project. I can give you copies of this. 00:49:07
When we're finished. 00:49:12
Promoting locally grown and owned. 00:49:13
It is anticipated that a lot of these retail establishments will be local businesses, locally owned businesses. 00:49:16
We're thinking the bank is going to be a relatively small regional bank. 00:49:22
Not a necessarily a National Bank. 00:49:26
Then your comp plan says direct hire residential developments toward areas of the proximity to adequate infrastructure and public 00:49:30
services. 00:49:33
Where appropriate, higher density. 00:49:36
Patio homes. Multi family development should be directed toward established urban areas based on proximity to existing services 00:49:38
and density. 00:49:42
Multi family development should be limited to area to areas where they're again access to commercial. 00:49:45
Surrounded by utilities. 00:49:51
The comp plan designates the Highlander Point as a commercial growth area. 00:49:54
Everyone realizes that. 00:49:58
A commercial should be. 00:50:01
Targeted toward Highlander. The Highlander Point corridor specifically says that. 00:50:02
This is the Georgetown Township excerpt from the comp plan. 00:50:07
That that. 00:50:11
Dark dark box in the upper right hand corner is the location of this. 00:50:12
The comp plan for Georgetown mostly focuses on the Edwardsville. 00:50:16
Gateway and the Edwardsville Interchange because this site really is more closely related to the Lafayette Township. The east 00:50:20
boundary of This site is Lafayette Township. 00:50:25
So this is the Lafayette Township map. 00:50:30
Map with the box showing the area again. It shows that as an intense development area by your comp plan. 00:50:32
Future land use in Georgetown Township would be directed toward existing infrastructure. That's a theme throughout your comp plan. 00:50:40
I'll try and skip that. 00:50:44
Commercial again at. 00:50:49
And this is average for Gateway for Georgetown? 00:50:50
Same language in Lafayette even says similar to Georgetown. 00:50:53
And then future commercial will be located at Hallander Point. 00:50:57
Properties already zoned commercial, but we are. 00:51:00
Continuing to implement. 00:51:03
Commercial element. 00:51:04
This project. 00:51:06
Current conditions and structures. 00:51:07
Again, there there is quite a bit of development happening and that has happened around this area. 00:51:09
You have Highlander Point Commercial. 00:51:14
District East. 00:51:16
You have additional commercial just east of this with the gas station. 00:51:17
Williamsburg Station, the bank that's coming in. 00:51:21
This project, as Nick said, would. 00:51:25
It's a nice transition from. 00:51:28
Commercial. Intense commercial. 00:51:30
Through higher density residential to lower density, even though it's still your residential urban. 00:51:31
Zoning. 00:51:37
And then this is a rendering of the building which you've seen in the package. 00:51:38
It is a very similar to what you see right across the street. 00:51:42
So the subdivision it is 2 commercial lots. 00:51:49
Would be a new road connecting the stub and villas of Floyd Knobs to Schreiber. 00:51:51
And if the MF and PUD MF are approved, the subdivision would meet all your requirements. 00:51:56
John talked about what a PUD means. 00:52:06
So the PUD in this particular case also. 00:52:09
Satisfies the development plan. I'll mention that later, but keep in mind when I'm talking about these PUD plans, I'm also talking 00:52:12
about the development plan. 00:52:15
Again, this is the engineering. 00:52:19
Site plan to support the development plan and the PUD. 00:52:21
It does feature the three buildings. 00:52:25
Also, it features the amenities. There's a swimming pool plan on lot 1. 00:52:27
There's an outdoor kitchen and outdoor seating and the outdoor games area that Mister Creeby mentioned earlier. 00:52:32
As well as open space to the West. 00:52:37
That those facilities are intended to serve both. 00:52:40
Both Watts in the neighborhood. 00:52:44
Same parameters I listed earlier. 00:52:47
There are two entrances from Lot 11 onto the proposed road and one on to Tuscany. 00:52:50
There are three interests from Lot 2, one on to Shriver and two onto the proposed roadway. 00:52:55
There are pedestrian walks and crossings throughout the site. 00:53:00
One interesting feature of the site is that is that once the traffic signal is installed at Schreiber. 00:53:02
That has pedestrian crosswalks included as part of the project. 00:53:09
You'll be able to walk from villas of Floyd Knobs or the Highlands all the way to anywhere you want to go in Highlander Point. 00:53:12
It's going to, it's going to facilitate pedestrian access for that whole region. 00:53:18
Again, the amenities on Lot 1. 00:53:23
Parking. 00:53:26
Lot 1. We've allocated 50 spaces for the proposed retail bank. 00:53:28
That leaves 1100. 00:53:33
111 spaces for the multifamily which is 1.88. 00:53:35
Spaces per dwelling unit. 00:53:38
127 spaces on Lot 2. 00:53:40
Which? 00:53:43
Yields 1.92 spaces per dwelling unit. 00:53:44
Mr. Creeby mentioned that your ordinance requires 2.5 spaces per dwelling unit. It makes no distinction as to whether they're one 00:53:47
bedroom or two-bedroom. 00:53:51
I personally believe that's overparked. 00:53:55
I did pick up the. 00:53:58
Institute of Traffic Engineers Parking generation manual. 00:54:00
They indicate that retail is. 00:54:03
5.45 spaces per 1000 square foot of retail, which would be 6 about 62 spaces required. 00:54:07
One bedroom units are 1.38 spaces per unit. 00:54:13
And a two-bedroom unit is 2.08 spaces per unit. 00:54:17
Using a total requirement per ITE. 00:54:19
About 265 and we're providing 288. 00:54:22
And I can give you copies of this. 00:54:26
After the presentation. 00:54:27
Lot area. 00:54:30
So lot 1. 00:54:31
The the pool and the recreation area to me should be included in open space. 00:54:33
If you don't include it in open space. 00:54:37
Or if you we have 68.8% impervious area. 00:54:40
If you do include it as open space, we have 61.5. 00:54:44
The MF ordinance require it allows 65. 00:54:48
Lot 2 we have a 71.5. 00:54:52
Making an overall of 69.85. 00:54:55
Or if you exclude the right out the recreation area is 65.4 so very close to what MF? 00:54:58
Would otherwise allow. 00:55:04
We do have significant landscaping and as Mr. Crete. 00:55:06
We do meet the ordinance as far as plantings along the roadways. 00:55:09
Parking lot screening and parking islands with plantings. 00:55:13
And then we did add the buffer along the West side for bills of fluid knobs. 00:55:17
With a wall that is concrete. 00:55:22
With plantings behind it, which is specified as a type 2 buffer. 00:55:24
We did not do that along. 00:55:28
The South Side. 00:55:30
I spoke with Mr. Tieneman after we received Mr. Kibe staff report. He is willing to do that but he would like to make a change. 00:55:32
Previously, the wall was planned to be brick on both sides. 00:55:39
He spent a lot of time in Florida lately and they have products there that would be concrete walls with stucco. 00:55:42
On either side that are still very attractive. 00:55:48
And so. 00:55:51
He would extend this wall to be 300 feet. 00:55:52
Along the South line. 00:55:54
There's a Creek that runs from that wider island there. 00:55:56
We can. Once you get past that Creek, it really doesn't make sense to buffer that area. So he would extend the buffer the wall. 00:55:59
That extra 300 feet with the plantings and that would then meet the requirements of type 2. 00:56:05
That that about 70 foot stretch. 00:56:10
On the east side of the Creek would not, but we still have the plantings there. 00:56:12
And you can see that's the front yard of the neighbor. 00:56:16
It should be less intrusive to him at that area. 00:56:20
The lighting plan meets the standards of the ordinance. No no fixture is taller than 20 feet and it's all down lighting. 00:56:24
These are the proposed lighting fixtures. 00:56:31
Just so we're showing a unified. 00:56:33
Design The sign plan meets the requirements of the ordinance. There are two monument signs, one at Tuscany and one at Knox Lane 00:56:35
Knox Landing Blvd. at Schreiber. 00:56:41
And all the building signage would comply with the existing sign against. 00:56:46
Ordinance the building facades. It's an attractive building. It meets the state requirements of the Highlander Point Overlay 00:56:50
District. 00:56:53
Brick, stone and Hardy. 00:56:57
You've seen that. 00:56:59
This is a blow up of the building 1. 00:57:01
Rendering This is a blow up of the Building 2 rendering which is on the South lot. 00:57:04
And this is the the bank with building one in the background. 00:57:08
OK. So common concerns that we hear always traffic. I know you've heard it from the audience today. 00:57:15
I'm not sure how many people are aware, but the county is planning to install a traffic signal at Shriver and Old Vincennes. 00:57:20
That has been in the plan. They're also upgrading Open Olden Sins. 00:57:27
The traffic study indicates that. 00:57:30
The intersections as proposed in the design year for original traffic study will also operate an acceptable level. 00:57:33
With additional traffic from this proposed development. 00:57:38
Drainage Fluke County is the most stringent drainage requirements in the region. 00:57:41
We anticipate stormwater and underground detention facilities circled there in the light blue. 00:57:46
That that wider island that you saw is the discharge town. 00:57:52
And then the county had commissioned a study for this whole area back in 2021. 00:57:56
That showed if development continued in accordance with your stormwater ordinance, that things will get better overtime. 00:58:01
Questions. 00:58:09
OK, you didn't do bad. You missed about 15 seconds. Sorry about that. 00:58:11
I do have a question OK, any that's why any questions for Mr. 00:58:15
I'm a little unclear on your on your wall. 00:58:20
On your wall. 00:58:23
Are you leaving Brick at Tuscany? 00:58:25
Are you switching it wanting to switch it all to the stucco wall? 00:58:27
He would request that we could switch it all to the stucco wall. 00:58:32
Because of the additional length. 00:58:35
That's a request. 00:58:37
So when you're you're saying 300 feet. 00:58:38
This is the additional approximately 300 feet. 00:58:41
Cortana. 00:58:46
That's the landscape plan. This is the 300 feet you're talking about, correct? 00:58:48
It's it's this. 00:58:52
It's this area here. 00:58:53
Just that's that's turned, yes, just short of that wider island there. 00:58:56
You do show. 00:59:03
60 foot of a vinyl fence. 00:59:06
Oh. 00:59:09
That's for parking lot screening. 00:59:10
Your ordinance requires a three foot understand why is it there? 00:59:13
I'm just wondering if we should make it. 00:59:18
Match the rest of the ball. 00:59:20
Question something? 00:59:23
Instead of final, maybe 60 feet. 00:59:26
I, I'm going to, I'm going to step out on a limb and say, well, that's. 00:59:29
I just think it ought to match I guess. 00:59:34
No problem. 00:59:36
My first meeting SO. 00:59:39
Indulge me, what were you talking about the fence parking lot then? 00:59:44
There. 00:59:49
There's a little piece of fence right here. 00:59:51
That's supposed to be final. 00:59:54
You're in the part of our ordinance says you've got to screen the parking lot. 00:59:56
Correct. The ordinance requires any parking that faces a street or a neighbor has to be screened with three foot tall shrubs. 00:59:59
Over 3 foot tall fence. 01:00:06
So we can't fit shrubs in that area because it's tied up to the right of way. 01:00:08
So I was proposing a fence. 01:00:11
Battle. If it has to be a wall, I don't. 01:00:13
I think that's a yeah. 01:00:16
Yeah, understood. 01:00:18
Yeah, this may be a question for the developer, but in terms of the. 01:00:20
Target renter. 01:00:24
Are we looking at Class A facilities or what kind of amenities, what kind of people are we targeting? 01:00:26
To inhabit the buildings, what he's told me is granite countertops, you know, very nice facilities. I think he's targeting the 01:00:31
minimum rent to be 1500. 01:00:35
For a one bedroom. 01:00:40
Well, give me a. 01:00:42
All right. Anybody else? 01:00:46
I do have one question, the Connector Rd. that's that is proposed, will there be parking allowed on that road? No. OK. Will you 01:00:51
make sure that that's. 01:00:56
Either signage or somehow. 01:01:01
Make sure that doesn't happen because I could see that. 01:01:03
In advance I could get. 01:01:06
Crowded. 01:01:08
All right, go ahead next. 01:01:10
That will be a county. 01:01:14
Road County. 01:01:15
Oh, it's Canada. 01:01:17
They will. They'll. 01:01:19
It'll be dedicated to the county after it's called, so it's dedicated to the county. 01:01:21
OK, All right. Makes it so we'll let Frank make that decision. 01:01:26
No. 01:01:33
Oh, I meant to start out. 01:01:35
And say that. 01:01:40
I appreciate all the changes that were made, I think. 01:01:42
Several of the comments came from me about. 01:01:47
Moving the bank and. 01:01:49
All of that and I think it's a much improved plan over what was originally presented, so. 01:01:50
You reduce the number of apartments, you move the bank. 01:01:57
So I do like to plan much better than was originally submitted. 01:02:01
Great. Thank you. 01:02:05
All right. At this time, what we'd like to do. 01:02:07
And and just I'd like for everybody just be respectful. 01:02:10
And kind of hold your comments down, if you will. 01:02:13
We're going to we're going to open up 20 minute session. 01:02:16
For anybody that like to speak in favor of this project, come forward in favor. 01:02:19
In favor. 01:02:24
OK, state your name. 01:02:26
I'd like to thank them for all the wonderful. I need your name and address, I'm sorry. 01:02:30
OK. 01:02:35
And I have an 8047 Schreiber Rd. 01:02:36
But I am speaking in favor of this project. I respect the wonderful things he has provided our community. 01:02:39
So I will say thank you for that, but. 01:02:47
You know, we don't always build wonderful things. I'm gonna support something that's not so wonderful because I can think of. 01:02:50
1019 people you know since. 01:02:56
Friday night. 01:02:59
That think this is a bad idea. 01:03:00
So I think he'll need a little support. 01:03:02
I'll say that the idea that they didn't have enough room to put shrubbery behind the fence, it's laughable. 01:03:04
The idea that. 01:03:10
You know pedestrians will be playing in a roundabout. 01:03:11
That's going to be built in the future. 01:03:15
Is asinine. 01:03:17
I mean, I know you all might have agendas or might have your minds made-up, but this is a bad idea. This does not. 01:03:19
I don't know if you read the same comprehensive plan that I did the same, you know, Highlander point. 01:03:26
Gateway plan that I read, but I guess it's up for interpretation. 01:03:32
This is zoning change. 01:03:36
I don't believe. 01:03:38
That that zoning change fits the vision that you had been outlaid. 01:03:39
That I read about. 01:03:43
I can say that. 01:03:45
When I read about the Highlander point plan. 01:03:46
It was unfavorable to have multifamily housing in that area. That was the least. 01:03:49
The least liked proposal. 01:03:53
So what's changed? 01:03:55
We don't need the destination. 01:03:57
You know, if you have pedestrians, it's going to be even more chaos. 01:04:00
And it's already bad and terrible traffic. 01:04:04
I like this area. This is a great area. I think we are going to be. 01:04:07
Value is by allowing this to go through. 01:04:10
So I implore you, please. 01:04:13
Don't. 01:04:16
Don't let this happen. 01:04:17
This is a nice place. We should have nice places. People should aspire to be in nice places. We want to encourage home ownership, 01:04:20
not rental. OK, I'm going to cut you. Cut you off. 01:04:25
I think you've taken. 01:04:30
More in an opposition side than a favorable side, so. 01:04:32
But we'll. 01:04:35
We'll let you come back up and take the time away from the opposition if you want to. I'm just trying to be fair here. 01:04:36
Thank you very much. 01:04:42
This is in favor. 01:04:43
Please. 01:04:44
More than in the favor. 01:04:45
I'm saying your name and your address. Brian's are sweet. OK, I live in the house South. 01:04:47
If you bring the picture back up, just tell us your address please. 01:04:54
It's 5007 over in Saints Row, its original house. Go ahead. 01:04:57
Main road was my driveway. 01:05:02
OK. 01:05:05
If she can get rid of the thing up there. 01:05:06
You just go ahead with your comments please. What I'm trying to do is. 01:05:10
You're changing the. 01:05:14
The Creek you're putting. 01:05:15
660 inch pipes in. 01:05:18
It's going to come down to my driveway, which is a 24 inch. I'm going to have to stop you too. It sounds like you're in 01:05:22
opposition. 01:05:25
No, no, no, I'm not in opposition. 01:05:28
Get this on the record. 01:05:31
Why the engineers people were here and the developers. Do you have some positive to say about this project? I'm just trying to get 01:05:33
you to let me tell you what I need to do because I'm the guy on the side that's going to be effective. OK, I'm going to ask you to 01:05:39
come up when the opposition time comes up, if you don't mind, Sir. 01:05:45
You're talking, I'm just trying to explain to me what. 01:05:51
I want you to put in. 01:05:55
For the engineers to do, it's not going to be a. 01:05:57
You know, either would. 01:06:00
Yeah, it's just trying to tell you. Do you have something to say in favor of this petition? 01:06:01
Is the question yes or no? 01:06:07
If you do, say it. 01:06:10
I'm Either way, you need to sit down, Sir. Thank you very much for your time. 01:06:11
Winner, Let me one more. 01:06:16
Officer, would you please remove this man from this meeting? 01:06:18
All because I live next door. 01:06:25
I asked you to sit down three times, Sir. I'm sorry. 01:06:28
All right, one more, one more time. 01:06:34
Is there anybody that has anything that they like to say in favor of this project? Please come forward. 01:06:36
In favor. 01:06:42
Please umm. 01:06:44
Ladies and gentlemen, we have a process and please respect it. 01:06:47
We're just, we're doing a job up here. If we're trying to do our job, please let us do it. That's all I ask you. 01:06:50
We're going to give everybody the same respect. 01:06:56
That's all I ask you to do. 01:06:58
Anybody else in favor of this, please step forward. 01:07:00
OK. Is there any Sherry? 01:07:03
We got we got an off site location because. 01:07:07
Our elevator is broke down. Sherry, would you come forward and tell us whether we have somebody there once I speak in favor of 01:07:11
this? 01:07:14
No, you do not. OK. Thank you, Sherry. Appreciate. 01:07:19
OK at this time. 01:07:23
If you will start the. 01:07:26
Go ahead. Laram, Sarah. 01:07:27
I will. I will. 01:07:31
At this time we start the timer for the opposition And what I asked. 01:07:32
Hold on. 01:07:37
Please give us a minute here. 01:07:37
What I ask you to do is. 01:07:40
For the for the courtesy of people that want to speak. 01:07:42
If somebody already brought something up about. 01:07:45
The traffic. 01:07:47
Are something that drainage or something that? 01:07:49
Please don't repeat it, save room for somebody has something new to say but. 01:07:51
At that point this gentleman. 01:07:55
Right here, if you will. 01:07:57
Remember, there's people behind you, so give us give them time, please. And we do just so that everybody's on the same page. We do 01:07:59
have a time limit. It's 20 minutes. 01:08:03
That is for everyone that wishes to speak in opposition so. 01:08:07
It's 10 minutes normally on our PER. 01:08:12
For our requirements. 01:08:15
Well I think what they see is so on the screen it does say 10. That is because it only allows her to do 10. So when it hits 10 she 01:08:17
will reset it for another 10 so. 01:08:21
That is for everyone, not for each person. Yeah, we will get back to 20. It's just thank you. 01:08:26
My name is Bill Emerson. I live at 339 Custody Drive in the village of Floyd's Knobs. 01:08:33
We bought our. 01:08:39
Lot in 2020 and. 01:08:40
Don theme and build up. 01:08:43
House quality house that we wanted. 01:08:44
During our meeting with Mr. Theme and we asked what he would be building on the adjacent property. 01:08:47
Which we're talking about today. 01:08:53
He said. 01:08:55
Build a medical services building along old business ends and might build a senior community with possible assisted living 01:08:57
community. 01:09:00
On the rest of the acreage? 01:09:04
That sounded good to us. 01:09:06
We love living the village of Floyd's Knobs. 01:09:08
Walk me to our location for the convenience of having amenities that we wanted nearby. 01:09:11
I would much rather the Don Theman build what he suggested to us. 01:09:17
Rather than the. 01:09:22
I do not support the project as presented tonight. 01:09:25
I would really like to see. 01:09:29
Mr. Thieneman. 01:09:32
Complete the villas. 01:09:33
Rather than us having to continue to live in the construction. 01:09:35
Zone site. They're in Phillips. 01:09:39
I like the houses he builds, he does a great job. 01:09:44
But if you drove up into the villas or you drove over to the other. 01:09:47
Project over in Georgetown. 01:09:51
It's an unfinished project. 01:09:53
And and those of us who live there. 01:09:55
Are really held hostage? 01:09:58
By an unfinished project where we can't have our own homeowners association until Dawn finishes the project. 01:10:00
I really wish you all would put something in. 01:10:07
And your bylaws or whatever if a project is started. 01:10:10
Then it needs to be finished at some particular point. 01:10:15
Our development was not that large that it couldn't be finished. 01:10:19
And the and the other piece of that is. 01:10:23
The walkability. 01:10:25
We have sidewalks once our house is built. 01:10:27
But we have large amounts of space in our in our. 01:10:31
On Tuscany. On Milan. 01:10:34
That we have to walk in the street. 01:10:36
So it's a walkability neighborhood. 01:10:38
But Don hasn't finished the sidewalks. 01:10:41
That are that need to be finished they cross the line across Tuscany so anyway. 01:10:45
I do not agree with Mr. Cooperates to comment about. 01:10:52
This states that the rezoning would not be injurious to the value of the profit in the area. 01:10:56
Come on, when did you ever put apartments next to? 01:11:02
Houses and never lowered the property. 01:11:06
And I'd say the same thing there. 01:11:09
You put apartments next to houses, you lower the property. 01:11:11
I'm grateful that the original location of the bank. 01:11:16
Has been moved. I'm glad that the project is not as large as it once was. I appreciate that. 01:11:19
The change in the fence. 01:11:27
I want the masonry brick fence. 01:11:29
I'm with the masonry. 01:11:32
I don't want the stucco fence. I've seen them. Nice. 01:11:35
But what? 01:11:39
We have is. 01:11:40
I want the brick fence. 01:11:42
My biggest concern about the project. 01:11:46
Is. 01:11:49
The dumpsters. 01:11:50
One of them is right there at the entrance to Tuscany Drive. 01:11:52
Right by very first house on the left on Tuscany. 01:11:56
You've got a you've got a 24 foot dumpster corral. 01:12:01
And then right behind the winnings house back there on the second building be built. 01:12:05
Also is a large dumpster corral right behind those homes? 01:12:10
I don't want I don't know how often they pick up those dumpsters and apartments, whether that's once a week or. 01:12:16
Three times a week. 01:12:21
I just I don't want the. 01:12:23
This put the dumpsters. 01:12:25
Does your way? 01:12:27
Sir, you have to talk to us. You can't talk to anybody. I'm sorry. 01:12:32
Move the dumpsters. 01:12:42
Move the dump. 01:12:44
And if you move the dumpsters. 01:12:45
I can. I can probably live with it. 01:12:47
That I don't like where the dumpsters are at all for the people in the village of Floyd's Knobs. 01:12:49
So anyway, I would encourage you to make those changes before you vote tonight. 01:12:57
All right. Thank you, Bill. 01:13:01
All right, come forward. State your name and address for us, Sir. 01:13:03
10th Interest Property owner .740 N Luther Rd. I cannot think of anything that would cause more problems. 01:13:06
On old Vincennes Rd. in the traffic flow then this project right here. 01:13:13
It is time for the people to speak up. 01:13:18
We have a nightmare there, we all know it. 01:13:20
We all know it, the change in zoning. 01:13:24
Is wrong. 01:13:26
Is wrong. Saying pedestrian traffic can crossover Vincent's road is crazy. 01:13:28
Somebody's gonna die. 01:13:33
I drive that bus through there twice a day and it is a nightmare. 01:13:35
Now I need that. 01:13:39
Were certified letters. 01:13:40
Sent out for this yet? 01:13:42
For affected property owners in here. 01:13:44
No, we're just OK. 01:13:46
You want that? You want me to answer that? 01:13:48
Yeah, go ahead. OK. Have they been sent out? 01:13:50
Yes, they have. 01:13:53
Yes. 01:13:55
Just us. 01:13:57
Personally, pardon me, was there a list? The reason I ask is this in the past? 01:13:59
You see, they were sent out. I can take the past 10 years. 01:14:04
I was always included because if you go too deep on that. 01:14:07
Especially because of the drainage problem. 01:14:11
I want to see. 01:14:14
Really tough drainage plan. 01:14:16
I want to see it. 01:14:19
You held it up. 01:14:21
On the on the. 01:14:22
Project before over there. 01:14:25
The Highlands. 01:14:27
And this here, I catch 8, I catch 90% of this. You all know that everybody knows. 01:14:29
But I don't want to see a change in zoning here. 01:14:34
We have enough problems on Old Vincent's Road. 01:14:37
Here's a great example very quickly. 01:14:41
22 Prosser buses leave Floyd Central at. 01:14:44
7:30. 01:14:48
In the morning. 01:14:50
They have to fight to get the OH Vincent Rd. They have to fight to get 150 interchange. By the time they get them through 01:14:52
Charlestown Road and down to Prosser, it's time to bring them home. Education is slipping in this county because of them. 01:14:59
Things like that. Right now I asked for a. 01:15:06
Negative. 01:15:09
Recommendation for this? 01:15:11
No more traffic. 01:15:12
No more building in that area. 01:15:15
Thank you, Mr. 01:15:16
Your name and address please. 01:15:21
Names Andrew Gromac. I live at 8042 Tribal Rd. in the islands UMM. 01:15:23
Evening Commission Board, Real quick, I have a question for you. I just moved here from Arizona in August. 01:15:28
Are you guys elected officials? 01:15:34
Or just how does that work? Everybody at this table is appointed except. 01:15:36
Point on this board. 01:15:42
On this board is appointed OK, OK, so you're not this general right here you want to buy the he's appointed. 01:15:43
OK. Yes, Sir. Well, the reason I bring that up is. 01:15:49
As of. 01:15:51
Just before this meeting, if you go to Change.org, there is 1017 signatures. 01:15:52
From this area that are opposed to this development plan. 01:15:58
Coming from Arizona, where I live is the 4th largest metropolitan area in the United States right now. 01:16:04
I moved in an area that was. 01:16:09
Semi rural. 01:16:11
And watch apartment buildings go up around my my house year after year after year. Over 15 years went from non. 01:16:12
No crime at all. 01:16:20
To prime rampant throughout my area. 01:16:21
The average rent in my neighborhood in the Highlands, I'd have to say is anywhere from. 01:16:25
Mortgage is 2500 to mine is just a little over 3000. 01:16:30
When you're putting. 01:16:34
Apartments up here. 01:16:36
These people don't have any skin in the game. They don't own the area that will own their apartments. They don't have any 01:16:38
incentive to take care of the area. 01:16:41
So besides the traffic, that's already been discussed. 01:16:45
And everything else. 01:16:48
I'm politely asking. 01:16:49
The board to vote nay on this as well. 01:16:51
I'm telling you guys that. 01:16:54
The Knobs area moved in here because it's rural enough. 01:16:55
Where it's semi big city but not big city. You start doing this, the domino effect is going to happen and I promise you guys 01:16:58
you're not going to like the outcome. 01:17:02
Thank you. Thank you, Sir. 01:17:05
Restate your name and address for the address. 01:17:11
It's a good thing we're all here right now, because we'd all be stuck at the light at 1:50 for another 5 or 6 more turns if we 01:17:15
were all heading home right now. 01:17:20
I don't trust a word that the theemans say. If anybody knows what has happened, up it. 01:17:25
Heritage Springs neighborhood that he was able to swindle a Dollar General and duplexes. 01:17:30
After his plans already went through. 01:17:35
I know the neighborhood. 01:17:38
Residents tried to fight him on that and somehow he had wording that. 01:17:39
Was able to get through and so that. 01:17:43
Didn't workout well for them. 01:17:45
I have more concern with my schools. 01:17:47
My kids and I have all gone through Naomi Blue County Schools. We had the largest middle school in the state of Indiana, which is 01:17:50
not a record I would like to hold. 01:17:54
Because it's way too many kids. 01:17:59
There's not a cap size on classrooms in the state of Indiana, which is also a problem to me because I'm pretty sure the fire 01:18:02
department should have one. 01:18:05
But you putting in all of these? 01:18:10
Residential apartments is going to just. 01:18:12
Ruin. I asked. 01:18:16
Ruin the class sizes for one. I mean, the teachers are already capped, they can't handle anymore. 01:18:18
The kids can't get through lunch lines. 01:18:23
Because they are in the longest lunch line ever, they can't sit there and eat. Your kids will come home and tell you that they 01:18:25
didn't get to eat lunch today because the line was so long. The buses are so full. 01:18:31
You've been into JC or tried to get something at the pharmacy. You're in a 40 minute line trying to cash out. 01:18:38
And get your prescriptions picked up because the grocery store can't handle the population that's already there. 01:18:44
So it's not just about the traffic, it's about the schools, it's about the community that we've tried to keep. 01:18:50
And businesses maybe would be OK in that space. 01:18:57
But that many apartments is just a ridiculous amount of people moving into our area. 01:19:01
And you can say you did a traffic study. 01:19:07
I don't believe it at all. 01:19:10
And then there's word that you're not going to let they're going to change the traffic pattern to where you can't go straight 01:19:11
across Walgreens. 01:19:15
Across 150 that they're going to change it to turn and go up. 01:19:20
To your girls Rd. up to 1 old Vincennes the other way and have to try. 01:19:23
Turn around. That makes no sense, but I heard that today from Qatar construction people. 01:19:27
So. 01:19:32
Obviously not in favor of this and I think more. 01:19:34
My kids school. 01:19:37
Than anything at this point. 01:19:38
Thank you. Thank you, Taylor. 01:19:40
I am speaking in the proper time now. My name is Aaron Jones, 8047 Trevor Rd. 01:19:47
There are individuals that approach me that have been unable to sign this petition for one reason or another, whether they do not 01:19:53
have. 01:19:56
This dude or did not want to, but similar number here. 01:19:59
So I just want to state that. 01:20:02
But I'll say that. 01:20:04
From where I where I moved from? 01:20:05
We are very familiar with this issue. 01:20:07
I worked very hard to be here. 01:20:09
I did my research. I looked at the zoning. I looked at hydrology. I looked at traffic studies. I studied. 01:20:12
I believed in this community. 01:20:18
I truly did. I wanted to be here. I chose to be here. 01:20:19
I worked my **** off to be. 01:20:22
So my family would happen. 01:20:24
Access to better opportunities than I did. 01:20:25
Coming from Jefferson County, they built. 01:20:28
This low income, luxury whatever apartments everywhere around me within the South end of Louisville. 01:20:30
And you can see how well that's going for them. 01:20:35
And how the problems that they have. And I ask you, do you want to be like Louisville? I have faith in you all. 01:20:37
I feel like we can be better than Louisville. I'm not saying we are better, I'm just saying that. 01:20:43
Our government. 01:20:46
Can work better than rules because we can all see how the government is working. We do not want to be like Louisville. I am a 01:20:47
refugee. 01:20:50
I literally. 01:20:54
Don't want to be back right where I was. 01:20:55
And once this goes through, it's gonna set precedent work to keep happening and we do not want to devalue our area, whether that 01:20:58
be New Albany here there. 01:21:02
We have something beautiful that works. We can make it work. 01:21:06
But if we. 01:21:10
Changing areas that don't need changing. 01:21:11
In ways that. 01:21:13
We don't support. 01:21:14
It doesn't make sense. 01:21:15
He could put this anywhere. This is 6 acres. There are other parcels. 01:21:17
And this is zoned. 01:21:21
In a way that does not support this. 01:21:23
So. 01:21:25
I don't know why this is an argument. 01:21:26
I know he has every right. I think I believe in the free market. I only tell him he can't tell what he wants to. 01:21:28
But I believe in the zoning. That's why I bought my house. 01:21:32
It's commercial. I don't have to worry about this. 01:21:35
But now I'm in the same boat. 01:21:38
That's just. 01:21:40
I'm sorry that is. 01:21:41
It is sickening to me. 01:21:43
I'm Scott Sugar, I live at 6378 old Vincennes Rd. 01:21:52
I retired up here from the Army as a engineer officer. 01:21:57
I am going to touch on a little bit of what some of the other people. 01:22:01
And spoke about. 01:22:04
But really what I'm going to do is I'm going to ask some questions that I think every. 01:22:06
One for the traffic study. 01:22:11
Everyone that drives that area goes through those intersections. 01:22:13
At 1:50 no Vincents. 01:22:16
They know what chaos it is at certain times of day. 01:22:18
For a lot of people it is a stressful. 01:22:21
Event just going through. 01:22:23
That intersection. 01:22:25
Making it past Highlander Point headed down to the school. 01:22:27
The other thing I want everybody. 01:22:30
School buses go through there every day. 01:22:32
And. 01:22:37
Everybody who has a student down there at Highland Hills. 01:22:39
Or at Void Central. 01:22:42
Every day we get calls about the school bus situation. 01:22:44
Routes canceled. 01:22:48
This and. 01:22:49
And it's usually two to three a day, honestly. 01:22:50
So that's one challenge. 01:22:52
And this will impact. 01:22:54
The challenges that. 01:22:56
The Floyd County school system has. 01:22:58
With uh. 01:23:00
School traffic, School bus traffic, getting kids to school sometimes. 01:23:01
It's a safety concern. 01:23:05
The question I have is with that traffic study. 01:23:07
Did they account in that traffic study for all the other construction that's going to be going on? 01:23:10
Up just north of. 01:23:15
The JC. 01:23:17
Because. 01:23:21
You put this in, it's already going to overtax. 01:23:23
A stressful area right there. 01:23:27
That intersection. 01:23:29
Put even more construction in if there's already plans. 01:23:30
Multi Housing. 01:23:34
North of the JC? What kind of impact? 01:23:36
And a half of that intersection. 01:23:38
When we put the stop light in there. 01:23:41
That's already going to happen. 01:23:44
Act regardless of where you put this, intersect this. 01:23:46
Complex in there or not, it's already going to change the dynamic of that in the flow. 01:23:49
Off that intersection area and it's going to make more challenge to get through. 01:23:54
I think it's a bad idea. 01:23:59
To put. 01:24:02
This specific. 01:24:03
The housing. 01:24:07
And have this many people in this area. 01:24:09
Just simply because it's. 01:24:13
Challenges it's going to have on those intersections. 01:24:14
And I know. 01:24:18
You know, we all look at growth in the area. 01:24:19
We know what's coming. 01:24:21
But we've got to fix the plan for it. 01:24:23
I don't think that this meets the test as far as effectively. 01:24:26
That's just my thank you. 01:24:32
My name is Clyde Harrelson. I live off of Buck Creek, so I'm a. 01:24:39
Couple miles from the place. 01:24:42
But I shot that area. I shot the bank. 01:24:44
Why do we need apartments in an area? 01:24:47
That has no apartments in it whatsoever. 01:24:50
And my main complaint that you all could use or the main complaint you could use is the parking. 01:24:52
Who has 1.8 vehicles in a home? 01:24:57
They're going to have two-bedroom apartments in there, 45 of them. 01:25:00
They'll have at least two cars, if not 3. 01:25:04
We went from three cars to two. 01:25:07
Just recently, but prior to that, we've always had three vehicles in our family. 01:25:09
And I think for no other reason, the parking. 01:25:13
Should turn this down if they put in a bank where there's a. 01:25:16
Three banks across the street. 01:25:19
Why do we need another bank here? 01:25:21
They're just they don't want to make the parking. 01:25:24
Fit that place because they're not going to make as much money. 01:25:26
But if they need to drop that another 50. 01:25:30
Units just to make the parking fee. 01:25:33
Clyde, sorry, before you leave, what's your address please? 01:25:36
4059 Tanglewood Dr. 01:25:39
South of Buck Creek. 01:25:41
All right. Thank you. Glad. 01:25:43
OK, great. Ladies first. 01:25:46
Theresa Temple, 3 to 5 Tuscany Drive. 01:25:49
Boys knobs. 01:25:52
You turn down Don's. 01:25:55
Approval for apartment staff in 2014, did you not? 01:25:57
And he offered. 01:26:00
To build our homes. 01:26:02
55 and older. 01:26:03
Didn't workout. 01:26:05
Now it's all families, which is fine. 01:26:06
They're supposed to be single family dwellings. Ends up being. 01:26:08
One family that has three families living in it. 01:26:12
And then the drainage. 01:26:15
Back behind where you got. 01:26:16
The 301 start with 301. 01:26:19
All the way down past where Donnie lives because he lives in our subdivision. 01:26:22
All that drainage back there, their yards are all wet all the time. 01:26:26
They're never, they're never dry. 01:26:30
Florence Hampton had to pick up. 01:26:32
All her flips. 01:26:34
Stuff in the backyard because it wouldn't have them and stick or grow. 01:26:36
Anyway, you're turning down in 2014 for apartments. 01:26:39
Turning down again, I like Donnie. 01:26:41
He builds a really good homes. 01:26:44
In our subdivision. 01:26:46
And he hasn't finished what he needs to do. 01:26:48
And we know that the grocery store will have a small JC store if you all well know. 01:26:50
Now it can't. It can't accommodate all these people. 01:26:55
You know. 01:26:58
Make a strip mall like he promised. He said he was going to do our a medical stability or something to that effect. But apartments 01:26:59
are only going to cause more crime. You know, one of the things the Floyd County Sheriff's told me. 01:27:04
That our subdivision was one of the safest subdivisions. 01:27:09
Because Tuscany draft. 01:27:13
Was one way in and one way out. 01:27:14
Do you not agree with that? 01:27:17
And now you're getting. 01:27:19
All these intersections. 01:27:20
Criminals are coming across the bridge. 01:27:22
Coming in all of our subdivisions. 01:27:24
Because they've got all these little exits to go through. 01:27:26
Yeah, I'm not right. 01:27:29
I mean, it's true. 01:27:31
And we've had several cars broken into even in our subject. 01:27:32
Donnie's head stuff stolen from his subdivision, but. 01:27:35
You know, you just can't keep building all this. 01:27:39
Apartments and it's just gonna bring our. 01:27:41
Our values down. 01:27:44
And we don't want to. We just don't want it. 01:27:45
All right. Thank you. 01:27:47
We got we got a minute left. Go ahead, Sir. 01:27:52
My name is Spencer Worth and I live at 8040 Schriever. 01:27:54
You don't have to. 01:27:57
Forgive me for my quick talk, my quick speaking. 01:27:58
I agree with many of the points brought up by those behind me. 01:28:01
But one thing that I feel like hasn't been brought up is, or at least expounded upon, is the parking. 01:28:04
So if if the parking is not enough is not 2 1/2 per unit which my wife and I. 01:28:09
Have never had less than two cars. 01:28:15
Since we've been married. 01:28:17
Where are these industry cars going to go? 01:28:18
They're gonna be parking in these neighborhoods next door. 01:28:20
And people are that we don't know people who ties the community. 01:28:22
Are we walking through our neighborhoods back and forth? 01:28:26
And we have no recourse whatsoever. 01:28:28
Thank you. 01:28:30
Thank you. 01:28:31
All right, that closes this this portion if the applicant would like to come up. 01:28:34
And rebut what was spoken about. 01:28:39
You've got 5 minutes. 01:28:44
I'll speak very quickly. Just a couple things to deal with. I'm sorry, just a second. 01:28:47
Make sure nobody. 01:28:53
Yeah, we got opened up for down. Sorry. We just need to make sure to wait downstairs because the elevators out. 01:28:54
Do we have anybody downstairs? 01:29:00
In opposition? No, Sir. All right. Thank you. No, Sir. 01:29:02
Now you go. Thank you. Very, very quickly, a couple things that Mister Emerson brought up and I think it's important to address 1 01:29:06
primarily deals with. 01:29:11
The issue pertaining to. 01:29:17
Sidewalks, things of that nature and homeowners association keep in mind under the terms of the restrictive covenants with govern 01:29:19
that. 01:29:23
Homeowners association is not going to be formed till the last light sells. That's in their restrictions. The other piece of it 01:29:28
tends to be there is a non remonstrance clause in each of their subdivision restrictions specifically indicates that they would 01:29:32
not. 01:29:37
Opposed any type of development that Mister Athena would do on adjacent property. 01:29:42
Please let let him speak. It's unclear. 01:29:51
And there is a non remonstrance clause in that and they all took title subject to that. 01:29:53
A couple other items I think are important. Dealing with one gentleman that said he just moved up there, he moved into the 01:29:58
Highlands, which is the brand new subdivision, residential and he wanted rural. So again, I take a little exception to that. 01:30:05
The other piece that I think is important is. 01:30:12
The wide Shriver Road and the issue with regards to the traffic study. 01:30:15
It was done, and Mr. Copper Weight will probably talk about this as well, but it was done in anticipation of all of those. 01:30:19
Existing. 01:30:26
Developments as well as those that are already on the books as well as looking at this. So it's not a matter that they forgot 01:30:28
something. All of those developments were taken into consideration when they did that. 01:30:34
I'll let Jason speak on several of the other issues, but again, keep in mind that the restrictive governance primarily deal with 01:30:40
when that homeowners association is turned over and likewise when the sidewalks are finished when all of them lots of. 01:30:46
I do want to hit on the traffic study. Number one. It used to be that the developer would hire a traffic engineer to do the 01:30:55
traffic study. That is no longer the case. It is the county that hires the traffic engineer. So the developer has no influence 01:31:00
over the over the traffic study or the traffic engineer. 01:31:05
When they did their study at that I reviewed they did take into account all of the. 01:31:11
There's Gray woods just to the north of Highlander Point. There's a there was a patio home. 01:31:15
There were some proposals that were across Open Sins Rd. 01:31:21
There were some other things going on in the air. They took all that into account. 01:31:25
And of course, the traffic study reflects that the light is in place. 01:31:28
The lights not in place today. 01:31:31
We acknowledge that there are traffic issues there today. 01:31:33
But when the county finishes constructing that light, it's going to be a whole lot better, and the traffic study shows that. 01:31:36
Regarding drainage, I touched on that already. 01:31:45
Again, you have the most strict drainage ordinance in the region. 01:31:48
I think that's it, unless you have any questions. 01:31:52
Oh, wait, one more thing. I'm sorry. 01:31:57
Under the general commercial zone, your maximum impervious area is 70%. 01:31:59
Under the MF at 65%. 01:32:04
Under our PUD plan, it is less than 70%. 01:32:06
So we're going to be better on drainage just as a baseline. 01:32:09
Yeah, last individual be Daniel Moriarty. Daniel did the. 01:32:13
Project the design on it. Likewise, he's going to address some of the issues pertaining to the very same project that he's done 01:32:18
throughout Indianapolis area as well as other parts of the state. 01:32:23
State your name and address please. 01:32:28
3628. 01:32:30
Place in Carmel. 01:32:32
And obviously I'm not local so I can't speak to traffic issues and things are going on but. 01:32:33
I will say they do a lot of these projects around the. 01:32:39
Right bargains, though. 01:32:41
Westville. 01:32:42
South Bend, Fort Wayne, Bluffton. 01:32:44
All all around the state. 01:32:47
Always the same issues. 01:32:49
But the things I consistently see. 01:32:50
Number ones, we said traffic. 01:32:53
This there's. 01:32:55
Things are gonna happen. 01:32:56
This ground, regardless of what happens, time, right, something is going to be built by right. 01:32:57
That's not going to stop the traffic. 01:33:02
No matter what it is, it's gonna. 01:33:04
So if there's traffic issues in the area. 01:33:06
Those who are not my opinion, not the responsibility of this landowner to solve the. 01:33:08
For the county. 01:33:14
I mean that this developed something happening on this property. 01:33:15
Is something that. 01:33:19
Just. 01:33:21
Regardless of what it is, they're still going to be, it sounds like. 01:33:22
I'm not here for everybody. The issues. 01:33:25
So that was one thing. Secondly, I've got six kids, all six of living apartments. 01:33:28
Only once been arrested. 01:33:32
He lives at home with me right now. 01:33:33
So, umm. 01:33:35
There's no. 01:33:36
Evidence, at least in it. 01:33:37
Brand new development. This is a very high quality development and again I was working with a lot of people around the state. 01:33:39
The one thing about that the ambulance has been very refreshing. 01:33:45
There's a level of quality that they brought to this development. 01:33:48
Is very much higher. 01:33:51
Than what I hear from. 01:33:52
Every other builder on the state. 01:33:54
I'm not, I'm not just saying. 01:33:55
That's true. So. 01:33:57
So what happens? 01:33:58
Rent levels are such. 01:33:59
That if you want to say. 01:34:01
At least, and I'm sure some people know a lot better than I do, but I don't believe that just. 01:34:03
Those higher rent values necessarily bring crime with them. 01:34:07
The other thing is the missing middle missing gap. 01:34:12
For someone said there's no apartments in the area. 01:34:14
Well, kids need apartments. Younger people need apartments to make the transition from school where they had. 01:34:17
Ones to eventually have. 01:34:23
And if you don't have that high quality piece within your community? 01:34:25
Again, just watching it elsewhere. 01:34:30
That's that's it. That's. 01:34:32
Thank you very much. 01:34:35
Thank you. 01:34:36
No, Sir, you can't. I'm sorry. 01:34:40
I don't make the rules I thought. I try to follow them, Sir. 01:34:43
OK. 01:34:47
At that point, we're done with the petitions rebuttal. At this time, we're looking for ballots. 01:34:49
Unless you all have any questions. Unless you have any questions. 01:34:57
Questions. 01:35:00
Today, understand what our information is as far as. 01:35:03
Go ahead. I'd just like to make a couple notes. I know there was concern that they did not receive certified mail. 01:35:14
The the requirement for that is 2 lots. 01:35:21
Adjacent. 01:35:24
From the project site, so if you did not receive the mail. 01:35:25
Within 22 lots of that site. 01:35:31
It was sent. 01:35:34
We do have the the green cards to verify that. 01:35:35
Regarding the traffic pattern that was brought up. 01:35:39
In dot controls the old Vincennes at 150 intersection and they do have plans to. 01:35:43
With projects to correct the issue at that. 01:35:50
That's about $7,000,000 I think what the project came in the. 01:35:54
Schreiber Road and Old Vincent's light construction is set to start. 01:36:00
Beginning of March for that project. 01:36:05
And. 01:36:09
The traffic study does account for all the other developments proposed in the area. 01:36:11
The sheriff was a part of the TRC meeting. 01:36:17
And noted that he had no concerns with public safety standpoint from this project. 01:36:20
All right. Does anybody have any other questions for Nick, please? 01:36:26
Hold it. 01:36:31
No. 01:36:34
There is a process that they are following. 01:36:36
Go ahead, Nick. 01:36:40
No, I had a question if Nick could also elaborate to. 01:36:42
To the audience there. 01:36:46
That there's also projects. 01:36:50
On the table right now. 01:36:52
Right behind Jacques and a light that's going in on 150 between Luther and. 01:36:55
Open Sense. 01:37:02
You're gonna, you're just gonna stop. As soon as you come off the Interstate, you're gonna stop. 01:37:04
123. 01:37:09
4-5. 01:37:12
Six times between there and Napleton Rd. 01:37:13
Well. 01:37:21
They're working on. 01:37:22
It's it's happening right now. There is a. 01:37:23
Study. 01:37:27
We have submitted an RFP for preliminary engineering for a light between. 01:37:28
Lutheran old consens for a connection. 01:37:34
To the Highlander Point area in there. 01:37:37
And one final note. 01:37:41
This property is currently zoned General Commercial. 01:37:42
Traffic for general commercial uses. 01:37:46
Are typically higher than. 01:37:49
Multifamily or any other residential use. 01:37:51
So. 01:37:54
What would be allowed by right? 01:37:55
Could likely have a greater impact on the traffic than what this proposal would suggest. 01:37:57
Right. 01:38:03
All right, all right. 01:38:05
May have to ask people to just. 01:38:08
All right. At this time, no other board questions. 01:38:16
OK. 01:38:20
Nick, you want to? 01:38:22
Nick, you want you want to just go through the process just one more time on the agenda items as far as. 01:38:27
Which one of these items is? 01:38:33
The options of the board so they. 01:38:36
Clearly understand so the rezoning requests in the PUD rezone. 01:38:38
Our recommendations to the. 01:38:43
County commissioners. 01:38:46
So that just sorry, I want to make sure. I think they want a little direction too. So that would be your docket item ending in O2. 01:38:48
And that's the rezone. 01:38:54
And your docket item ending in 04 is your put correct? 01:38:56
Go ahead. And 03 is the major subdivision. 01:39:01
Huh. And then docket item 05 is the detailed development plan. 01:39:04
Associated with the. 01:39:08
OK. 01:39:10
OK, everybody. 01:39:12
Claire So in, two in. 01:39:14
For both favorable, unfavorable or no recommendation. 01:39:16
And then the other two ending in three and five would be granting or denying. 01:39:21
Any questions on those and? 01:39:28
One ballot at a time. So you're going to start with the O2, start with O2. 01:39:30
All right, we need a ballot from somebody, please. Docket FC01-25-02, Petitioner, theme and group. 01:39:34
Decision. 01:39:41
After careful review, the Floyd County Planning Commission finds that one. 01:39:42
Rezoning of subject property is consistent with Floyd County Comprehensive Plan. 01:39:47
Because the Conflict County Comprehensive Plan identifies the area. 01:39:52
As commercial growth area. 01:39:55
Rose planned unit development will be. 01:39:57
Mixed-use featuring a commercial element nearest to Old Vincent's Road. 01:40:00
Additionally, rezoning is consistent with. 01:40:05
Smart growth principles identified in the pan. 01:40:07
Specifically, mixed land uses compact building design. 01:40:10
Creating a range of housing opportunities. 01:40:13
Directing development towards existing communities and preserving open space, farmland, natural beauty and critical environment 01:40:16
areas. 01:40:19
As this is an infill development. 01:40:23
#2. 01:40:25
The rezoning of subject property is consistent with the current conditions. 01:40:27
And the character of the current structures and uses in the area because commercial uses. 01:40:30
At the front of the. 01:40:35
The lot are consistent with the original general commercial zoning. 01:40:36
The multiplication. 01:40:40
The multifamily uses are appropriate. 01:40:43
Transitional uses between general commercial and urban residential uses. 01:40:46
Building facade materials are to be brick and Hardy board. 01:40:51
Structures are within the height limits. 01:40:54
Of the Flower County zoning ordinance. 01:40:56
And there there is another three story building in the vicinity. 01:40:59
#3 The rezoning of subject property is necessary for the most desirable use of the land. 01:41:03
Because the rezoning follows smart growth principles already noted. 01:41:08
It also provides additional housing identified as needed in the Purdue Housing Report. 01:41:12
The county had completed in 2020. 01:41:17
Is a mixed-use infill development. 01:41:19
In the commercial growth area? 01:41:22
#4 the rezoning of subject property. 01:41:23
Will not be interest to the value of other properties in the area. 01:41:26
Because commercial uses are consistent with general commercial zoning and appropriate adjacent to residential urban zoning and 01:41:30
uses. 01:41:33
The addition of a multi family component will support local business customer base. 01:41:37
The development will increase the value. 01:41:42
Of the lot itself and is expected to have positive impacts. 01:41:45
On neighboring commercial lots. 01:41:48
The buffer yard alone. 01:41:50
Adjacent residential lots are provided to the West. Additional buffering is recommended for the properties on the South. 01:41:52
The rezoning of subject property will support. 01:41:59
Responsible growth and development in the area. 01:42:02
Rezoning follows the objectives of smart growth outlined in the Floyd County Comprehensive Plan. 01:42:04
Higher density development is directed towards existing infrastructure. 01:42:10
Provider Provider letters indicate ability to serve the development is in. 01:42:14
The identified commercial growth area and is in the infill development. 01:42:20
Upon careful review, the Floyd County Penny Commission hereby makes a favorable recommendation. 01:42:24
On the petitioner zoning. 01:42:30
Amendment application at the meeting held on the 10th of February 2025. 01:42:32
A favorable recommendation is based on the following written commencement. 01:42:37
Buffer Yard 2 standards will be met on all adjoining residential properties. 01:42:41
Trick #2 Drainage will be Floyd County storm water standards as approved by the Storm Water Board. 01:42:46
#3A phase lot 1 will be developed first and a schedule of completion for the project will be provided by the applicant. 01:42:52
That completes my ballot. 01:42:59
OK, we have a ballot. I need a second. 01:43:02
No second. 01:43:25
That I need a ballot. 01:43:27
By somebody that's not approving this ballot. 01:43:29
You need to fill one out. 01:43:31
I can't do it. 01:43:33
What was the question? 01:43:42
Mr. Vice President. 01:43:44
Somebody need somebody will need to complete a ballot. 01:43:49
Otherwise you can have discussion on the first one if you want to at this point. 01:43:58
Go from there. 01:44:03
But. 01:44:04
Nations from out for conversations. 01:44:10
Yeah. I mean, you guys can discuss it. You can. 01:44:13
The only thing that would not require bouts unfavorable recommend or sorry, no recommendation that would not have a ballot with 01:44:16
us. 01:44:19
It's favorable, unfavorable, or no recommendation. 01:44:24
I was listening correct because you wouldn't have a ballot with no recommendation. 01:44:28
OK, so somebody makes needs to make a motion. 01:44:33
That's the path that somebody wants, OK? 01:44:36
So I think once again, that's why we kind of went through and explained so. 01:44:38
Obviously, Mr. Bible Hauser has a ballot with a favorable. 01:44:41
We either need somebody with an unfavorable or no recommendation at all. 01:44:45
Unfavorable takes a ballot. No recommendation would not be a ballot, so no recommendation does not take about. 01:44:51
I'll make a motion for no recommendation to the Board Commission. 01:44:57
Could place place. Please respect what we're trying to get accomplished here. I beg you. 01:45:01
If you cannot be quiet, you need to leave the room please. Thank you. 01:45:07
OK, so I have I have a motion for no recommendation correct? 01:45:11
I need a second. 01:45:16
I need a second. 01:45:24
I will second that motion. 01:45:26
OK, have a second. 01:45:27
Any discussion? 01:45:29
Yeah, I'm just not qualified to do this unfavorable ballot. I'm. 01:45:31
Totally opposed to this. I don't know why we're making an adjustment to this zoning to our. 01:45:35
Residents of that area. 01:45:40
But to put me to. 01:45:46
Could do this ballot. I'm just not qualified. I mean, it's so detailed, so complex, just what they went through. 01:45:48
I think it's a process. OK. So do you want to fill out an unfavorable? 01:45:55
Not or you want to vote for. 01:46:01
No recommendation. 01:46:03
Maybe if we can re. 01:46:04
Revisit this another meeting, give me time to prepare for it. That's not possible. We've got three options and we're going to 01:46:06
leave the room with 1/3 so. 01:46:10
I'm not qualified to do this. 01:46:13
Unfavorable. Sort of. 01:46:17
I have a motion. I have a second. 01:46:18
We had discussion all in favor. 01:46:20
Signify for I. 01:46:22
Aye, aye. 01:46:24
There's three. That's for no recommendation at all. 01:46:26
So you had three, so you do not have enough to support a no recommendation. So there needs to be a ballot. 01:46:31
That is prepared or a. 01:46:36
Vote in favor. You have to have a majority vote. 01:46:38
Call again. So no recommendation. 01:46:45
Everybody understands what's going on there. That goes to the ministers, they make the decision so. 01:46:48
You could make an unfavorable. 01:46:53
And vote unanimous. All that still goes to the Commission. 01:46:55
Makes the commissioners make the decision so. 01:46:58
In order to for us to finish this meeting tonight, we have to have a vote. 01:47:01
So can I put it up for one more time? 01:47:06
Somebody else can make a motion, yes. 01:47:09
Can I review this? I mean how complex is this? 01:47:12
I know I'm not qualified, but I mean, can we just put up a? 01:47:15
Vote unfavorable how details is going to be you have. 01:47:19
Ballot and bring your motion with. 01:47:22
Your ballot. 01:47:25
But you can take time to fill out and do, but it does. 01:47:27
Be brought and then a second to that. 01:47:29
Vote on that ballot. 01:47:32
Not an answer question. We're we. 01:47:35
We're not supposed to answer questions, but hold on a second. 01:47:52
Once again, what we're trying to do here is we've got favorable, unfavorable. 01:47:55
Or no recommendation. So that's what we're trying to get through right now, so. 01:47:59
Let it give us time to get through this place. 01:48:02
Yes. All right, I'll make a motion is. 01:48:06
I'll make a motion and no recommendation. 01:48:10
I'll second. 01:48:13
We have a second. 01:48:15
Any other discussion? 01:48:16
All in favor. 01:48:18
For no recommendation signify by aye. 01:48:19
Ah, those opposed. 01:48:23
All right, all right. 01:48:24
OK, so it's two, it passes. 01:48:26
Good. Five, Yeah, OK. 01:48:28
So it's going to the Commission with no recommendation. So I'll get to visit Michelle. Let me let me show a hands who said yes. 01:48:30
No recommendations. No recommendation? Sure. 01:48:37
12345 So we've got enough, correct that is correct. 01:48:39
So that passes. 01:48:44
OK, so now agenda item. 01:48:45
Number. 01:48:48
4/3 right? 01:48:51
Excuse me, Sir. What? 01:48:55
We all right, go ahead. 01:48:57
I'm looking for a ballot. 01:49:00
For agenda item number. 01:49:01
433. 01:49:05
3 Umm. 01:49:07
Even though we got no recommendation here, you still want to all tied together. That's what I Nick, have you. Yeah. 01:49:08
Make a contingent on commissioners approval. 01:49:20
Yeah, I mean. 01:49:22
Well, the the subdivisions. 01:49:26
Ministerial. 01:49:28
Correct. 01:49:29
So if the Mr. standards, then you. 01:49:31
Child permit. So for that work they want to table it. 01:49:33
If the applicant wishes to table until commissioners make a decision, otherwise you guys would, it would be up to you and it's 01:49:39
ministerial, so if they meet all the requirements it has to be approved. 01:49:43
With you can make a condition contingent on the commissioners approval of the rezone, though obviously other than that if they 01:49:48
meet the requirements of the zoning ordinance it has to be approved. 01:49:52
The question is just do you want to table it until a decision is made by the commissioners or do you want a do you want the board 01:50:01
to go ahead and vote on it this evening? 01:50:05
OK. 01:50:09
So that you guys are left with the ballot for that. 01:50:10
Which is agenda item 4 but. 01:50:15
Docket ending in 03 is a grant or deny that subdivision. 01:50:17
Again, is ministerial in nature as long as they meet the zoning ordinance. 01:50:21
With that though, I would. 01:50:24
Recommend subject subject to the Commissioners approval. 01:50:26
Zoning change which is reference that docket number, I think will be helpful. 01:50:30
OK. So just for everybody on the board, if you get a ballot that's in favor of this? 01:50:34
We put us, we put a condition on it. 01:50:39
That it's subject to the commissioners, correct? So if the commissioners don't approve that, then it would not be approved. All 01:50:42
right, so I need, I need a ballot for agenda item item number 4. 01:50:46
#4. 01:50:51
Well, it's agenda item 4. It's agenda item 4, Docket three. Yeah, Docket 3. 01:50:54
Docket FCO 1-25-03. 01:51:10
Number one, petitioner has met all the following requirements. 01:51:16
So he's met all the requirements for. 01:51:20
Preliminary plan provided. 01:51:24
Certification demonstrating idem. 01:51:26
Platt provided geotechnical report staff. 01:51:29
Traffic Study. 01:51:33
The lots working. 01:51:36
And compliance. 01:51:38
The streets. 01:51:40
Item I Streets are in compliance. J Sidewalks are in compliance #2 Petitioner has met. 01:51:41
The following requirements for drainage and storm water. 01:51:48
#3 The petitioner has provided a letter confirming. 01:51:52
Confirming availability and willingness to serve for all necessary utilities. Lloyd Water Company, Georgetown Fire Department. 01:51:56
Harrison REMC, New Albany Wastewater. 01:52:04
At T and Charter. 01:52:08
#4 Petitioner has met the following requirements for sewer and or septic. 01:52:10
Service for the development we provided by New Albany Wastewater. 01:52:14
Decision. 01:52:22
Upon careful review, the boy county. 01:52:25
Planning Commissioner right grants the petitioner. 01:52:27
Primary approval for a major subdivision at the meeting held on the 10th of February 2025. Primary approval is based on completion 01:52:30
of fine conditions. 01:52:35
Final Approval The drainage stormwater plans are required prior to secondary approval. 01:52:39
The number of apartments. 01:52:45
For this development shall not exceed 125 units. 01:52:47
And this. 01:52:53
This approval is subject to. 01:52:57
Contingent is contingent upon. 01:53:00
The the planning. 01:53:09
The commissioners approving the previous one, right? 01:53:12
FC is put down FC. 01:53:16
This is contingent upon. 01:53:18
FC01. 01:53:20
I will just hold on there, OK. 01:53:22
FCO One. 01:53:34
2502, that's right, yeah. 01:53:36
This is contingent upon the Commissioner's approval of FCO 1-25-02 that completes my ballot. 01:53:41
All right, we have a ballot. I need a any discussion. 01:53:49
I need a second. 01:53:53
I'll second. 01:53:54
We have a second. All in favor signify by aye. 01:53:55
All right, all right, let me see. A show of hands and said aye. 01:53:59
OK, let the record show that there was a majority more than 5. 01:54:03
That passes. 01:54:07
Once again, that is subject to the Commissioners approval. 01:54:10
Of the zoning map. 01:54:12
All right, you got agenda item number 5. 01:54:14
FC-01-25-04. 01:54:18
On this one, Nick, this would go from the multifamily to the PUD though, so I think at this time. 01:54:25
Would the applicant want to table that one? Because. 01:54:31
I mean, it wasn't. 01:54:35
Obviously the recommendation. There's no recommendation from. 01:54:36
Commercial to multifamily. 01:54:39
I still you have 8 will be back in the morning. 01:54:42
Unfavorable, OK. 01:54:47
OK. All right. 01:54:49
All right, so confirming that's OK with you so. 01:54:51
Is there any on a body on the board that wants to make no recommendation motion or is there a ballot from somebody? 01:54:53
Anybody. 01:55:02
Which one is this for? This is the one that. 01:55:04
PUD. 01:55:09
It's #4. 01:55:10
It's it's it's agenda file. 01:55:14
So your options again are favorable, unfavorable, both of those require ballots or no recommendation. 01:55:19
So, and this is on 04. 01:55:31
This is yes. 01:55:33
Huh. 01:55:37
The first part of this thing. 01:55:46
It's all up to you. 01:55:47
So all I have to say. 01:55:49
Officer, can't we start? 01:55:51
Multiple pages in correct? 01:55:53
Yes, page 4. 01:55:55
All right, all right, That's OK. 01:56:01
We have three options. 01:56:06
I know the proposed. 01:56:07
Planned unit development does very does significantly. 01:56:10
Does vary significant from the zoning and subdivision control regulation concerning density, parking and buffering? 01:56:14
Yard #1 #2. 01:56:20
The closed land use and the. 01:56:23
In the planned unit development. 01:56:25
Are not in conflict. 01:56:27
With spirit and the intent of the comprehensive. 01:56:29
Plants surrounding land use and zoning district. 01:56:32
#3 the proposed. 01:56:36
HUD does provide adequate public service like air traffic control. 01:56:38
Open and. 01:56:44
Common space and recreation. 01:56:45
#4. 01:56:48
The planned unit development is compatible with the adjacent properties and surrounding neighborhoods. 01:56:49
#5. 01:56:55
The proposed planned unit development will not interfere with the use or diminish the values of adjacent properties and 01:56:56
surrounding neighborhood. 01:57:00
Number six, the proposed planned unit development will not diminish the level of service. 01:57:04
For roadway systems in the vicinity. 01:57:09
#7. 01:57:12
The plan you development can't be immediately and adequately served by existing public facilities. 01:57:13
#8. 01:57:20
Planned unit development does preserve natural and historic resources to extent possible. 01:57:21
#9 The planned unit development will not be interest to the public health and safety and general welfare. 01:57:27
#10 The written commitments will be required. The applicant shall provide a schedule for phasing the construction of the project. 01:57:33
A schedule for the completion of all phases. 01:57:37
We'll provide it to the Planning Commission. 01:57:42
#11. 01:57:44
The petitioner will be. 01:57:46
Required. 01:57:48
To meet conditions. 01:57:49
Please specify those conditions a the number of apartments of development. 01:57:51
Shall not exceed 125 units. 01:57:56
Be for secondary approval, provide additional screening of dumpster on. 01:57:59
Dumpster. 01:58:03
On lot 1 between dumpsters and roadway provided light at entrance. 01:58:04
Locations where there are none. 01:58:10
Meet suffer buffer zone. 01:58:12
Buffer Yard 2 standards. 01:58:15
For adjoining residential youth on the South side. 01:58:17
With a ball. 01:58:21
That completes my appointment. That's not complete my brother. 01:58:25
I gotta read something over here. 01:58:29
Upon careful review, the Floyd County Planning Commission hereby. 01:58:31
Makes a favorable recommendation to the County Commissioner concerning the petitioner planned unit development at the beating held 01:58:34
on the 10th of February, 2025. 01:58:38
All right, we have a ballot. 01:58:44
Any discussion on that ballot? 01:58:46
I need a second. 01:58:48
I'll second. 01:58:51
We do have a second. 01:58:52
Any further discussion if none? 01:58:54
We need a vote all signify that agreed by aye. 01:58:57
Aye. 01:59:00
Those opposed. 01:59:02
Aye. 01:59:03
All right, well, let's say this show of hands and approve it. 01:59:04
Which one are you doing? 01:59:08
4. 01:59:10
Just making sure I heard you right. 01:59:11
1234. 01:59:13
OK. 01:59:15
All right. 01:59:16
So if we need somebody to do. 01:59:19
I will adjust. 01:59:22
Ballot. 01:59:24
To no recommendation. 01:59:25
So you're just bringing a motion for number? Yeah, it's not your ballot. 01:59:28
Well, it's on here to 2nd, make no recommendation. 01:59:31
Ending ending Commissioner approval. 01:59:35
Is is it just no recommendation or is it? 01:59:40
Automatically pending Commissioner approval. 01:59:43
It goes to commissioners regardless. 01:59:47
OK, I'll second that. 01:59:49
OK, so we have a motion for. 01:59:52
No recommendation. 01:59:55
Correct, and you're seconded. 01:59:57
Any discussion? 01:59:59
OK, all in favor, say bye. 02:00:01
Raise hands, please. So we got it on record. 02:00:03
OK, we do have 5 or above so that does pass. 02:00:06
All right. Thank you. 02:00:09
All right, it passes no recommendation. 02:00:12
All right, the last. 02:00:17
Is agenda item 6. 02:00:21
Which is FC. 02:00:24
01 Dash, 2505. 02:00:25
I thought that's what we just did. No, I didn't. 02:00:28
I don't know if that was the floor. Huh. It was all four. 02:00:31
It didn't read. 02:00:37
Yeah, 'cause that's. 02:00:41
Yeah, that should have signatures. 02:00:42
Because that should have that as a no recommendation, shouldn't have signatures on it, right? 02:00:47
That one does. 02:00:53
Hey, Nick. 02:00:55
I'm all confused at this point guys. 02:00:58
The 04 ballot has no recommendation but still has a ballot which? 02:01:02
Are you OK with that? 02:01:06
Yeah. 02:01:08
You vote, you voted on it. 02:01:10
Recommendation. 02:01:12
Do you have, do you have agenda item 5? Is that what you? Yeah, that's fine. That's still fine. 02:01:15
You just read Ballot. 02:01:22
Agenda item. 02:01:26
Agenda item 5 + 4. 02:01:28
Gotcha. OK. That was the one you just read. 02:01:30
You read it. 02:01:33
Where's it at? 02:01:35
That's when we just. That's what I just read. 02:01:37
Yeah, I don't think that's right. I'm confused. 02:01:41
Nick, you want help a second. 02:01:43
You skipped. 02:01:49
Is this right? 02:01:51
You have the first 3. 02:01:54
Here we go, you're saying? 02:01:57
You want an 05 now, right? Correct. 02:01:59
That's the one we're on now. 02:02:01
We have to. 02:02:07
Did we approve this one? 02:02:09
OK, so we're on. 02:02:11
That's right. 02:02:23
Do we need to finish signing that? 02:02:26
I need it and I'll move it on. 02:02:30
OK. All right. 02:02:35
So, so Nick on this development plan, I mean, if we're voting no recommendation on. 02:02:36
O2 and 04. 02:02:40
How? How do we How do we vote on it? 02:02:41
On both O2. 02:02:45
That's right. 02:02:47
Yeah, I got a sign. 02:02:49
I bet so that's good. 02:02:52
That's alright, you got it. I'm. 02:02:57
Hey, I'm good. 02:03:01
How do I know what I'm saying? 02:03:02
OK, the next we need a ballot for agenda item 6. 02:03:12
05. 02:03:17
FC-O125-505. 02:03:18
No, I just making sure that. 02:03:24
Where's my wife? 02:03:42
You guys. 02:03:48
This will be. 02:03:51
Subject to FC 01. 02:03:52
25. 02:03:56
Dash O2. 02:03:58
And 04104 1. 02:04:01
That's it, You got it. 02:04:11
And I still need some. 02:04:13
All right, do we have a ballot for Docket FCO 1-25-O5? 02:04:17
Conceptual site plan. 02:04:25
Review by planning director Yes. 02:04:27
Findings #1 Petitioner has met all the veterans standards. 02:04:29
For the district #2A waiver for the development standard. 02:04:33
Requirement is not required. 02:04:37
#3. 02:04:39
Proposed development plan is consistent with the Comprehensive plan because the Floyd County Comprehensive Plan identifies the 02:04:41
area as a commercial growth area. 02:04:45
The proposed planned unit development be mixed-use featuring a commercial element nearest the frontage additional rezoning 02:04:50
assistant with the smart growth principles. 02:04:54
Identified in the plan, specifically mixed land use. 02:04:59
Compact building design, creating a range of housing opportunities, directing development towards existing communities and 02:05:02
preserving open space. 02:05:06
And critical environmental areas as this is an infill development. 02:05:11
#4 The proposed development is consistent with the intent. 02:05:15
Of the district has set forth in Boyd County zoning ordinance because it is a multi family planned unit development district. 02:05:19
District which allows modifications to underlying district. 02:05:26
Standards #4 the proposed development plan. 02:05:29
Does satisfy. 02:05:32
The following development. 02:05:33
Requirements. 02:05:35
And there are. 02:05:36
A is signage, B is access, C is designed D lighting. 02:05:37
Number six, the proposed development is a multi family development development plan does satisfy the requirements for a 02:05:43
recreational space and open space by providing a pool and outdoor gaming area. 02:05:49
And is less than the 25 acres in Toll area. 02:05:55
#7 The proposed developments is located in the Highlander Point District. 02:05:58
The following requirements have been met. Building facades or brick. 02:06:02
And Harding board there are no loading docks, burden dumpsters located to the side and rear of the buildings. 02:06:06
A The building facades that face any adjacent streets have a finished facade. 02:06:12
Be loading docks and trash collector bins are not placed on or along the facade that face. 02:06:17
Any adjacent streets? 02:06:22
See the accommodation is. 02:06:25
Is made for community space where a proposal commercial development. 02:06:27
Has over 100,000 square feet. 02:06:32
Either in combination of buildings or lots and is. 02:06:34
A cohesive commercial project or development D. 02:06:38
Open space requirements for Section 904. The Fern. 02:06:41
Zoning ordinance are met. 02:06:44
Decision. This decision is contingent upon Commissioners approval. 02:06:46
Of SCO 12502 and FCO 1/25/04. 02:06:50
One careful review. The Floyd County Planning Commission hereby approves. 02:06:54
The Petition Development Plan review application at the meeting held on the 10th of February 2025. 02:06:58
Completes my ballot. 02:07:04
All right, we have a ballot. Everybody understands the conditions written on the ballot. 02:07:06
I need a second. 02:07:10
All right, I've got a second. 02:07:14
I would like to. 02:07:18
Note that. 02:07:19
This detailed improvement detailed. 02:07:21
Plan would be contingent upon the rezoning. 02:07:25
He said that. 02:07:29
Not only as a condition, but as a matter of. 02:07:31
Whether it is valid or not. 02:07:34
That's why I made a second. 02:07:37
There you go. So I have I do have a a second. 02:07:40
OK. 02:07:43
All right, all in favor signify by aye. 02:07:46
Aye, show of hands please, on the eyes. 02:07:49
OK, that is. 02:07:52
A majority. So that passes. Thank you, Larry. 02:07:53
All righty, Nick. 02:07:57
Includes the. 02:07:58
Agenda items other than we had something on here about the overlay. 02:08:00
Can we, can we push, push that down the road? 02:08:04
Please I need to. 02:08:07
I really need to. 02:08:10
I need to. I gotta be honest with you. 02:08:12
OK, OK, let's get these signed before we adjourn. 02:08:16
Because that is. 02:08:19
That is no old business, new business. 02:08:21
Complete for tonight. 02:08:24
Appreciate advice, patience. 02:08:26
Need a motion for adjourned. Yeah, don't, don't leave till you sign though. I need a motion to adjourn motion. 02:08:29
OK, any a second so moved. 02:08:34
Favor signify by. 02:08:37
All right. Thank you very much. 02:08:39
Oh. 02:08:44
Link
Start video at
Social
Embed
* you need to log in to manage your favorites
My Favorites List
You haven't added any favorites yet. Click the "Add Favorite" button on any media page, and they'll show up here.
* use Ctrl+F (Cmd+F on Mac) to search in document
Unable to preview the file.
Name Document type
FC-01-25-05 - Thieneman- Development Plan General Document
FC-01-25-04 - Thieneman - PUD General Document
FC-01-25-03 - Thieneman- Knobs Landing Subdivision General Document
FC-01-25-02 - Thieneman- Rezone General Document
FC-01-25-01 - ASB- Administrative Subdivision General Document
At this time, I'd like to call to order the February 10th the Floyd County Planning Commission. At this time, we'd like to stand 00:00:13
and honor our flag, please. 00:00:17
United States of America. 00:00:23
And to Republic, for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. 00:00:26
OK, at this time I'd like to have a roll call. 00:00:36
Here. 00:00:39
Present. 00:00:44
Yeah. 00:00:46
Here. 00:00:47
Here. 00:00:50
Here. 00:00:51
Here. 00:00:53
Alrighty, one shorter board member. That's eight of us, correct? 00:00:55
All right. 00:00:58
At this time. 00:01:01
We'd like to have the minutes of the December. 00:01:03
Fruit. I'm going to take a look at those and make a motion. 00:01:07
I make a motion that we approve the December Planning Commission. 00:01:15
Minutes. All right. Thank you. I have a. 00:01:18
Motion any second. 00:01:21
Awesome. Go ahead. 00:01:24
I got a second, but John any. 00:01:25
Conversation. 00:01:27
Discussion. 00:01:29
At that time, we take a motion all in favor. 00:01:30
Aye, those opposed likewise. Thank you. Approved. Thank you. 00:01:33
All righty. We have no old business. Is that correct, Nick? 00:01:36
OK, this time we'd like to agenda number item number one, we have have to have the election of officers. 00:01:42
And at this time, we need some recommendation emotions. 00:01:49
I nominate Mr. Hunter for the president. 00:01:54
All right, we got a motion for president. We need a second. 00:01:57
Second. All right, we've got a second all in favor. 00:02:00
Aye, those opposed likewise. Thank you. 00:02:03
All right, now we need somebody for Vice President. 00:02:06
Needed somebody to. 00:02:09
Volunteer piece. 00:02:11
For a motion or a motion, there you go. Make somebody make a motion. That'll work. 00:02:16
Frank, are you willing to do it? 00:02:22
Take care. All right, so somebody needs to make a motion for Frank. 00:02:26
I'll make a motion, Frank. 00:02:29
For vice president. 00:02:31
All right, we have a motion a second all any discussion? 00:02:33
All in favor signify by. 00:02:37
Those opposed likewise. All right. Thanks. Thanks a lot. 00:02:39
All right. Next thing is the plant review committee. 00:02:42
Right now I've show that's Larry. 00:02:46
Chris Welch, Gina. 00:02:48
John Brankworth and myself as everybody still willing to serve. 00:02:50
I am OK Larry is John. 00:02:54
Gina and we called Chris and I'm willing to do that. So that takes care of that, OK? 00:02:58
All right. Next Adam is the Adam agenda item number two, FC-01. 00:03:03
Hold on. So you guys need to vote on that. 00:03:08
On which someone on the plant review, so I'm sorry, we need a vote on the plant review. So I need a motion to accept those 5 00:03:10
members. 00:03:13
Make a motion. All right, we have a motion. I need a second. 00:03:18
All right, all in favor signify by. 00:03:22
Likewise opposed. Thank you all right now. 00:03:24
All right. Now we're going to go to agenda item number 2. 00:03:29
FC-01-25-01, Administrative Subdivision. 00:03:32
Nick will give us his staff report. 00:03:37
This is an. 00:03:40
Minor subdivision application for four lot subdivision. The petitioner is ASB LLC. The zoning district is agricultural 00:03:41
residential. 00:03:45
They are requesting A4 lot subdivision with frontage on Nippleton Road. 00:03:50
The property currently has a home and two barns on it. 00:03:54
There is an identified floodway and floodway fringe on the South and. 00:03:58
Side of the property. 00:04:01
The plaque committee for this was cancelled due to a lack of quorum. 00:04:03
Staff comments is that the plat as submitted does comply with lot size standards. Lots are minimum of two acres with 100 foot. 00:04:07
Road frontage plate I submitted does comply with streets. 00:04:15
Standards There are no new streets provided. The plat as submitted does comply with easement standards with conditions. 00:04:19
Stated below, the driveway easements are needed. 00:04:25
For every two lots, one driveway easement is required. 00:04:30
Unless that requirement is waived by the. 00:04:34
Flat as submitted does comply with the block standards. There are no blocks proposed. 00:04:38
The plat as submitted does provide St. improvements as required. Again, no streets proposed. 00:04:44
The plat, as submitted does comply with Water Supply Standards Board and tri-county Regional Water has provided a service letter 00:04:51
for the new lots. 00:04:55
3 inch inch line is available for service. 00:04:59
This line is not adequate to provide Fire Protection. 00:05:02
The plot as submitted is suitable for sewage and wastewater containment because they have soil provided soil testing. 00:05:07
And has been completed by the Floyd County Health Department. 00:05:14
Reviewed in by the Floyd County Health Department and provided septic system requirements for suitable systems. 00:05:19
Staff Recommendations. 00:05:26
Would be to require joint driveways. 00:05:28
In easements to be added to the plat for lots. 00:05:31
I believe we said it was one and two, unless that is waived by the Planning Commission. 00:05:37
Add note on. 00:05:42
Flat that prior to development, the Owner shall consult with Highlander Fire Protection District. 00:05:44
On driveway placement. 00:05:50
All right. That's our staff reporting by having questions for Nick at this time on the board. 00:05:53
None. All righty. Thank you, Nick. 00:06:01
OK, at this time we'd like to call the applicant to come. 00:06:04
Forward and presenter. 00:06:06
Good evening. State your name and address. Yes, Sir. Brad Benson with ASB 720 Rolling Creek. 00:06:10
Drive the Ste. 106 in New Albany. 00:06:16
I know you all have blacks in your file there, but I've got a couple bigger ones if anyone would like. 00:06:19
You want to walk on. 00:06:24
Not a problem. 00:06:25
Yes, please. 00:06:29
So the staff report pretty much. 00:06:41
Pretty clear on what it is. It's a 20 acre parcel located at 688. 00:06:44
0 Mapleton Rd. 00:06:48
It is a R. 00:06:50
The tracks are. 00:06:51
For Track 1 is five acres, Track 2 is five acres, Track 3 is 2 acres. 00:06:53
Track 3 is the one with the house on it that will remain. 00:06:59
Track 4 is the 8 acre parcel. 00:07:02
He's correct on the ordinance allows for. 00:07:06
A minimum of two acre lots, so it applies with that. The road frontage is 100 square or 100 feet. 00:07:09
So we could play with that. 00:07:15
One element that he did say that. 00:07:16
It does not meet. 00:07:18
The board has. 00:07:20
So the Commission has the ability to. 00:07:22
Waive the right for an access easement between these lots. 00:07:24
We would ask that that be waived for all four parcels. 00:07:28
Track 3 already has a house on it. Our goal with this is that we're not. There's no plans for this right now. We're going to let 00:07:33
it sit. 00:07:36
May list it and sell it and let somebody out. 00:07:40
Build a house on it. We are home builder so hopefully it's us. 00:07:42
We may end up holding. 00:07:45
Family member, but right now there's no plans. 00:07:47
So with these big, Big Lots, we're hoping that you know you're. 00:07:51
State style houses big, lots big. 00:07:55
You know, big entrance in there. 00:07:58
If the Commission were to require a. 00:08:00
The access easement. 00:08:03
I would ask that it only be on. 00:08:05
Lots 1 and 2. 00:08:07
Those are the two bigger ones on the. 00:08:09
If you're looking at the fly on the bottom side. 00:08:11
It's only because lot 3 already has a drive. 00:08:14
Lot 4 would then be a separate drive as well. 00:08:17
If that is not an option and Commission would require the. 00:08:21
Access easements on all of them. 00:08:26
Then I would ask that the approval tonight be conditioned upon us supplying those. 00:08:28
I believe it's 50 feet wide along those property lines. 00:08:33
And we'll submit that proper paperwork. 00:08:37
For Nick for approval. 00:08:39
So just to clarify real quick on the excess easements. 00:08:40
Are they are they not using the road frontage to access their properties or will they need to go across the other tracks? No they 00:08:46
will. They all have proper Rd. frontage along Naples and road. So our hope would be that we would have drives off of Napleton. 00:08:52
That would not be able to. 00:08:58
Access easement will not be needed. 00:09:00
So you still got these the site provisions for one for #1 Yes, there is. So the minimum is 100 feet and. 00:09:04
There's 100 on all. 00:09:13
Yeah. 00:09:18
Fall from there and Associates, 301 E Chestnut St. Court in Indiana. 00:09:21
Your administrative subdivision requirements have have a have a requirement for joint driveways for every two lots. That's what 00:09:24
Mr. Benson is describing. 00:09:28
I understand the limit the need is to limit access to county roads. 00:09:34
But when you have Big Lots like this, especially one that has an existing House of drive, it makes it difficult to Co locate those 00:09:38
drives. 00:09:42
And even though the ordinance requires it, it still creates a maintenance problem. 00:09:46
Because you have two homeowners fighting over. 00:09:49
Who's going to maintain that joint driveway? 00:09:51
It's it's in my opinion to everyone's best interest to separate those travelers. 00:09:53
OK. Any other questions? 00:10:00
None. 00:10:05
All right. At this time, we'd like to open up to anybody that like to speak in favor of this project. 00:10:06
Come forward now. State your name and your address for the record. 00:10:13
See that there's none stepping forward. 00:10:19
Now we open up to those who want to oppose. Are you come in favor, Sir? 00:10:21
OK, OK. Well. 00:10:26
Yeah, anybody wants coming against it, coming forward. 00:10:28
State your name and your address for the record please. 00:10:31
James White. 00:10:38
Everybody got that gotcha. 00:10:39
OK, I live at 314 Tuscany Drive. 00:10:41
And if they open all that up there and that's going to open our street up to. 00:10:44
Them coming more traffic down through there, right? 00:10:50
Sir, I think you're about the wrong. You're on the wrong project. Sir, this is on Napleton Road. 00:10:53
I'm sorry. 00:10:57
You're in the right church, Wrong Pew. 00:10:59
All right, so. 00:11:05
You he got a jump on you guys. 00:11:09
All right, at this time everybody will speak in opposition. 00:11:13
To the administrative subdivision. 00:11:17
On naval Tarot come forward, state your name and address. 00:11:20
Mike Gatton. I live at 6975 Napleton Rd. 00:11:24
And my property overlooks this property. 00:11:27
And. 00:11:31
The traffic is already bad due to Cutter Smith woodworking. 00:11:32
Huber's all that and to divide this out and put four more houses on there. 00:11:36
Just opens it up for more development and. 00:11:42
There's a second. 00:11:44
Lot that is not involved in this to the left of it and it's going to open that up for more development. 00:11:45
We moved out there to be in the county. I've lived there 23 years. We don't want to be in the city. 00:11:52
The traffic, The busing. 00:11:56
School buses, things like that. 00:11:58
The trucks it's already bad enough we. 00:12:01
Preferred the county to state county. 00:12:03
That's why we're there. 00:12:06
Thank you. 00:12:09
Have some more time for anybody else to come forward. State your name and address for the record. 00:12:14
And take the films. 00:12:20
And I live at 7200 Mableton Rd. 00:12:22
Our property also looks through. 00:12:25
Mr. loops backyard. 00:12:27
Over to this property. 00:12:29
Like he said, the traffic is already so terrible. We have. 00:12:31
Multiple wrecks with semis on. 00:12:35
Our Rd. every year that drive off the roads hit trees. 00:12:37
It is. 00:12:42
So busy. 00:12:43
Adding this is. 00:12:44
Taking away all of our country, all of our farmland. 00:12:46
I I had somebody build a house behind me a couple years ago and I now have no deer in my yard. I mean like there's literally no 00:12:50
wildlife except for comedies. If anybody knows about my coyote issue, but. 00:12:56
There is. 00:13:01
Like nothing coming in our property more because everybody's building and scaring them out and. 00:13:02
That's why we moved there. We moved to begin the country. We have farm animals. 00:13:07
And dogs and. 00:13:11
Horses and goats, and that's what we moved there for and. 00:13:13
I mean you all all moved out there for the same reason. I know where most of you live and you move to those areas for. 00:13:16
That in. 00:13:22
You're turning it around. There's another piece of land. 00:13:23
I know the same person bought on Ableton road and if you all approve this. 00:13:26
It's just gonna turn around and get approved for him as well, and that's. 00:13:30
Down by the cows. 00:13:33
So like, that's our landmarks. We turn at the cows you go to. 00:13:35
This farm and that farm and you're just turning it away. 00:13:39
Everybody asked me every day. 00:13:43
Do you know anybody that has 5 acres for sale? 00:13:44
No, because somebody buys it and puts a whole bunch of houses on it. 00:13:47
That's not what we want. 00:13:51
So just consider that. 00:13:52
Thank you. 00:13:54
Good evening, Troy Durham. 00:14:03
7222 Napleton Rd. 00:14:05
I'm also as a crow flies less than a mile from this development potential development. 00:14:07
I don't chagrin anybody for China. 00:14:12
Exercise their free enterprise and do business as they see fit. They have the freedom to do it. 00:14:14
My two cents as much like these other people who spoke. 00:14:20
It's too crowded on the road. It's too busy. 00:14:24
And uh, uh. 00:14:26
To be frank. 00:14:28
I don't like the discomfort I already have fearing for my. 00:14:29
Home and those within it from vehicle. 00:14:33
Thanks. We've had semis in our front yard. 00:14:36
In the past. 00:14:38
And I just think it's too much on the road. 00:14:41
Too much development. 00:14:43
This would maybe be a domino. 00:14:44
Of continuing the domino effect of what's already happened with the. 00:14:46
Development further out to the county. 00:14:50
I don't wish to see it. 00:14:52
For my $0.02. 00:14:54
And where I lived. 00:14:56
And chose to live. 00:14:57
For rural reasons. 00:14:59
There's something. 00:15:00
Alluring to being out in the country. 00:15:01
And I think that would be spoiled. 00:15:03
Thank you very much. Thank you. 00:15:05
Anybody else? 00:15:08
All right, at this time we get. 00:15:12
Nobody else in opposition. We open the floor back to the petitioner to rebut. 00:15:15
Anything that was discussed. 00:15:19
Thank you. I'll make it short here. The only thing I would like to point out is we are this is administrative flat. 00:15:23
We comply with the ordinance. The only issue would be the access easement. 00:15:29
I said I would ask that you waive that right here because of what we're trying to do with this. 00:15:34
We are not looking to divide this property. It is an AR which is a. 00:15:39
Two acre lot minimum. 00:15:42
So hypothetically we get coming forth with a plat for 9 acres in that zone. 00:15:44
We're not looking to do that. 00:15:49
Worth looking just for four. 00:15:50
They're Big Lots, A2 acre. The smallest one is one with the house on it. They'll remain. 00:15:52
And then the 55 naked SO. 00:15:57
All right. Thank you. 00:15:59
At this point where we looking for a ballot? 00:16:03
I have a ballot. 00:16:07
Subdivision named Ableton Place DACA. 00:16:08
FC 01/25/01. 00:16:11
After careful review, the fact committee finds that one. 00:16:15
Plant as submitted does comply with the lot size standards. 00:16:18
Because the new lights are all a minimum of two acres with more than 100. 00:16:22
Foot of Rd. frontage #2. 00:16:26
The plan has submitted does comply with the street design standards. 00:16:29
Because no streets, no new streets are proposed. 00:16:33
#3. 00:16:36
The plan has submitted does comply with the easement standards because with the conditions below, driveway easements. 00:16:37
Or required. 00:16:43
#4 the plat as submitted does comply with the block standards. 00:16:45
Because there are no blocks required or proposed. 00:16:48
#5 the plat as submitted does. 00:16:52
Provide St. and. 00:16:55
Improvements as required by the ordinance. There are no new streets provided. 00:16:56
Number six, the Plat as submitted does comply with the water supply standards because. 00:17:01
Board and Tri Water Regional. 00:17:06
Water has provided a service letter for the new. 00:17:09
Lots. A three inch line is available for service. Note this line is not adequate for bad Fire Protection. 00:17:13
#7 the plat as submitted is suitable. 00:17:19
Pursuage and wastewater contain. 00:17:21
Containment because soil testing has been completed. 00:17:24
And Floyd County Health Department has provided septic system requirements for suitable systems. 00:17:27
The plant is accepted upon completion of the following condition at a joint driveway and easement to the plat for Lots 1 and 2. 00:17:33
Adding note to the plat. 00:17:40
That states the following. Prior to development, the owners shall consult the Highlander Fire Protection District for Fire 00:17:41
Protection requirements. 00:17:45
Due to the lack of adequate water supply. 00:17:48
Decision the Floyd County Planning Commission hereby grants the. 00:17:51
Primary approval. 00:17:55
For this administrative subdivision at the meeting held on the 10th of February, 2025. 00:17:56
That completes my ballot. 00:18:02
All right, we have a ballot. We're looking for a second. 00:18:04
I'll second. We have a second. 00:18:09
All in favor signify any discussion. Any discussion. 00:18:11
Any discussion? 00:18:15
All in favor signify by aye aye, those opposed likewise. 00:18:17
It passes. Thank you. 00:18:22
Did they sign down? 00:18:31
OK, at this time we like to move to Well, first of all, we want to ask the petitioner. 00:18:34
If they're OK with us putting. 00:18:40
Agenda items 3 through 6 and hearing them at the same time. 00:18:43
Mr. Craft, you OK with that? 00:18:47
All right. 00:18:50
Yes, separate ballots on everyone. Yes, Sir. 00:18:52
OK. OK. At this time, we'd like to ask Nick Creeby. 00:18:55
I'm a non voting member but I'll be recused recusing myself for the rest of the meeting. All right, thank you. 00:19:00
At this time, they could give a staff report. 00:19:09
So this is for docket items number FCO 1/25/02. 00:19:13
CO125. 00:19:18
Three FC 24. 00:19:20
504. 00:19:23
In FC. 00:19:27
1/25/05. 00:19:31
Petitioner Here's the Thing Group LLC. The location is 5031 through 5053 Old Vincent's Road. 00:19:38
The requests are for a zoning map amendment. 00:19:45
A major subdivision. 00:19:50
A PUD map amendment. 00:19:53
In detailed development. 00:19:56
They are all pertaining to the same project. 00:19:59
The current zoning is for general commercial. 00:20:03
Underlying zoning request is for multi family and then a multi family PUD. 00:20:07
The petitioner is seeking a planned unit development for mixed-use, multi family residential and commercial use. 00:20:13
This proposal will consolidate 4 parcels into two building lots, 3 points 64 and 2.334 acres. 00:20:19
The lots will be separated by through St. known as Knobs Landing Blvd. 00:20:28
Connecting Tuscany Drive in Trevor Rd. 00:20:33
Lot 1 will front will Vincennes Road and is the larger lot and will include two building. 00:20:36
Two buildings, A mixed-use commercial multifamily building. Building 1. 00:20:42
In a separate standalone commercial. 00:20:46
Retail building with drive through. 00:20:49
Which is proposed bank building 3 threes. 00:20:51
Lot 2 will have a single multi family building. 00:20:54
In a building 2. 00:20:58
Building 1 at the north of the property in the fronting Old Vincennes Rd. 00:21:00
Will be a three story structure with the ground floor area of 25,092 square feet. 00:21:05
The building will include 7717 square foot of commercial retail space. 00:21:11
Clubhouse leasing office. 00:21:17
And 59 multifamily units, 21 of those will be two-bedroom, 38 one bedroom. 00:21:19
Building 3 at the east side of the property will be near the corner of Shriver and Old Vincent's. 00:21:26
It will be a thirty 3600 square foot retail building with drive through that is the proposed bank. 00:21:31
Building 2, located at the South of the property on Lot 2, will be a three story multi family structure with ground floor area of 00:21:40
23,679 square feet and 66 units. 00:21:46
The property will also have. 00:21:52
Pool and outdoor recreation games area. 00:21:54
Neat foot masonry wall. 00:21:57
We'll buffer the residents on the West side of the development. 00:22:00
Villas of Floyd's knives. 00:22:03
Adjoining properties to the West. 00:22:05
Is the residential urban zone subdivision buildings of Floyd's Knobs to northwest across Tuscany. Dr. is a vacant general 00:22:07
commercial property. 00:22:12
Across Old Vincennes Road to the north is undeveloped general commercial. 00:22:16
To the northeast is Highlander Point development. 00:22:20
General commercial zoned. 00:22:23
The East Across River Rd. is general commercial. 00:22:26
To the South is residentially urban zone property with two acre single family lot. 00:22:29
In small section of the Highland subdivision. 00:22:34
Which is residential urban. 00:22:37
The current base zone for the proposal is general commercial. 00:22:39
Commercial. 00:22:43
Part of Floyd County Zoning Ordinance Section 7.04 GA Base Commercial Zone may not designate more than 30% of the proposed 00:22:44
development per square footage for residential. 00:22:49
Therefore the applicant is requesting the base zone be changed to multi family. 00:22:55
A traffic impact study was conducted for the proposal and determined that the intersections impacted by the development. 00:23:01
Will continue to work at an acceptable level of service. 00:23:07
Technical Review Committee was held on December 18th, 2024 for this development. 00:23:17
Summary report was attached to your staff report. 00:23:23
The technical review committee provides. 00:23:27
Recommendations to the Planning Commission. 00:23:30
On that. 00:23:33
Are the utility providers. 00:23:34
Public Safety. Sheriff Fire. 00:23:37
School. 00:23:40
As well as county staff, storm water engineering and planning. 00:23:42
The reason? Staff finds that the rezoning of the subject property is consistent with the Floyd County Comprehensive Plan. 00:23:47
Because the Floyd County Comprehensive Plan identifies the area as a commercial growth area. 00:23:54
Proposed. 00:23:59
The mixed-use featuring a commercial element yours to the frontage. 00:24:00
Additionally, rezoning is consistent with smart growth principles identified in the plan. Specifically mixed land uses compact 00:24:04
building design. 00:24:08
Creating a range of housing opportunities, directing development towards existing communities and preferring. 00:24:12
And thus preserving open space, farmland, natural beauty, and critical environmental areas. 00:24:18
As this is an infill development. 00:24:23
The rezoning of the subject property is consistent with the. 00:24:27
Conditions of the character of the current structures in the. 00:24:30
And uses in the area. 00:24:34
Because the commercial use is in the front of the lot are consistent with the original general commercial zoning. 00:24:36
The multifamily uses our appropriate transitional uses between general commercial and urban residential uses. 00:24:42
Voting facade materials are brick and Hardy board. 00:24:48
The structures are within the height limits of the zoning ordinance. And there are. 00:24:52
There is another three story building in the vicinity that is the Chase Bank. 00:24:56
The rezoning of the subject property is necessary for the most desirable use of. 00:25:01
The land because. 00:25:06
The rezoning follows smart growth principles already noted. 00:25:08
It has also provided. 00:25:12
Additional housing identified as needed in the Purdue Housing Report the county had completed in 2020. 00:25:14
It is mixed-use infill in commercial growth area. 00:25:20
The rezoning of the subject property will not be interest to the values of other properties in the area because. 00:25:24
Commercial uses are consistent with the neighborhood commercial zoning. 00:25:30
Excuse me? 00:25:34
The general commercial zoning. 00:25:35
Inappropriate adjacent and residential urban zoning. 00:25:38
And uses the addition of the multifamily component. 00:25:41
Will support local business customer base. The development will increase the value of the lots itself and expected that positive 00:25:44
impacts on neighboring commercial lots. 00:25:48
Buffer yard. 00:25:53
Along adjacent residential lots is provided on the West. Additional buffering is recommended for the properties on the South. 00:25:54
The rezoning of the subject property will support responsible growth and development in the area. 00:26:03
Because rezoning follows the objectives of small smart growth outlined in the Floyd County Comprehensive Plan. 00:26:08
Higher development is directed towards existing infrastructure. 00:26:15
Provider letters indicate ability to serve and the development is identified. Commercial growth area. 00:26:18
It is an infill development staff has favorable recommendations for the reason. 00:26:24
Written commitments recommended would be buffer yard 2 standards met. 00:26:30
For all adjoining residents. 00:26:34
Drainage will meet Floyd County stormwater standards as approved by the Stormwater Board. 00:26:37
And if phased, lot 1 will be developed first in a schedule for completion of the project will be provided. 00:26:43
Onto the subdivision application. 00:26:51
I will not repeat the. 00:26:54
Outline of the. 00:26:58
Project. 00:26:59
On staff review, the Petitioner has provided compliant preliminary plan for the project, including preliminary plat. Petitioner 00:27:01
has provided certification that all drainage and environmental requirements will be complied with and that there are no known 00:27:06
outstanding issues concerning IDAM. 00:27:11
Geotechnical report is not required for the property and staff. The traffic study has been completed by strained associates. 00:27:17
In the phase one environmental is not required. 00:27:25
Lots meet the size and frontage standards of the zoning ordinance. 00:27:28
General, commercial and multifamily districts. 00:27:31
Knobs Landing Blvd. is proposed as a through St. between Tuscany and Schreiber Rd. Dimensions and layout. 00:27:35
Subdivision control ordinance requirements. 00:27:43
Multiple entrances from Schreiber Rd. Knobs Landing Blvd. in Tuscany Dr. is provided. 00:27:46
Sidewalks are provided. 00:27:52
Certification to meet county drainage and stormwater standards have been provided final approval of the drainage plan. 00:27:54
Will be required prior to secondary approval. 00:28:01
The petitioner has provided willingness to serve. Letters from Floyd Knobs Water, Georgetown. 00:28:05
Township Fire Protection District, Harrison RC, New Albany Wastewater Charter and AT&T. 00:28:09
The wastewater will be provided by New Albany Storm Water. 00:28:16
Our wastewater is not. 00:28:19
Staff recommendations are just that, the. 00:28:21
Final approval of drains stormwater plans be required prior to secondary improvement. 00:28:24
For the PUD application. 00:28:30
I'll go over the PUD process. 00:28:32
So part. 00:28:34
Planned unit development is a design special district that can be pursued by an applicant. The purpose of the planned unit 00:28:36
development is to courage the flexibility to develop or redevelop land in an effort to promote appropriate uses. 00:28:42
Maintain unique character features such as natural or historic resources. 00:28:49
Promote innovative design concepts. 00:28:53
It is also designed to facilitate the economies of scale in relationship to infrastructure, public services, encouraging field 00:28:56
development. 00:28:59
PUD process. 00:29:03
Petitioner meets with staff. 00:29:05
For a conceptual step. 00:29:07
Sketch playing and playing conference, which they did on. 00:29:09
October 23rd, 2024. 00:29:13
Petitioner then submits a detailed development plan for review. 00:29:16
And submits a PUD application for Employment Commission. 00:29:19
The Plan Commission can then. 00:29:23
Provide umm. 00:29:25
A recommendation to the county commissioners. 00:29:26
In a favor favorable recommendation. 00:29:29
An unfavorable recommendation or no recommendation? 00:29:32
The county commissioners will then review the rezoning petition within 90 days and may approve or disapprove the request. Upon 00:29:36
approval, the property is officially resumed. 00:29:41
The PUD will then return to the Planning Commission for secondary approval. 00:29:46
Of the detailed development plan. 00:29:50
No additional public hearing will be required. 00:29:52
Safra views of the pod. 00:29:56
But very significantly from the zoning. 00:29:58
In subdivision control ordinances in a few areas. 00:30:01
1st. 00:30:08
It is unclear the minimum. 00:30:09
Unit size of the units. 00:30:10
We have an 800 square foot. 00:30:13
Minimum. So I would just like. 00:30:15
The applicant provide that information. 00:30:17
Density. They're requesting approximately 20.9 dwellings per acre. 00:30:20
Our multi family standard is. 00:30:25
Currently 8 is the allowed maximum. 00:30:28
We do have several developments in the county. 00:30:31
That have. 00:30:34
19 to 20, that's not built. 00:30:35
And Gateway villages has about 15. 00:30:39
Dwelling units breaker. 00:30:41
Parking 2 1/2 spaces are required per dwelling unit. 00:30:44
They have provided 1.8 for lot 1 and 1.92 for lot 2. 00:30:48
And then the buffer yard. 00:30:55
South side of the property. 00:30:56
Would require. 00:30:59
Buffer Yard 2 standards. 00:31:00
The proposed land in the in. 00:31:03
Land uses in the PUD are. 00:31:06
Are not in conflict with the spirit and intent. 00:31:08
Of the comprehensive plan, surrounding land uses and zoning districts. 00:31:11
The comprehensive plan. 00:31:16
It shows that the area is a commercial growth area. High density should be directed towards adequate infrastructure and public 00:31:18
services. 00:31:21
Proposal can be served by all utility providers without expansion. 00:31:24
In multi family style density should consider mixed land uses which is studs. 00:31:29
Zoning and surrounding land uses. The proposal is currently in the general commercial district with residential urban. 00:31:34
General commercial adjacent. 00:31:40
The proposed blood does provide adequate public service, light, air traffic control, open and more common. 00:31:43
Space and recreation. 00:31:49
The proposal does include adequate services, as evidenced. 00:31:52
Service provider letters. 00:31:55
Proposal includes reasonable traffic circulation plan. 00:31:58
Traffic impact study has been conducted. 00:32:01
And the proposal provides recreational space in the form of a pool and outdoor games area. There's also green space within the 00:32:04
development. 00:32:07
The proposed PUD is compatible with adjacent properties and surrounding neighborhood. 00:32:12
Commercial use is consistent with general commercial uses in the Highlander point in the zoning of adjacent properties, 00:32:17
multifamily residential. 00:32:21
Is appropriate with mixed uses and should be buffered from adjacent. 00:32:24
Residential uses. 00:32:29
The proposed BUD will not interfere with the use or diminish the value of adjacent properties. 00:32:31
In surrounding neighborhood. 00:32:35
Improvements on the land are expected to have positive impacts on neighboring property values. 00:32:37
Mixed retail, commercial and multi family will not diminish the use of neighborhood properties with adequate public services 00:32:42
provided. 00:32:46
Appropriate offering is required to adjourn. 00:32:50
Residential properties. 00:32:53
HUD will not diminish the level of service for roadway systems in the vicinity. 00:32:55
As the traffic impact study. 00:33:00
Concluded. 00:33:03
The proposed PUD can be immediately and adequately served by the existing public facilities and services. 00:33:05
As evidenced by the. 00:33:11
Service letters. 00:33:13
The proposed POD does preserve natural and historic. 00:33:15
Resources to every extent possible. The existing cycles of single family structure used as a commercial office. 00:33:18
The site will be cleared and new plantings consistent with the zoning ordinance Landscaping will be installed. 00:33:24
There are no known historic resources on the site. 00:33:30
Proposed PUD will not be interest to the health, safety and general welfare. The proposed plot is consistent with planning 00:33:35
documents for this area. Adequate public infrastructure is available. 00:33:40
For the development as our public services. 00:33:46
Drainage will be approved by County Stormwater consistent with their requirements. Staff recommendations are favorable 00:33:49
recommendation with the following commitments and conditions. 00:33:53
Written commitments will be phased. Phase one will be Lot 1 funding or Vincents Road and the schedule for completion of all phases 00:33:59
will be provided. 00:34:03
To the Planning Commission. 00:34:07
Prior to secondary approval. 00:34:08
Provide additional screening of dumpster on lot 1 between dumpster and roadway. 00:34:11
Provide light at entrance locations where there are none and meet Buffer Yard 2 standards for adjoining residential use to the 00:34:16
South. 00:34:20
That is the staff report for these 4. 00:34:24
Applications. 00:34:27
All righty. Thanks, Nick. Any any questions on the board? 00:34:30
You have a question. 00:34:34
Nick, you indicated. 00:34:36
There that strange associates conducted a traffic study for the project and then an acceptable. 00:34:37
Loss or level of service was was found. Those law studies typically indicate like a grade between A and F Do you have any idea 00:34:42
what the grade was for the particular project? 00:34:47
B i.e. and beyond. 00:34:53
The the level of service indicated. 00:34:57
Which is. 00:35:01
Deemed acceptable as the current level of service. 00:35:03
So any other? 00:35:09
Any other questions? 00:35:11
For Nick. 00:35:14
And they if. 00:35:16
We had a TRC on this right, a technical review committee. 00:35:17
Can we explain just a little bit to the board? 00:35:20
What came out of that meeting? What's the purpose of that meeting? Yes, the tier the plans provided to the TRC were. 00:35:24
A little bit different than what we finally have here. 00:35:30
The alignment of the site had the bank on the opposite side on Tuscany Drive. 00:35:34
Dumpster was located closer to the roadway on Knox Landing or Knox Landing Blvd. 00:35:42
There were more multifamily units. 00:35:48
So the parking. 00:35:51
Ratios were. 00:35:53
Less. 00:35:55
And there was number buffer yard. 00:35:59
For the residential. 00:36:00
Properties to the West. So they didn't make all those modifications for this final application, OK. 00:36:02
All righty. 00:36:11
So they've already adjusted. 00:36:14
The original application, is that correct? 00:36:16
At the TRC. 00:36:19
Thank you. 00:36:21
Are any other questions for Nick? 00:36:22
OK. At this point, let me go through just a little bit of a housekeeping here. 00:36:24
Because of the sensitivity of this project and the number of. 00:36:29
Agenda items we have. 00:36:34
We're going to increase the time that we allow. 00:36:36
For the applicant to present his. 00:36:38
Project and then we're going to double the times. 00:36:43
That we have for people to speak in favor, to speak in opposition, and then we will then give the applicant 5 minutes to rebut 00:36:46
anything that was so said. So just let the board know that that's what we're going to do because of the. 00:36:52
The sensitivity of this project so. 00:36:58
If the applicant would like to come forward, state his name and address. 00:37:01
We appreciate it. 00:37:05
For the record, John Craft with the law firm of Young Lind Anderson Kraft, 126 W Spring Street in New Albany. 00:37:14
Appearing on behalf of the applicant. 00:37:21
Along with the engineer which would be Jason Copper White with Paul Primavera and Associates. 00:37:23
Jackson Theneman is with me as well from Phenomenon. 00:37:28
Group LLC. 00:37:32
And then likewise Daniel Moriarty. 00:37:34
Who has designed the? 00:37:36
Project from the standpoint of the architectural piece of that. 00:37:38
So ultimately. 00:37:42
Four of us will present. 00:37:44
I'll cover first of all, as indicated, there are four items before you this evening. 00:37:47
Two of which are rezoning. 00:37:51
Which means ultimately, those two rezoning issues come to you for a recommendation. 00:37:53
Not an approval tonight, but merely. 00:37:59
A request as it relates to those zoning requirements. 00:38:02
Going forward to the county commissioners with a favorable. 00:38:06
And unfavorable or no recommendation at all. 00:38:09
Under those two elements, and again, we'll talk a little bit about each one, but under each of those elements. 00:38:13
You have to pay due consideration and these are the same considerations the commissioners will look at in order to make a 00:38:20
determination. 00:38:23
On the passage of these two ordinances. 00:38:27
Primarily, Indiana Code 3674603 covers those five elements. 00:38:30
Those five elements deal with the Comprehensive Plan and. 00:38:35
You'll hear on a. 00:38:38
PowerPoint, you'll hear Mr. Copper Weight go through those issues with regards to compliance with the current comprehensive plan. 00:38:41
Current conditions and character of current structures and uses in each district. 00:38:48
The most desirable use for which land in each district is adapted. 00:38:53
Conservation of property values throughout the jurisdiction. 00:38:57
And responsible development and growth. 00:39:01
You've probably heard a number of items covered by Mr. Creepy when he spoke. 00:39:03
Pertaining to the staff report. 00:39:07
And this is a growth area in the county? 00:39:09
Certainly, again, Mr. Copper weight will cover that more fully. 00:39:12
The piece as it relates to. 00:39:16
The change from GC, which if you look at the current zoning ordinance in Floyd County, there are 91. 00:39:18
Uses that could be put there as a matter of right. 00:39:27
Including, uh. 00:39:30
Big box commercial. 00:39:31
Including smaller units, but it is a GC in their actual 91 uses that could be put there as a matter of right. 00:39:32
One of the things that you'll hear this evening is when Mr. Feenman looked at this project. 00:39:40
He looked at it from the standpoint of dealing with. 00:39:45
Walkability. 00:39:49
Specifically, individuals as well as commercial uses don't want to go in an area now just where they're putting a commercial use. 00:39:51
They want the possibility of residents that can use that commercial area and also look at the possibility of walking to and from 00:39:58
their residence to those commercial uses. 00:40:04
When we look at the issue from a GC to the MF. 00:40:10
The multifamily. 00:40:14
Under the terms of a normal change of zoning. 00:40:16
When taking it to an MF that would allow any type of. 00:40:19
Multifamily use on this property. 00:40:23
Provided it meets the development standards of the multifamily. 00:40:26
But the other piece of the rezoning request this evening? 00:40:29
Is taking that multifamily to a PUD. 00:40:33
And the purpose of a PUD first and foremost is to deal with mixed uses. 00:40:36
On a given property. 00:40:41
But most importantly to you as well as the county commissioners as well as the community. 00:40:43
When you take a. 00:40:48
Change to an MF that allows, as long as it meets the requirements, to go as deep and as dense as you desire to do on this 6 plus 00:40:50
acres. 00:40:54
But with the change to a planned unit development district. 00:40:59
What it requires, and you heard Mr. Creevy, again go through the process because the process is one of those that if both zoning 00:41:04
changes are forwarded to the commissioners with favorable recommendations and again the commissioners passed those. 00:41:11
That ultimately. 00:41:19
The PUD must then return to you as the Plan Commission for secondary review. 00:41:20
So it's not a matter that we're getting a blank check. 00:41:26
For a change to multifamily and do what we desire to do. 00:41:29
The project itself. And that's the 4th element you'll see this evening. 00:41:33
Is the development plan. 00:41:37
But under the terms of a planned unit development district. 00:41:39
It is established by way of ordinance. So ultimately. 00:41:42
Commissioners pass that ordinance. 00:41:45
They will then adopt specific. 00:41:48
Definitions of what you may do. 00:41:50
Much again as indicated. 00:41:53
We went to the. 00:41:55
Technical Review Committee on December 18th and walk through this project in order to make certain that what we would do and what 00:41:57
the development plan would cover would be in order that we can move forward with it. 00:42:03
So it's not a matter that by granting an MF. 00:42:08
In that instance, it's a matter of granting an MF with a planned unit development district. 00:42:12
It will then designate exactly what can be put on that parcel. 00:42:17
That will then be brought back to you as the Plan Commission for secondary review. 00:42:21
Once that secondary review is granted. 00:42:26
Then from that standpoint, what you end up with is a situation of having to abide. 00:42:30
By that plan that you see in front of you. 00:42:36
If that is the secondary approval plan. 00:42:39
And as a result of that, it allows you as well as the commissioners the ability. 00:42:41
To determine what planned documentation. 00:42:47
And you heard Mr. Creedy's report, some of those elements of what needs to be provided. 00:42:50
In order to move this forward. 00:42:55
Provided. 00:42:57
It changes from MF. 00:42:58
To the PUD. 00:43:00
Those two come together. 00:43:02
And again, those would be adopted by way of an ordinance by the county commissioners. 00:43:03
The other two pieces of it. 00:43:08
Provided. 00:43:10
Those two zoning changes come forward. Those other two pieces then become ministerial in nature. 00:43:12
And that is the subdivision. 00:43:19
And as long as the subdivision meets the requirements of the subdivision control ordinance. And again when listening to the report 00:43:21
of Mr. Privy, and I'm sure you've read it. 00:43:26
Specifically, uh. 00:43:31
We meet those requirements if in fact those two zoning changes come about. 00:43:32
The other piece of it. 00:43:37
Would be the development. 00:43:39
And once again, provided that development plan meets all of the elements as to setbacks and otherwise for this zoning district. 00:43:40
With the planned unit development district. 00:43:48
Then likewise, that is a ministerial action as well. 00:43:51
We're here this evening asking specifically that these 4 dockets. 00:43:55
Be approved. 00:43:59
Two of which were asking for favorable recommendation. 00:44:00
To the county commissioners. 00:44:04
Certainly your recommendation is what the county commissioners are going to listen to. 00:44:05
The county commissioners do not have to follow your recommendation. 00:44:10
But certainly from the standpoint it in my experience over 40 plus years. 00:44:14
Most times and most often, they will follow that recommendation. So we're here this evening asking for favorable recommendation 00:44:19
on. 00:44:23
The zoning change from. 00:44:27
Our two MF from. 00:44:30
The GC as well as asking that MF be limited by way of a PUD. 00:44:33
And ask that that likewise be forwarded. 00:44:39
With a favorable recommendation. 00:44:42
I'm gonna call on. 00:44:44
Jason to go through the elements with regards to the plan itself and touch on those elements under the comprehensive plan you 00:44:46
should have in front of you. If not, it'll be on the screen a power. 00:44:51
PowerPoint presentation regarding that. Thank you. 00:44:57
All right. Thank you. How are we doing on time? 00:45:01
How much? 00:45:08
Two, he had 20. He had total 20 minutes. 00:45:09
12. 00:45:13
He got 1212 minutes. I'll try to be quick. 00:45:15
There you go. 00:45:18
Good evening, Jason Copper. Wait again with Paul from Avera and Associates. 00:45:19
I'll try not to repeat anything. 00:45:22
Mr. Creeby said, or Mr. Kraft said, though there are probably slides that you repeat that information. 00:45:24
I'll try to gloss over those if I can. 00:45:28
Again, this is knobs landing mixed-use development. 00:45:30
Located at 5031 through 50. 00:45:33
53 Old Vincennes Rd. 00:45:35
The next slide, that's the aerial of the site. 00:45:38
I don't know that anyone's actually showing you that when they were talking, but it's the southwest quadrant of the intersection 00:45:41
of Shriver Rd. 00:45:43
And open sense you can see to the West as villas of Floyd Knobs. 00:45:46
To the South as a single family residence and the Highlands that's still developing NE is Highlander Point. 00:45:50
Just to the east of this Planning Commission may remember. 00:45:56
You've approved a bank development plan at that site. 00:45:59
Don't know when that will be developed, but it's coming. 00:46:02
This is the zoning map for the area. The red is general commercial GC. 00:46:04
The orange is residential urban. 00:46:08
Are you? 00:46:10
These are the four applications that have been talked about already. 00:46:12
This is an artist rendering that Mister Moriarty prepared for the site. 00:46:17
You can see. 00:46:21
Prize and help you, but there are two buildings on the north lot. 00:46:23
One building on the South with some amenities together on the north lot. 00:46:26
This is the. 00:46:31
My engineering version of his color rendering which shows a little bit more detail. It has turned 90°. Apologize for that. 00:46:32
But again, it's just a little bit more detailed. 00:46:40
So it is 6.4 acres. It will be. 00:46:43
The plan is to divide it into two lots. 00:46:46
Mr. Creepy went through the particulars. Just to highlight those, Building 1 is 7717 square foot of ground floor retail. 00:46:49
With a leasing office, clubhouse. 00:46:57
59 multifamily dwelling units, 21 of which are two-bedroom, 38 of which are one bedroom. 00:46:58
Google and other outdoor amenities are proposed there. 00:47:03
Building 2 is 66 multifamily dwelling units, 24 two-bedroom and 42 one bedroom. This that's on the South lot and building 3 is a 00:47:06
3600 square foot. 00:47:11
Bank Retail. 00:47:15
With a drive through. 00:47:17
These are the zoning. 00:47:20
Change characteristics that Mister Kraft talked about earlier. 00:47:22
So I took excerpts from your comprehensive plan that I that I felt showed that this site. 00:47:28
Met the requirements. 00:47:33
As Mr. Creeby said, smart growth, it's kind of buzzword throughout your comprehensive plan. 00:47:35
Smart Growth is a planning theory designed toward the efficient use of land, resources and existing urban infrastructure. 00:47:40
And your in your comp plan list. 00:47:45
10 smart growth principles, of which we probably meet 8. 00:47:48
Mixed land uses where appropriate. 00:47:52
Take advantage of compact building design. 00:47:54
Create a range of housing opportunities throughout the jurisdiction. 00:47:56
Create walkable communities. You'll see the pedestrian infrastructure we're proposing. 00:47:59
Preserve open space. Now you could say this is not preserving open space. 00:48:06
But what this does is it brings people to a developed area where there is infrastructure that allows remaining properties to the 00:48:09
county to remain. 00:48:13
To remain open and undeveloped. 00:48:17
Strengthen development Development toward existing communities. 00:48:20
Again at Highlander Point. 00:48:23
We're at Highlander Point. 00:48:25
And then? 00:48:28
Encourage community and stakeholder collaboration. 00:48:30
You have a very interactive process, as you know with TRC meetings. 00:48:33
We took that TRC meeting and those comments from that TRC meeting to heart. 00:48:36
And made very significant changes to the plan. 00:48:40
The original proposal was, I think, about 156 multifamily dwellings, dwelling units. 00:48:43
And a comparable number of retail. 00:48:48
The developer shrunk that to 125, split the bank out, per TRC comments. 00:48:51
Added the buffering we'll talk about. 00:48:55
So he's listening is the point. He's listening and adapting. 00:48:58
Theme places to live a lot again, a lot of those. 00:49:02
Objectives from the goals meet this this project. I can give you copies of this. 00:49:07
When we're finished. 00:49:12
Promoting locally grown and owned. 00:49:13
It is anticipated that a lot of these retail establishments will be local businesses, locally owned businesses. 00:49:16
We're thinking the bank is going to be a relatively small regional bank. 00:49:22
Not a necessarily a National Bank. 00:49:26
Then your comp plan says direct hire residential developments toward areas of the proximity to adequate infrastructure and public 00:49:30
services. 00:49:33
Where appropriate, higher density. 00:49:36
Patio homes. Multi family development should be directed toward established urban areas based on proximity to existing services 00:49:38
and density. 00:49:42
Multi family development should be limited to area to areas where they're again access to commercial. 00:49:45
Surrounded by utilities. 00:49:51
The comp plan designates the Highlander Point as a commercial growth area. 00:49:54
Everyone realizes that. 00:49:58
A commercial should be. 00:50:01
Targeted toward Highlander. The Highlander Point corridor specifically says that. 00:50:02
This is the Georgetown Township excerpt from the comp plan. 00:50:07
That that. 00:50:11
Dark dark box in the upper right hand corner is the location of this. 00:50:12
The comp plan for Georgetown mostly focuses on the Edwardsville. 00:50:16
Gateway and the Edwardsville Interchange because this site really is more closely related to the Lafayette Township. The east 00:50:20
boundary of This site is Lafayette Township. 00:50:25
So this is the Lafayette Township map. 00:50:30
Map with the box showing the area again. It shows that as an intense development area by your comp plan. 00:50:32
Future land use in Georgetown Township would be directed toward existing infrastructure. That's a theme throughout your comp plan. 00:50:40
I'll try and skip that. 00:50:44
Commercial again at. 00:50:49
And this is average for Gateway for Georgetown? 00:50:50
Same language in Lafayette even says similar to Georgetown. 00:50:53
And then future commercial will be located at Hallander Point. 00:50:57
Properties already zoned commercial, but we are. 00:51:00
Continuing to implement. 00:51:03
Commercial element. 00:51:04
This project. 00:51:06
Current conditions and structures. 00:51:07
Again, there there is quite a bit of development happening and that has happened around this area. 00:51:09
You have Highlander Point Commercial. 00:51:14
District East. 00:51:16
You have additional commercial just east of this with the gas station. 00:51:17
Williamsburg Station, the bank that's coming in. 00:51:21
This project, as Nick said, would. 00:51:25
It's a nice transition from. 00:51:28
Commercial. Intense commercial. 00:51:30
Through higher density residential to lower density, even though it's still your residential urban. 00:51:31
Zoning. 00:51:37
And then this is a rendering of the building which you've seen in the package. 00:51:38
It is a very similar to what you see right across the street. 00:51:42
So the subdivision it is 2 commercial lots. 00:51:49
Would be a new road connecting the stub and villas of Floyd Knobs to Schreiber. 00:51:51
And if the MF and PUD MF are approved, the subdivision would meet all your requirements. 00:51:56
John talked about what a PUD means. 00:52:06
So the PUD in this particular case also. 00:52:09
Satisfies the development plan. I'll mention that later, but keep in mind when I'm talking about these PUD plans, I'm also talking 00:52:12
about the development plan. 00:52:15
Again, this is the engineering. 00:52:19
Site plan to support the development plan and the PUD. 00:52:21
It does feature the three buildings. 00:52:25
Also, it features the amenities. There's a swimming pool plan on lot 1. 00:52:27
There's an outdoor kitchen and outdoor seating and the outdoor games area that Mister Creeby mentioned earlier. 00:52:32
As well as open space to the West. 00:52:37
That those facilities are intended to serve both. 00:52:40
Both Watts in the neighborhood. 00:52:44
Same parameters I listed earlier. 00:52:47
There are two entrances from Lot 11 onto the proposed road and one on to Tuscany. 00:52:50
There are three interests from Lot 2, one on to Shriver and two onto the proposed roadway. 00:52:55
There are pedestrian walks and crossings throughout the site. 00:53:00
One interesting feature of the site is that is that once the traffic signal is installed at Schreiber. 00:53:02
That has pedestrian crosswalks included as part of the project. 00:53:09
You'll be able to walk from villas of Floyd Knobs or the Highlands all the way to anywhere you want to go in Highlander Point. 00:53:12
It's going to, it's going to facilitate pedestrian access for that whole region. 00:53:18
Again, the amenities on Lot 1. 00:53:23
Parking. 00:53:26
Lot 1. We've allocated 50 spaces for the proposed retail bank. 00:53:28
That leaves 1100. 00:53:33
111 spaces for the multifamily which is 1.88. 00:53:35
Spaces per dwelling unit. 00:53:38
127 spaces on Lot 2. 00:53:40
Which? 00:53:43
Yields 1.92 spaces per dwelling unit. 00:53:44
Mr. Creeby mentioned that your ordinance requires 2.5 spaces per dwelling unit. It makes no distinction as to whether they're one 00:53:47
bedroom or two-bedroom. 00:53:51
I personally believe that's overparked. 00:53:55
I did pick up the. 00:53:58
Institute of Traffic Engineers Parking generation manual. 00:54:00
They indicate that retail is. 00:54:03
5.45 spaces per 1000 square foot of retail, which would be 6 about 62 spaces required. 00:54:07
One bedroom units are 1.38 spaces per unit. 00:54:13
And a two-bedroom unit is 2.08 spaces per unit. 00:54:17
Using a total requirement per ITE. 00:54:19
About 265 and we're providing 288. 00:54:22
And I can give you copies of this. 00:54:26
After the presentation. 00:54:27
Lot area. 00:54:30
So lot 1. 00:54:31
The the pool and the recreation area to me should be included in open space. 00:54:33
If you don't include it in open space. 00:54:37
Or if you we have 68.8% impervious area. 00:54:40
If you do include it as open space, we have 61.5. 00:54:44
The MF ordinance require it allows 65. 00:54:48
Lot 2 we have a 71.5. 00:54:52
Making an overall of 69.85. 00:54:55
Or if you exclude the right out the recreation area is 65.4 so very close to what MF? 00:54:58
Would otherwise allow. 00:55:04
We do have significant landscaping and as Mr. Crete. 00:55:06
We do meet the ordinance as far as plantings along the roadways. 00:55:09
Parking lot screening and parking islands with plantings. 00:55:13
And then we did add the buffer along the West side for bills of fluid knobs. 00:55:17
With a wall that is concrete. 00:55:22
With plantings behind it, which is specified as a type 2 buffer. 00:55:24
We did not do that along. 00:55:28
The South Side. 00:55:30
I spoke with Mr. Tieneman after we received Mr. Kibe staff report. He is willing to do that but he would like to make a change. 00:55:32
Previously, the wall was planned to be brick on both sides. 00:55:39
He spent a lot of time in Florida lately and they have products there that would be concrete walls with stucco. 00:55:42
On either side that are still very attractive. 00:55:48
And so. 00:55:51
He would extend this wall to be 300 feet. 00:55:52
Along the South line. 00:55:54
There's a Creek that runs from that wider island there. 00:55:56
We can. Once you get past that Creek, it really doesn't make sense to buffer that area. So he would extend the buffer the wall. 00:55:59
That extra 300 feet with the plantings and that would then meet the requirements of type 2. 00:56:05
That that about 70 foot stretch. 00:56:10
On the east side of the Creek would not, but we still have the plantings there. 00:56:12
And you can see that's the front yard of the neighbor. 00:56:16
It should be less intrusive to him at that area. 00:56:20
The lighting plan meets the standards of the ordinance. No no fixture is taller than 20 feet and it's all down lighting. 00:56:24
These are the proposed lighting fixtures. 00:56:31
Just so we're showing a unified. 00:56:33
Design The sign plan meets the requirements of the ordinance. There are two monument signs, one at Tuscany and one at Knox Lane 00:56:35
Knox Landing Blvd. at Schreiber. 00:56:41
And all the building signage would comply with the existing sign against. 00:56:46
Ordinance the building facades. It's an attractive building. It meets the state requirements of the Highlander Point Overlay 00:56:50
District. 00:56:53
Brick, stone and Hardy. 00:56:57
You've seen that. 00:56:59
This is a blow up of the building 1. 00:57:01
Rendering This is a blow up of the Building 2 rendering which is on the South lot. 00:57:04
And this is the the bank with building one in the background. 00:57:08
OK. So common concerns that we hear always traffic. I know you've heard it from the audience today. 00:57:15
I'm not sure how many people are aware, but the county is planning to install a traffic signal at Shriver and Old Vincennes. 00:57:20
That has been in the plan. They're also upgrading Open Olden Sins. 00:57:27
The traffic study indicates that. 00:57:30
The intersections as proposed in the design year for original traffic study will also operate an acceptable level. 00:57:33
With additional traffic from this proposed development. 00:57:38
Drainage Fluke County is the most stringent drainage requirements in the region. 00:57:41
We anticipate stormwater and underground detention facilities circled there in the light blue. 00:57:46
That that wider island that you saw is the discharge town. 00:57:52
And then the county had commissioned a study for this whole area back in 2021. 00:57:56
That showed if development continued in accordance with your stormwater ordinance, that things will get better overtime. 00:58:01
Questions. 00:58:09
OK, you didn't do bad. You missed about 15 seconds. Sorry about that. 00:58:11
I do have a question OK, any that's why any questions for Mr. 00:58:15
I'm a little unclear on your on your wall. 00:58:20
On your wall. 00:58:23
Are you leaving Brick at Tuscany? 00:58:25
Are you switching it wanting to switch it all to the stucco wall? 00:58:27
He would request that we could switch it all to the stucco wall. 00:58:32
Because of the additional length. 00:58:35
That's a request. 00:58:37
So when you're you're saying 300 feet. 00:58:38
This is the additional approximately 300 feet. 00:58:41
Cortana. 00:58:46
That's the landscape plan. This is the 300 feet you're talking about, correct? 00:58:48
It's it's this. 00:58:52
It's this area here. 00:58:53
Just that's that's turned, yes, just short of that wider island there. 00:58:56
You do show. 00:59:03
60 foot of a vinyl fence. 00:59:06
Oh. 00:59:09
That's for parking lot screening. 00:59:10
Your ordinance requires a three foot understand why is it there? 00:59:13
I'm just wondering if we should make it. 00:59:18
Match the rest of the ball. 00:59:20
Question something? 00:59:23
Instead of final, maybe 60 feet. 00:59:26
I, I'm going to, I'm going to step out on a limb and say, well, that's. 00:59:29
I just think it ought to match I guess. 00:59:34
No problem. 00:59:36
My first meeting SO. 00:59:39
Indulge me, what were you talking about the fence parking lot then? 00:59:44
There. 00:59:49
There's a little piece of fence right here. 00:59:51
That's supposed to be final. 00:59:54
You're in the part of our ordinance says you've got to screen the parking lot. 00:59:56
Correct. The ordinance requires any parking that faces a street or a neighbor has to be screened with three foot tall shrubs. 00:59:59
Over 3 foot tall fence. 01:00:06
So we can't fit shrubs in that area because it's tied up to the right of way. 01:00:08
So I was proposing a fence. 01:00:11
Battle. If it has to be a wall, I don't. 01:00:13
I think that's a yeah. 01:00:16
Yeah, understood. 01:00:18
Yeah, this may be a question for the developer, but in terms of the. 01:00:20
Target renter. 01:00:24
Are we looking at Class A facilities or what kind of amenities, what kind of people are we targeting? 01:00:26
To inhabit the buildings, what he's told me is granite countertops, you know, very nice facilities. I think he's targeting the 01:00:31
minimum rent to be 1500. 01:00:35
For a one bedroom. 01:00:40
Well, give me a. 01:00:42
All right. Anybody else? 01:00:46
I do have one question, the Connector Rd. that's that is proposed, will there be parking allowed on that road? No. OK. Will you 01:00:51
make sure that that's. 01:00:56
Either signage or somehow. 01:01:01
Make sure that doesn't happen because I could see that. 01:01:03
In advance I could get. 01:01:06
Crowded. 01:01:08
All right, go ahead next. 01:01:10
That will be a county. 01:01:14
Road County. 01:01:15
Oh, it's Canada. 01:01:17
They will. They'll. 01:01:19
It'll be dedicated to the county after it's called, so it's dedicated to the county. 01:01:21
OK, All right. Makes it so we'll let Frank make that decision. 01:01:26
No. 01:01:33
Oh, I meant to start out. 01:01:35
And say that. 01:01:40
I appreciate all the changes that were made, I think. 01:01:42
Several of the comments came from me about. 01:01:47
Moving the bank and. 01:01:49
All of that and I think it's a much improved plan over what was originally presented, so. 01:01:50
You reduce the number of apartments, you move the bank. 01:01:57
So I do like to plan much better than was originally submitted. 01:02:01
Great. Thank you. 01:02:05
All right. At this time, what we'd like to do. 01:02:07
And and just I'd like for everybody just be respectful. 01:02:10
And kind of hold your comments down, if you will. 01:02:13
We're going to we're going to open up 20 minute session. 01:02:16
For anybody that like to speak in favor of this project, come forward in favor. 01:02:19
In favor. 01:02:24
OK, state your name. 01:02:26
I'd like to thank them for all the wonderful. I need your name and address, I'm sorry. 01:02:30
OK. 01:02:35
And I have an 8047 Schreiber Rd. 01:02:36
But I am speaking in favor of this project. I respect the wonderful things he has provided our community. 01:02:39
So I will say thank you for that, but. 01:02:47
You know, we don't always build wonderful things. I'm gonna support something that's not so wonderful because I can think of. 01:02:50
1019 people you know since. 01:02:56
Friday night. 01:02:59
That think this is a bad idea. 01:03:00
So I think he'll need a little support. 01:03:02
I'll say that the idea that they didn't have enough room to put shrubbery behind the fence, it's laughable. 01:03:04
The idea that. 01:03:10
You know pedestrians will be playing in a roundabout. 01:03:11
That's going to be built in the future. 01:03:15
Is asinine. 01:03:17
I mean, I know you all might have agendas or might have your minds made-up, but this is a bad idea. This does not. 01:03:19
I don't know if you read the same comprehensive plan that I did the same, you know, Highlander point. 01:03:26
Gateway plan that I read, but I guess it's up for interpretation. 01:03:32
This is zoning change. 01:03:36
I don't believe. 01:03:38
That that zoning change fits the vision that you had been outlaid. 01:03:39
That I read about. 01:03:43
I can say that. 01:03:45
When I read about the Highlander point plan. 01:03:46
It was unfavorable to have multifamily housing in that area. That was the least. 01:03:49
The least liked proposal. 01:03:53
So what's changed? 01:03:55
We don't need the destination. 01:03:57
You know, if you have pedestrians, it's going to be even more chaos. 01:04:00
And it's already bad and terrible traffic. 01:04:04
I like this area. This is a great area. I think we are going to be. 01:04:07
Value is by allowing this to go through. 01:04:10
So I implore you, please. 01:04:13
Don't. 01:04:16
Don't let this happen. 01:04:17
This is a nice place. We should have nice places. People should aspire to be in nice places. We want to encourage home ownership, 01:04:20
not rental. OK, I'm going to cut you. Cut you off. 01:04:25
I think you've taken. 01:04:30
More in an opposition side than a favorable side, so. 01:04:32
But we'll. 01:04:35
We'll let you come back up and take the time away from the opposition if you want to. I'm just trying to be fair here. 01:04:36
Thank you very much. 01:04:42
This is in favor. 01:04:43
Please. 01:04:44
More than in the favor. 01:04:45
I'm saying your name and your address. Brian's are sweet. OK, I live in the house South. 01:04:47
If you bring the picture back up, just tell us your address please. 01:04:54
It's 5007 over in Saints Row, its original house. Go ahead. 01:04:57
Main road was my driveway. 01:05:02
OK. 01:05:05
If she can get rid of the thing up there. 01:05:06
You just go ahead with your comments please. What I'm trying to do is. 01:05:10
You're changing the. 01:05:14
The Creek you're putting. 01:05:15
660 inch pipes in. 01:05:18
It's going to come down to my driveway, which is a 24 inch. I'm going to have to stop you too. It sounds like you're in 01:05:22
opposition. 01:05:25
No, no, no, I'm not in opposition. 01:05:28
Get this on the record. 01:05:31
Why the engineers people were here and the developers. Do you have some positive to say about this project? I'm just trying to get 01:05:33
you to let me tell you what I need to do because I'm the guy on the side that's going to be effective. OK, I'm going to ask you to 01:05:39
come up when the opposition time comes up, if you don't mind, Sir. 01:05:45
You're talking, I'm just trying to explain to me what. 01:05:51
I want you to put in. 01:05:55
For the engineers to do, it's not going to be a. 01:05:57
You know, either would. 01:06:00
Yeah, it's just trying to tell you. Do you have something to say in favor of this petition? 01:06:01
Is the question yes or no? 01:06:07
If you do, say it. 01:06:10
I'm Either way, you need to sit down, Sir. Thank you very much for your time. 01:06:11
Winner, Let me one more. 01:06:16
Officer, would you please remove this man from this meeting? 01:06:18
All because I live next door. 01:06:25
I asked you to sit down three times, Sir. I'm sorry. 01:06:28
All right, one more, one more time. 01:06:34
Is there anybody that has anything that they like to say in favor of this project? Please come forward. 01:06:36
In favor. 01:06:42
Please umm. 01:06:44
Ladies and gentlemen, we have a process and please respect it. 01:06:47
We're just, we're doing a job up here. If we're trying to do our job, please let us do it. That's all I ask you. 01:06:50
We're going to give everybody the same respect. 01:06:56
That's all I ask you to do. 01:06:58
Anybody else in favor of this, please step forward. 01:07:00
OK. Is there any Sherry? 01:07:03
We got we got an off site location because. 01:07:07
Our elevator is broke down. Sherry, would you come forward and tell us whether we have somebody there once I speak in favor of 01:07:11
this? 01:07:14
No, you do not. OK. Thank you, Sherry. Appreciate. 01:07:19
OK at this time. 01:07:23
If you will start the. 01:07:26
Go ahead. Laram, Sarah. 01:07:27
I will. I will. 01:07:31
At this time we start the timer for the opposition And what I asked. 01:07:32
Hold on. 01:07:37
Please give us a minute here. 01:07:37
What I ask you to do is. 01:07:40
For the for the courtesy of people that want to speak. 01:07:42
If somebody already brought something up about. 01:07:45
The traffic. 01:07:47
Are something that drainage or something that? 01:07:49
Please don't repeat it, save room for somebody has something new to say but. 01:07:51
At that point this gentleman. 01:07:55
Right here, if you will. 01:07:57
Remember, there's people behind you, so give us give them time, please. And we do just so that everybody's on the same page. We do 01:07:59
have a time limit. It's 20 minutes. 01:08:03
That is for everyone that wishes to speak in opposition so. 01:08:07
It's 10 minutes normally on our PER. 01:08:12
For our requirements. 01:08:15
Well I think what they see is so on the screen it does say 10. That is because it only allows her to do 10. So when it hits 10 she 01:08:17
will reset it for another 10 so. 01:08:21
That is for everyone, not for each person. Yeah, we will get back to 20. It's just thank you. 01:08:26
My name is Bill Emerson. I live at 339 Custody Drive in the village of Floyd's Knobs. 01:08:33
We bought our. 01:08:39
Lot in 2020 and. 01:08:40
Don theme and build up. 01:08:43
House quality house that we wanted. 01:08:44
During our meeting with Mr. Theme and we asked what he would be building on the adjacent property. 01:08:47
Which we're talking about today. 01:08:53
He said. 01:08:55
Build a medical services building along old business ends and might build a senior community with possible assisted living 01:08:57
community. 01:09:00
On the rest of the acreage? 01:09:04
That sounded good to us. 01:09:06
We love living the village of Floyd's Knobs. 01:09:08
Walk me to our location for the convenience of having amenities that we wanted nearby. 01:09:11
I would much rather the Don Theman build what he suggested to us. 01:09:17
Rather than the. 01:09:22
I do not support the project as presented tonight. 01:09:25
I would really like to see. 01:09:29
Mr. Thieneman. 01:09:32
Complete the villas. 01:09:33
Rather than us having to continue to live in the construction. 01:09:35
Zone site. They're in Phillips. 01:09:39
I like the houses he builds, he does a great job. 01:09:44
But if you drove up into the villas or you drove over to the other. 01:09:47
Project over in Georgetown. 01:09:51
It's an unfinished project. 01:09:53
And and those of us who live there. 01:09:55
Are really held hostage? 01:09:58
By an unfinished project where we can't have our own homeowners association until Dawn finishes the project. 01:10:00
I really wish you all would put something in. 01:10:07
And your bylaws or whatever if a project is started. 01:10:10
Then it needs to be finished at some particular point. 01:10:15
Our development was not that large that it couldn't be finished. 01:10:19
And the and the other piece of that is. 01:10:23
The walkability. 01:10:25
We have sidewalks once our house is built. 01:10:27
But we have large amounts of space in our in our. 01:10:31
On Tuscany. On Milan. 01:10:34
That we have to walk in the street. 01:10:36
So it's a walkability neighborhood. 01:10:38
But Don hasn't finished the sidewalks. 01:10:41
That are that need to be finished they cross the line across Tuscany so anyway. 01:10:45
I do not agree with Mr. Cooperates to comment about. 01:10:52
This states that the rezoning would not be injurious to the value of the profit in the area. 01:10:56
Come on, when did you ever put apartments next to? 01:11:02
Houses and never lowered the property. 01:11:06
And I'd say the same thing there. 01:11:09
You put apartments next to houses, you lower the property. 01:11:11
I'm grateful that the original location of the bank. 01:11:16
Has been moved. I'm glad that the project is not as large as it once was. I appreciate that. 01:11:19
The change in the fence. 01:11:27
I want the masonry brick fence. 01:11:29
I'm with the masonry. 01:11:32
I don't want the stucco fence. I've seen them. Nice. 01:11:35
But what? 01:11:39
We have is. 01:11:40
I want the brick fence. 01:11:42
My biggest concern about the project. 01:11:46
Is. 01:11:49
The dumpsters. 01:11:50
One of them is right there at the entrance to Tuscany Drive. 01:11:52
Right by very first house on the left on Tuscany. 01:11:56
You've got a you've got a 24 foot dumpster corral. 01:12:01
And then right behind the winnings house back there on the second building be built. 01:12:05
Also is a large dumpster corral right behind those homes? 01:12:10
I don't want I don't know how often they pick up those dumpsters and apartments, whether that's once a week or. 01:12:16
Three times a week. 01:12:21
I just I don't want the. 01:12:23
This put the dumpsters. 01:12:25
Does your way? 01:12:27
Sir, you have to talk to us. You can't talk to anybody. I'm sorry. 01:12:32
Move the dumpsters. 01:12:42
Move the dump. 01:12:44
And if you move the dumpsters. 01:12:45
I can. I can probably live with it. 01:12:47
That I don't like where the dumpsters are at all for the people in the village of Floyd's Knobs. 01:12:49
So anyway, I would encourage you to make those changes before you vote tonight. 01:12:57
All right. Thank you, Bill. 01:13:01
All right, come forward. State your name and address for us, Sir. 01:13:03
10th Interest Property owner .740 N Luther Rd. I cannot think of anything that would cause more problems. 01:13:06
On old Vincennes Rd. in the traffic flow then this project right here. 01:13:13
It is time for the people to speak up. 01:13:18
We have a nightmare there, we all know it. 01:13:20
We all know it, the change in zoning. 01:13:24
Is wrong. 01:13:26
Is wrong. Saying pedestrian traffic can crossover Vincent's road is crazy. 01:13:28
Somebody's gonna die. 01:13:33
I drive that bus through there twice a day and it is a nightmare. 01:13:35
Now I need that. 01:13:39
Were certified letters. 01:13:40
Sent out for this yet? 01:13:42
For affected property owners in here. 01:13:44
No, we're just OK. 01:13:46
You want that? You want me to answer that? 01:13:48
Yeah, go ahead. OK. Have they been sent out? 01:13:50
Yes, they have. 01:13:53
Yes. 01:13:55
Just us. 01:13:57
Personally, pardon me, was there a list? The reason I ask is this in the past? 01:13:59
You see, they were sent out. I can take the past 10 years. 01:14:04
I was always included because if you go too deep on that. 01:14:07
Especially because of the drainage problem. 01:14:11
I want to see. 01:14:14
Really tough drainage plan. 01:14:16
I want to see it. 01:14:19
You held it up. 01:14:21
On the on the. 01:14:22
Project before over there. 01:14:25
The Highlands. 01:14:27
And this here, I catch 8, I catch 90% of this. You all know that everybody knows. 01:14:29
But I don't want to see a change in zoning here. 01:14:34
We have enough problems on Old Vincent's Road. 01:14:37
Here's a great example very quickly. 01:14:41
22 Prosser buses leave Floyd Central at. 01:14:44
7:30. 01:14:48
In the morning. 01:14:50
They have to fight to get the OH Vincent Rd. They have to fight to get 150 interchange. By the time they get them through 01:14:52
Charlestown Road and down to Prosser, it's time to bring them home. Education is slipping in this county because of them. 01:14:59
Things like that. Right now I asked for a. 01:15:06
Negative. 01:15:09
Recommendation for this? 01:15:11
No more traffic. 01:15:12
No more building in that area. 01:15:15
Thank you, Mr. 01:15:16
Your name and address please. 01:15:21
Names Andrew Gromac. I live at 8042 Tribal Rd. in the islands UMM. 01:15:23
Evening Commission Board, Real quick, I have a question for you. I just moved here from Arizona in August. 01:15:28
Are you guys elected officials? 01:15:34
Or just how does that work? Everybody at this table is appointed except. 01:15:36
Point on this board. 01:15:42
On this board is appointed OK, OK, so you're not this general right here you want to buy the he's appointed. 01:15:43
OK. Yes, Sir. Well, the reason I bring that up is. 01:15:49
As of. 01:15:51
Just before this meeting, if you go to Change.org, there is 1017 signatures. 01:15:52
From this area that are opposed to this development plan. 01:15:58
Coming from Arizona, where I live is the 4th largest metropolitan area in the United States right now. 01:16:04
I moved in an area that was. 01:16:09
Semi rural. 01:16:11
And watch apartment buildings go up around my my house year after year after year. Over 15 years went from non. 01:16:12
No crime at all. 01:16:20
To prime rampant throughout my area. 01:16:21
The average rent in my neighborhood in the Highlands, I'd have to say is anywhere from. 01:16:25
Mortgage is 2500 to mine is just a little over 3000. 01:16:30
When you're putting. 01:16:34
Apartments up here. 01:16:36
These people don't have any skin in the game. They don't own the area that will own their apartments. They don't have any 01:16:38
incentive to take care of the area. 01:16:41
So besides the traffic, that's already been discussed. 01:16:45
And everything else. 01:16:48
I'm politely asking. 01:16:49
The board to vote nay on this as well. 01:16:51
I'm telling you guys that. 01:16:54
The Knobs area moved in here because it's rural enough. 01:16:55
Where it's semi big city but not big city. You start doing this, the domino effect is going to happen and I promise you guys 01:16:58
you're not going to like the outcome. 01:17:02
Thank you. Thank you, Sir. 01:17:05
Restate your name and address for the address. 01:17:11
It's a good thing we're all here right now, because we'd all be stuck at the light at 1:50 for another 5 or 6 more turns if we 01:17:15
were all heading home right now. 01:17:20
I don't trust a word that the theemans say. If anybody knows what has happened, up it. 01:17:25
Heritage Springs neighborhood that he was able to swindle a Dollar General and duplexes. 01:17:30
After his plans already went through. 01:17:35
I know the neighborhood. 01:17:38
Residents tried to fight him on that and somehow he had wording that. 01:17:39
Was able to get through and so that. 01:17:43
Didn't workout well for them. 01:17:45
I have more concern with my schools. 01:17:47
My kids and I have all gone through Naomi Blue County Schools. We had the largest middle school in the state of Indiana, which is 01:17:50
not a record I would like to hold. 01:17:54
Because it's way too many kids. 01:17:59
There's not a cap size on classrooms in the state of Indiana, which is also a problem to me because I'm pretty sure the fire 01:18:02
department should have one. 01:18:05
But you putting in all of these? 01:18:10
Residential apartments is going to just. 01:18:12
Ruin. I asked. 01:18:16
Ruin the class sizes for one. I mean, the teachers are already capped, they can't handle anymore. 01:18:18
The kids can't get through lunch lines. 01:18:23
Because they are in the longest lunch line ever, they can't sit there and eat. Your kids will come home and tell you that they 01:18:25
didn't get to eat lunch today because the line was so long. The buses are so full. 01:18:31
You've been into JC or tried to get something at the pharmacy. You're in a 40 minute line trying to cash out. 01:18:38
And get your prescriptions picked up because the grocery store can't handle the population that's already there. 01:18:44
So it's not just about the traffic, it's about the schools, it's about the community that we've tried to keep. 01:18:50
And businesses maybe would be OK in that space. 01:18:57
But that many apartments is just a ridiculous amount of people moving into our area. 01:19:01
And you can say you did a traffic study. 01:19:07
I don't believe it at all. 01:19:10
And then there's word that you're not going to let they're going to change the traffic pattern to where you can't go straight 01:19:11
across Walgreens. 01:19:15
Across 150 that they're going to change it to turn and go up. 01:19:20
To your girls Rd. up to 1 old Vincennes the other way and have to try. 01:19:23
Turn around. That makes no sense, but I heard that today from Qatar construction people. 01:19:27
So. 01:19:32
Obviously not in favor of this and I think more. 01:19:34
My kids school. 01:19:37
Than anything at this point. 01:19:38
Thank you. Thank you, Taylor. 01:19:40
I am speaking in the proper time now. My name is Aaron Jones, 8047 Trevor Rd. 01:19:47
There are individuals that approach me that have been unable to sign this petition for one reason or another, whether they do not 01:19:53
have. 01:19:56
This dude or did not want to, but similar number here. 01:19:59
So I just want to state that. 01:20:02
But I'll say that. 01:20:04
From where I where I moved from? 01:20:05
We are very familiar with this issue. 01:20:07
I worked very hard to be here. 01:20:09
I did my research. I looked at the zoning. I looked at hydrology. I looked at traffic studies. I studied. 01:20:12
I believed in this community. 01:20:18
I truly did. I wanted to be here. I chose to be here. 01:20:19
I worked my **** off to be. 01:20:22
So my family would happen. 01:20:24
Access to better opportunities than I did. 01:20:25
Coming from Jefferson County, they built. 01:20:28
This low income, luxury whatever apartments everywhere around me within the South end of Louisville. 01:20:30
And you can see how well that's going for them. 01:20:35
And how the problems that they have. And I ask you, do you want to be like Louisville? I have faith in you all. 01:20:37
I feel like we can be better than Louisville. I'm not saying we are better, I'm just saying that. 01:20:43
Our government. 01:20:46
Can work better than rules because we can all see how the government is working. We do not want to be like Louisville. I am a 01:20:47
refugee. 01:20:50
I literally. 01:20:54
Don't want to be back right where I was. 01:20:55
And once this goes through, it's gonna set precedent work to keep happening and we do not want to devalue our area, whether that 01:20:58
be New Albany here there. 01:21:02
We have something beautiful that works. We can make it work. 01:21:06
But if we. 01:21:10
Changing areas that don't need changing. 01:21:11
In ways that. 01:21:13
We don't support. 01:21:14
It doesn't make sense. 01:21:15
He could put this anywhere. This is 6 acres. There are other parcels. 01:21:17
And this is zoned. 01:21:21
In a way that does not support this. 01:21:23
So. 01:21:25
I don't know why this is an argument. 01:21:26
I know he has every right. I think I believe in the free market. I only tell him he can't tell what he wants to. 01:21:28
But I believe in the zoning. That's why I bought my house. 01:21:32
It's commercial. I don't have to worry about this. 01:21:35
But now I'm in the same boat. 01:21:38
That's just. 01:21:40
I'm sorry that is. 01:21:41
It is sickening to me. 01:21:43
I'm Scott Sugar, I live at 6378 old Vincennes Rd. 01:21:52
I retired up here from the Army as a engineer officer. 01:21:57
I am going to touch on a little bit of what some of the other people. 01:22:01
And spoke about. 01:22:04
But really what I'm going to do is I'm going to ask some questions that I think every. 01:22:06
One for the traffic study. 01:22:11
Everyone that drives that area goes through those intersections. 01:22:13
At 1:50 no Vincents. 01:22:16
They know what chaos it is at certain times of day. 01:22:18
For a lot of people it is a stressful. 01:22:21
Event just going through. 01:22:23
That intersection. 01:22:25
Making it past Highlander Point headed down to the school. 01:22:27
The other thing I want everybody. 01:22:30
School buses go through there every day. 01:22:32
And. 01:22:37
Everybody who has a student down there at Highland Hills. 01:22:39
Or at Void Central. 01:22:42
Every day we get calls about the school bus situation. 01:22:44
Routes canceled. 01:22:48
This and. 01:22:49
And it's usually two to three a day, honestly. 01:22:50
So that's one challenge. 01:22:52
And this will impact. 01:22:54
The challenges that. 01:22:56
The Floyd County school system has. 01:22:58
With uh. 01:23:00
School traffic, School bus traffic, getting kids to school sometimes. 01:23:01
It's a safety concern. 01:23:05
The question I have is with that traffic study. 01:23:07
Did they account in that traffic study for all the other construction that's going to be going on? 01:23:10
Up just north of. 01:23:15
The JC. 01:23:17
Because. 01:23:21
You put this in, it's already going to overtax. 01:23:23
A stressful area right there. 01:23:27
That intersection. 01:23:29
Put even more construction in if there's already plans. 01:23:30
Multi Housing. 01:23:34
North of the JC? What kind of impact? 01:23:36
And a half of that intersection. 01:23:38
When we put the stop light in there. 01:23:41
That's already going to happen. 01:23:44
Act regardless of where you put this, intersect this. 01:23:46
Complex in there or not, it's already going to change the dynamic of that in the flow. 01:23:49
Off that intersection area and it's going to make more challenge to get through. 01:23:54
I think it's a bad idea. 01:23:59
To put. 01:24:02
This specific. 01:24:03
The housing. 01:24:07
And have this many people in this area. 01:24:09
Just simply because it's. 01:24:13
Challenges it's going to have on those intersections. 01:24:14
And I know. 01:24:18
You know, we all look at growth in the area. 01:24:19
We know what's coming. 01:24:21
But we've got to fix the plan for it. 01:24:23
I don't think that this meets the test as far as effectively. 01:24:26
That's just my thank you. 01:24:32
My name is Clyde Harrelson. I live off of Buck Creek, so I'm a. 01:24:39
Couple miles from the place. 01:24:42
But I shot that area. I shot the bank. 01:24:44
Why do we need apartments in an area? 01:24:47
That has no apartments in it whatsoever. 01:24:50
And my main complaint that you all could use or the main complaint you could use is the parking. 01:24:52
Who has 1.8 vehicles in a home? 01:24:57
They're going to have two-bedroom apartments in there, 45 of them. 01:25:00
They'll have at least two cars, if not 3. 01:25:04
We went from three cars to two. 01:25:07
Just recently, but prior to that, we've always had three vehicles in our family. 01:25:09
And I think for no other reason, the parking. 01:25:13
Should turn this down if they put in a bank where there's a. 01:25:16
Three banks across the street. 01:25:19
Why do we need another bank here? 01:25:21
They're just they don't want to make the parking. 01:25:24
Fit that place because they're not going to make as much money. 01:25:26
But if they need to drop that another 50. 01:25:30
Units just to make the parking fee. 01:25:33
Clyde, sorry, before you leave, what's your address please? 01:25:36
4059 Tanglewood Dr. 01:25:39
South of Buck Creek. 01:25:41
All right. Thank you. Glad. 01:25:43
OK, great. Ladies first. 01:25:46
Theresa Temple, 3 to 5 Tuscany Drive. 01:25:49
Boys knobs. 01:25:52
You turn down Don's. 01:25:55
Approval for apartment staff in 2014, did you not? 01:25:57
And he offered. 01:26:00
To build our homes. 01:26:02
55 and older. 01:26:03
Didn't workout. 01:26:05
Now it's all families, which is fine. 01:26:06
They're supposed to be single family dwellings. Ends up being. 01:26:08
One family that has three families living in it. 01:26:12
And then the drainage. 01:26:15
Back behind where you got. 01:26:16
The 301 start with 301. 01:26:19
All the way down past where Donnie lives because he lives in our subdivision. 01:26:22
All that drainage back there, their yards are all wet all the time. 01:26:26
They're never, they're never dry. 01:26:30
Florence Hampton had to pick up. 01:26:32
All her flips. 01:26:34
Stuff in the backyard because it wouldn't have them and stick or grow. 01:26:36
Anyway, you're turning down in 2014 for apartments. 01:26:39
Turning down again, I like Donnie. 01:26:41
He builds a really good homes. 01:26:44
In our subdivision. 01:26:46
And he hasn't finished what he needs to do. 01:26:48
And we know that the grocery store will have a small JC store if you all well know. 01:26:50
Now it can't. It can't accommodate all these people. 01:26:55
You know. 01:26:58
Make a strip mall like he promised. He said he was going to do our a medical stability or something to that effect. But apartments 01:26:59
are only going to cause more crime. You know, one of the things the Floyd County Sheriff's told me. 01:27:04
That our subdivision was one of the safest subdivisions. 01:27:09
Because Tuscany draft. 01:27:13
Was one way in and one way out. 01:27:14
Do you not agree with that? 01:27:17
And now you're getting. 01:27:19
All these intersections. 01:27:20
Criminals are coming across the bridge. 01:27:22
Coming in all of our subdivisions. 01:27:24
Because they've got all these little exits to go through. 01:27:26
Yeah, I'm not right. 01:27:29
I mean, it's true. 01:27:31
And we've had several cars broken into even in our subject. 01:27:32
Donnie's head stuff stolen from his subdivision, but. 01:27:35
You know, you just can't keep building all this. 01:27:39
Apartments and it's just gonna bring our. 01:27:41
Our values down. 01:27:44
And we don't want to. We just don't want it. 01:27:45
All right. Thank you. 01:27:47
We got we got a minute left. Go ahead, Sir. 01:27:52
My name is Spencer Worth and I live at 8040 Schriever. 01:27:54
You don't have to. 01:27:57
Forgive me for my quick talk, my quick speaking. 01:27:58
I agree with many of the points brought up by those behind me. 01:28:01
But one thing that I feel like hasn't been brought up is, or at least expounded upon, is the parking. 01:28:04
So if if the parking is not enough is not 2 1/2 per unit which my wife and I. 01:28:09
Have never had less than two cars. 01:28:15
Since we've been married. 01:28:17
Where are these industry cars going to go? 01:28:18
They're gonna be parking in these neighborhoods next door. 01:28:20
And people are that we don't know people who ties the community. 01:28:22
Are we walking through our neighborhoods back and forth? 01:28:26
And we have no recourse whatsoever. 01:28:28
Thank you. 01:28:30
Thank you. 01:28:31
All right, that closes this this portion if the applicant would like to come up. 01:28:34
And rebut what was spoken about. 01:28:39
You've got 5 minutes. 01:28:44
I'll speak very quickly. Just a couple things to deal with. I'm sorry, just a second. 01:28:47
Make sure nobody. 01:28:53
Yeah, we got opened up for down. Sorry. We just need to make sure to wait downstairs because the elevators out. 01:28:54
Do we have anybody downstairs? 01:29:00
In opposition? No, Sir. All right. Thank you. No, Sir. 01:29:02
Now you go. Thank you. Very, very quickly, a couple things that Mister Emerson brought up and I think it's important to address 1 01:29:06
primarily deals with. 01:29:11
The issue pertaining to. 01:29:17
Sidewalks, things of that nature and homeowners association keep in mind under the terms of the restrictive covenants with govern 01:29:19
that. 01:29:23
Homeowners association is not going to be formed till the last light sells. That's in their restrictions. The other piece of it 01:29:28
tends to be there is a non remonstrance clause in each of their subdivision restrictions specifically indicates that they would 01:29:32
not. 01:29:37
Opposed any type of development that Mister Athena would do on adjacent property. 01:29:42
Please let let him speak. It's unclear. 01:29:51
And there is a non remonstrance clause in that and they all took title subject to that. 01:29:53
A couple other items I think are important. Dealing with one gentleman that said he just moved up there, he moved into the 01:29:58
Highlands, which is the brand new subdivision, residential and he wanted rural. So again, I take a little exception to that. 01:30:05
The other piece that I think is important is. 01:30:12
The wide Shriver Road and the issue with regards to the traffic study. 01:30:15
It was done, and Mr. Copper Weight will probably talk about this as well, but it was done in anticipation of all of those. 01:30:19
Existing. 01:30:26
Developments as well as those that are already on the books as well as looking at this. So it's not a matter that they forgot 01:30:28
something. All of those developments were taken into consideration when they did that. 01:30:34
I'll let Jason speak on several of the other issues, but again, keep in mind that the restrictive governance primarily deal with 01:30:40
when that homeowners association is turned over and likewise when the sidewalks are finished when all of them lots of. 01:30:46
I do want to hit on the traffic study. Number one. It used to be that the developer would hire a traffic engineer to do the 01:30:55
traffic study. That is no longer the case. It is the county that hires the traffic engineer. So the developer has no influence 01:31:00
over the over the traffic study or the traffic engineer. 01:31:05
When they did their study at that I reviewed they did take into account all of the. 01:31:11
There's Gray woods just to the north of Highlander Point. There's a there was a patio home. 01:31:15
There were some proposals that were across Open Sins Rd. 01:31:21
There were some other things going on in the air. They took all that into account. 01:31:25
And of course, the traffic study reflects that the light is in place. 01:31:28
The lights not in place today. 01:31:31
We acknowledge that there are traffic issues there today. 01:31:33
But when the county finishes constructing that light, it's going to be a whole lot better, and the traffic study shows that. 01:31:36
Regarding drainage, I touched on that already. 01:31:45
Again, you have the most strict drainage ordinance in the region. 01:31:48
I think that's it, unless you have any questions. 01:31:52
Oh, wait, one more thing. I'm sorry. 01:31:57
Under the general commercial zone, your maximum impervious area is 70%. 01:31:59
Under the MF at 65%. 01:32:04
Under our PUD plan, it is less than 70%. 01:32:06
So we're going to be better on drainage just as a baseline. 01:32:09
Yeah, last individual be Daniel Moriarty. Daniel did the. 01:32:13
Project the design on it. Likewise, he's going to address some of the issues pertaining to the very same project that he's done 01:32:18
throughout Indianapolis area as well as other parts of the state. 01:32:23
State your name and address please. 01:32:28
3628. 01:32:30
Place in Carmel. 01:32:32
And obviously I'm not local so I can't speak to traffic issues and things are going on but. 01:32:33
I will say they do a lot of these projects around the. 01:32:39
Right bargains, though. 01:32:41
Westville. 01:32:42
South Bend, Fort Wayne, Bluffton. 01:32:44
All all around the state. 01:32:47
Always the same issues. 01:32:49
But the things I consistently see. 01:32:50
Number ones, we said traffic. 01:32:53
This there's. 01:32:55
Things are gonna happen. 01:32:56
This ground, regardless of what happens, time, right, something is going to be built by right. 01:32:57
That's not going to stop the traffic. 01:33:02
No matter what it is, it's gonna. 01:33:04
So if there's traffic issues in the area. 01:33:06
Those who are not my opinion, not the responsibility of this landowner to solve the. 01:33:08
For the county. 01:33:14
I mean that this developed something happening on this property. 01:33:15
Is something that. 01:33:19
Just. 01:33:21
Regardless of what it is, they're still going to be, it sounds like. 01:33:22
I'm not here for everybody. The issues. 01:33:25
So that was one thing. Secondly, I've got six kids, all six of living apartments. 01:33:28
Only once been arrested. 01:33:32
He lives at home with me right now. 01:33:33
So, umm. 01:33:35
There's no. 01:33:36
Evidence, at least in it. 01:33:37
Brand new development. This is a very high quality development and again I was working with a lot of people around the state. 01:33:39
The one thing about that the ambulance has been very refreshing. 01:33:45
There's a level of quality that they brought to this development. 01:33:48
Is very much higher. 01:33:51
Than what I hear from. 01:33:52
Every other builder on the state. 01:33:54
I'm not, I'm not just saying. 01:33:55
That's true. So. 01:33:57
So what happens? 01:33:58
Rent levels are such. 01:33:59
That if you want to say. 01:34:01
At least, and I'm sure some people know a lot better than I do, but I don't believe that just. 01:34:03
Those higher rent values necessarily bring crime with them. 01:34:07
The other thing is the missing middle missing gap. 01:34:12
For someone said there's no apartments in the area. 01:34:14
Well, kids need apartments. Younger people need apartments to make the transition from school where they had. 01:34:17
Ones to eventually have. 01:34:23
And if you don't have that high quality piece within your community? 01:34:25
Again, just watching it elsewhere. 01:34:30
That's that's it. That's. 01:34:32
Thank you very much. 01:34:35
Thank you. 01:34:36
No, Sir, you can't. I'm sorry. 01:34:40
I don't make the rules I thought. I try to follow them, Sir. 01:34:43
OK. 01:34:47
At that point, we're done with the petitions rebuttal. At this time, we're looking for ballots. 01:34:49
Unless you all have any questions. Unless you have any questions. 01:34:57
Questions. 01:35:00
Today, understand what our information is as far as. 01:35:03
Go ahead. I'd just like to make a couple notes. I know there was concern that they did not receive certified mail. 01:35:14
The the requirement for that is 2 lots. 01:35:21
Adjacent. 01:35:24
From the project site, so if you did not receive the mail. 01:35:25
Within 22 lots of that site. 01:35:31
It was sent. 01:35:34
We do have the the green cards to verify that. 01:35:35
Regarding the traffic pattern that was brought up. 01:35:39
In dot controls the old Vincennes at 150 intersection and they do have plans to. 01:35:43
With projects to correct the issue at that. 01:35:50
That's about $7,000,000 I think what the project came in the. 01:35:54
Schreiber Road and Old Vincent's light construction is set to start. 01:36:00
Beginning of March for that project. 01:36:05
And. 01:36:09
The traffic study does account for all the other developments proposed in the area. 01:36:11
The sheriff was a part of the TRC meeting. 01:36:17
And noted that he had no concerns with public safety standpoint from this project. 01:36:20
All right. Does anybody have any other questions for Nick, please? 01:36:26
Hold it. 01:36:31
No. 01:36:34
There is a process that they are following. 01:36:36
Go ahead, Nick. 01:36:40
No, I had a question if Nick could also elaborate to. 01:36:42
To the audience there. 01:36:46
That there's also projects. 01:36:50
On the table right now. 01:36:52
Right behind Jacques and a light that's going in on 150 between Luther and. 01:36:55
Open Sense. 01:37:02
You're gonna, you're just gonna stop. As soon as you come off the Interstate, you're gonna stop. 01:37:04
123. 01:37:09
4-5. 01:37:12
Six times between there and Napleton Rd. 01:37:13
Well. 01:37:21
They're working on. 01:37:22
It's it's happening right now. There is a. 01:37:23
Study. 01:37:27
We have submitted an RFP for preliminary engineering for a light between. 01:37:28
Lutheran old consens for a connection. 01:37:34
To the Highlander Point area in there. 01:37:37
And one final note. 01:37:41
This property is currently zoned General Commercial. 01:37:42
Traffic for general commercial uses. 01:37:46
Are typically higher than. 01:37:49
Multifamily or any other residential use. 01:37:51
So. 01:37:54
What would be allowed by right? 01:37:55
Could likely have a greater impact on the traffic than what this proposal would suggest. 01:37:57
Right. 01:38:03
All right, all right. 01:38:05
May have to ask people to just. 01:38:08
All right. At this time, no other board questions. 01:38:16
OK. 01:38:20
Nick, you want to? 01:38:22
Nick, you want you want to just go through the process just one more time on the agenda items as far as. 01:38:27
Which one of these items is? 01:38:33
The options of the board so they. 01:38:36
Clearly understand so the rezoning requests in the PUD rezone. 01:38:38
Our recommendations to the. 01:38:43
County commissioners. 01:38:46
So that just sorry, I want to make sure. I think they want a little direction too. So that would be your docket item ending in O2. 01:38:48
And that's the rezone. 01:38:54
And your docket item ending in 04 is your put correct? 01:38:56
Go ahead. And 03 is the major subdivision. 01:39:01
Huh. And then docket item 05 is the detailed development plan. 01:39:04
Associated with the. 01:39:08
OK. 01:39:10
OK, everybody. 01:39:12
Claire So in, two in. 01:39:14
For both favorable, unfavorable or no recommendation. 01:39:16
And then the other two ending in three and five would be granting or denying. 01:39:21
Any questions on those and? 01:39:28
One ballot at a time. So you're going to start with the O2, start with O2. 01:39:30
All right, we need a ballot from somebody, please. Docket FC01-25-02, Petitioner, theme and group. 01:39:34
Decision. 01:39:41
After careful review, the Floyd County Planning Commission finds that one. 01:39:42
Rezoning of subject property is consistent with Floyd County Comprehensive Plan. 01:39:47
Because the Conflict County Comprehensive Plan identifies the area. 01:39:52
As commercial growth area. 01:39:55
Rose planned unit development will be. 01:39:57
Mixed-use featuring a commercial element nearest to Old Vincent's Road. 01:40:00
Additionally, rezoning is consistent with. 01:40:05
Smart growth principles identified in the pan. 01:40:07
Specifically, mixed land uses compact building design. 01:40:10
Creating a range of housing opportunities. 01:40:13
Directing development towards existing communities and preserving open space, farmland, natural beauty and critical environment 01:40:16
areas. 01:40:19
As this is an infill development. 01:40:23
#2. 01:40:25
The rezoning of subject property is consistent with the current conditions. 01:40:27
And the character of the current structures and uses in the area because commercial uses. 01:40:30
At the front of the. 01:40:35
The lot are consistent with the original general commercial zoning. 01:40:36
The multiplication. 01:40:40
The multifamily uses are appropriate. 01:40:43
Transitional uses between general commercial and urban residential uses. 01:40:46
Building facade materials are to be brick and Hardy board. 01:40:51
Structures are within the height limits. 01:40:54
Of the Flower County zoning ordinance. 01:40:56
And there there is another three story building in the vicinity. 01:40:59
#3 The rezoning of subject property is necessary for the most desirable use of the land. 01:41:03
Because the rezoning follows smart growth principles already noted. 01:41:08
It also provides additional housing identified as needed in the Purdue Housing Report. 01:41:12
The county had completed in 2020. 01:41:17
Is a mixed-use infill development. 01:41:19
In the commercial growth area? 01:41:22
#4 the rezoning of subject property. 01:41:23
Will not be interest to the value of other properties in the area. 01:41:26
Because commercial uses are consistent with general commercial zoning and appropriate adjacent to residential urban zoning and 01:41:30
uses. 01:41:33
The addition of a multi family component will support local business customer base. 01:41:37
The development will increase the value. 01:41:42
Of the lot itself and is expected to have positive impacts. 01:41:45
On neighboring commercial lots. 01:41:48
The buffer yard alone. 01:41:50
Adjacent residential lots are provided to the West. Additional buffering is recommended for the properties on the South. 01:41:52
The rezoning of subject property will support. 01:41:59
Responsible growth and development in the area. 01:42:02
Rezoning follows the objectives of smart growth outlined in the Floyd County Comprehensive Plan. 01:42:04
Higher density development is directed towards existing infrastructure. 01:42:10
Provider Provider letters indicate ability to serve the development is in. 01:42:14
The identified commercial growth area and is in the infill development. 01:42:20
Upon careful review, the Floyd County Penny Commission hereby makes a favorable recommendation. 01:42:24
On the petitioner zoning. 01:42:30
Amendment application at the meeting held on the 10th of February 2025. 01:42:32
A favorable recommendation is based on the following written commencement. 01:42:37
Buffer Yard 2 standards will be met on all adjoining residential properties. 01:42:41
Trick #2 Drainage will be Floyd County storm water standards as approved by the Storm Water Board. 01:42:46
#3A phase lot 1 will be developed first and a schedule of completion for the project will be provided by the applicant. 01:42:52
That completes my ballot. 01:42:59
OK, we have a ballot. I need a second. 01:43:02
No second. 01:43:25
That I need a ballot. 01:43:27
By somebody that's not approving this ballot. 01:43:29
You need to fill one out. 01:43:31
I can't do it. 01:43:33
What was the question? 01:43:42
Mr. Vice President. 01:43:44
Somebody need somebody will need to complete a ballot. 01:43:49
Otherwise you can have discussion on the first one if you want to at this point. 01:43:58
Go from there. 01:44:03
But. 01:44:04
Nations from out for conversations. 01:44:10
Yeah. I mean, you guys can discuss it. You can. 01:44:13
The only thing that would not require bouts unfavorable recommend or sorry, no recommendation that would not have a ballot with 01:44:16
us. 01:44:19
It's favorable, unfavorable, or no recommendation. 01:44:24
I was listening correct because you wouldn't have a ballot with no recommendation. 01:44:28
OK, so somebody makes needs to make a motion. 01:44:33
That's the path that somebody wants, OK? 01:44:36
So I think once again, that's why we kind of went through and explained so. 01:44:38
Obviously, Mr. Bible Hauser has a ballot with a favorable. 01:44:41
We either need somebody with an unfavorable or no recommendation at all. 01:44:45
Unfavorable takes a ballot. No recommendation would not be a ballot, so no recommendation does not take about. 01:44:51
I'll make a motion for no recommendation to the Board Commission. 01:44:57
Could place place. Please respect what we're trying to get accomplished here. I beg you. 01:45:01
If you cannot be quiet, you need to leave the room please. Thank you. 01:45:07
OK, so I have I have a motion for no recommendation correct? 01:45:11
I need a second. 01:45:16
I need a second. 01:45:24
I will second that motion. 01:45:26
OK, have a second. 01:45:27
Any discussion? 01:45:29
Yeah, I'm just not qualified to do this unfavorable ballot. I'm. 01:45:31
Totally opposed to this. I don't know why we're making an adjustment to this zoning to our. 01:45:35
Residents of that area. 01:45:40
But to put me to. 01:45:46
Could do this ballot. I'm just not qualified. I mean, it's so detailed, so complex, just what they went through. 01:45:48
I think it's a process. OK. So do you want to fill out an unfavorable? 01:45:55
Not or you want to vote for. 01:46:01
No recommendation. 01:46:03
Maybe if we can re. 01:46:04
Revisit this another meeting, give me time to prepare for it. That's not possible. We've got three options and we're going to 01:46:06
leave the room with 1/3 so. 01:46:10
I'm not qualified to do this. 01:46:13
Unfavorable. Sort of. 01:46:17
I have a motion. I have a second. 01:46:18
We had discussion all in favor. 01:46:20
Signify for I. 01:46:22
Aye, aye. 01:46:24
There's three. That's for no recommendation at all. 01:46:26
So you had three, so you do not have enough to support a no recommendation. So there needs to be a ballot. 01:46:31
That is prepared or a. 01:46:36
Vote in favor. You have to have a majority vote. 01:46:38
Call again. So no recommendation. 01:46:45
Everybody understands what's going on there. That goes to the ministers, they make the decision so. 01:46:48
You could make an unfavorable. 01:46:53
And vote unanimous. All that still goes to the Commission. 01:46:55
Makes the commissioners make the decision so. 01:46:58
In order to for us to finish this meeting tonight, we have to have a vote. 01:47:01
So can I put it up for one more time? 01:47:06
Somebody else can make a motion, yes. 01:47:09
Can I review this? I mean how complex is this? 01:47:12
I know I'm not qualified, but I mean, can we just put up a? 01:47:15
Vote unfavorable how details is going to be you have. 01:47:19
Ballot and bring your motion with. 01:47:22
Your ballot. 01:47:25
But you can take time to fill out and do, but it does. 01:47:27
Be brought and then a second to that. 01:47:29
Vote on that ballot. 01:47:32
Not an answer question. We're we. 01:47:35
We're not supposed to answer questions, but hold on a second. 01:47:52
Once again, what we're trying to do here is we've got favorable, unfavorable. 01:47:55
Or no recommendation. So that's what we're trying to get through right now, so. 01:47:59
Let it give us time to get through this place. 01:48:02
Yes. All right, I'll make a motion is. 01:48:06
I'll make a motion and no recommendation. 01:48:10
I'll second. 01:48:13
We have a second. 01:48:15
Any other discussion? 01:48:16
All in favor. 01:48:18
For no recommendation signify by aye. 01:48:19
Ah, those opposed. 01:48:23
All right, all right. 01:48:24
OK, so it's two, it passes. 01:48:26
Good. Five, Yeah, OK. 01:48:28
So it's going to the Commission with no recommendation. So I'll get to visit Michelle. Let me let me show a hands who said yes. 01:48:30
No recommendations. No recommendation? Sure. 01:48:37
12345 So we've got enough, correct that is correct. 01:48:39
So that passes. 01:48:44
OK, so now agenda item. 01:48:45
Number. 01:48:48
4/3 right? 01:48:51
Excuse me, Sir. What? 01:48:55
We all right, go ahead. 01:48:57
I'm looking for a ballot. 01:49:00
For agenda item number. 01:49:01
433. 01:49:05
3 Umm. 01:49:07
Even though we got no recommendation here, you still want to all tied together. That's what I Nick, have you. Yeah. 01:49:08
Make a contingent on commissioners approval. 01:49:20
Yeah, I mean. 01:49:22
Well, the the subdivisions. 01:49:26
Ministerial. 01:49:28
Correct. 01:49:29
So if the Mr. standards, then you. 01:49:31
Child permit. So for that work they want to table it. 01:49:33
If the applicant wishes to table until commissioners make a decision, otherwise you guys would, it would be up to you and it's 01:49:39
ministerial, so if they meet all the requirements it has to be approved. 01:49:43
With you can make a condition contingent on the commissioners approval of the rezone, though obviously other than that if they 01:49:48
meet the requirements of the zoning ordinance it has to be approved. 01:49:52
The question is just do you want to table it until a decision is made by the commissioners or do you want a do you want the board 01:50:01
to go ahead and vote on it this evening? 01:50:05
OK. 01:50:09
So that you guys are left with the ballot for that. 01:50:10
Which is agenda item 4 but. 01:50:15
Docket ending in 03 is a grant or deny that subdivision. 01:50:17
Again, is ministerial in nature as long as they meet the zoning ordinance. 01:50:21
With that though, I would. 01:50:24
Recommend subject subject to the Commissioners approval. 01:50:26
Zoning change which is reference that docket number, I think will be helpful. 01:50:30
OK. So just for everybody on the board, if you get a ballot that's in favor of this? 01:50:34
We put us, we put a condition on it. 01:50:39
That it's subject to the commissioners, correct? So if the commissioners don't approve that, then it would not be approved. All 01:50:42
right, so I need, I need a ballot for agenda item item number 4. 01:50:46
#4. 01:50:51
Well, it's agenda item 4. It's agenda item 4, Docket three. Yeah, Docket 3. 01:50:54
Docket FCO 1-25-03. 01:51:10
Number one, petitioner has met all the following requirements. 01:51:16
So he's met all the requirements for. 01:51:20
Preliminary plan provided. 01:51:24
Certification demonstrating idem. 01:51:26
Platt provided geotechnical report staff. 01:51:29
Traffic Study. 01:51:33
The lots working. 01:51:36
And compliance. 01:51:38
The streets. 01:51:40
Item I Streets are in compliance. J Sidewalks are in compliance #2 Petitioner has met. 01:51:41
The following requirements for drainage and storm water. 01:51:48
#3 The petitioner has provided a letter confirming. 01:51:52
Confirming availability and willingness to serve for all necessary utilities. Lloyd Water Company, Georgetown Fire Department. 01:51:56
Harrison REMC, New Albany Wastewater. 01:52:04
At T and Charter. 01:52:08
#4 Petitioner has met the following requirements for sewer and or septic. 01:52:10
Service for the development we provided by New Albany Wastewater. 01:52:14
Decision. 01:52:22
Upon careful review, the boy county. 01:52:25
Planning Commissioner right grants the petitioner. 01:52:27
Primary approval for a major subdivision at the meeting held on the 10th of February 2025. Primary approval is based on completion 01:52:30
of fine conditions. 01:52:35
Final Approval The drainage stormwater plans are required prior to secondary approval. 01:52:39
The number of apartments. 01:52:45
For this development shall not exceed 125 units. 01:52:47
And this. 01:52:53
This approval is subject to. 01:52:57
Contingent is contingent upon. 01:53:00
The the planning. 01:53:09
The commissioners approving the previous one, right? 01:53:12
FC is put down FC. 01:53:16
This is contingent upon. 01:53:18
FC01. 01:53:20
I will just hold on there, OK. 01:53:22
FCO One. 01:53:34
2502, that's right, yeah. 01:53:36
This is contingent upon the Commissioner's approval of FCO 1-25-02 that completes my ballot. 01:53:41
All right, we have a ballot. I need a any discussion. 01:53:49
I need a second. 01:53:53
I'll second. 01:53:54
We have a second. All in favor signify by aye. 01:53:55
All right, all right, let me see. A show of hands and said aye. 01:53:59
OK, let the record show that there was a majority more than 5. 01:54:03
That passes. 01:54:07
Once again, that is subject to the Commissioners approval. 01:54:10
Of the zoning map. 01:54:12
All right, you got agenda item number 5. 01:54:14
FC-01-25-04. 01:54:18
On this one, Nick, this would go from the multifamily to the PUD though, so I think at this time. 01:54:25
Would the applicant want to table that one? Because. 01:54:31
I mean, it wasn't. 01:54:35
Obviously the recommendation. There's no recommendation from. 01:54:36
Commercial to multifamily. 01:54:39
I still you have 8 will be back in the morning. 01:54:42
Unfavorable, OK. 01:54:47
OK. All right. 01:54:49
All right, so confirming that's OK with you so. 01:54:51
Is there any on a body on the board that wants to make no recommendation motion or is there a ballot from somebody? 01:54:53
Anybody. 01:55:02
Which one is this for? This is the one that. 01:55:04
PUD. 01:55:09
It's #4. 01:55:10
It's it's it's agenda file. 01:55:14
So your options again are favorable, unfavorable, both of those require ballots or no recommendation. 01:55:19
So, and this is on 04. 01:55:31
This is yes. 01:55:33
Huh. 01:55:37
The first part of this thing. 01:55:46
It's all up to you. 01:55:47
So all I have to say. 01:55:49
Officer, can't we start? 01:55:51
Multiple pages in correct? 01:55:53
Yes, page 4. 01:55:55
All right, all right, That's OK. 01:56:01
We have three options. 01:56:06
I know the proposed. 01:56:07
Planned unit development does very does significantly. 01:56:10
Does vary significant from the zoning and subdivision control regulation concerning density, parking and buffering? 01:56:14
Yard #1 #2. 01:56:20
The closed land use and the. 01:56:23
In the planned unit development. 01:56:25
Are not in conflict. 01:56:27
With spirit and the intent of the comprehensive. 01:56:29
Plants surrounding land use and zoning district. 01:56:32
#3 the proposed. 01:56:36
HUD does provide adequate public service like air traffic control. 01:56:38
Open and. 01:56:44
Common space and recreation. 01:56:45
#4. 01:56:48
The planned unit development is compatible with the adjacent properties and surrounding neighborhoods. 01:56:49
#5. 01:56:55
The proposed planned unit development will not interfere with the use or diminish the values of adjacent properties and 01:56:56
surrounding neighborhood. 01:57:00
Number six, the proposed planned unit development will not diminish the level of service. 01:57:04
For roadway systems in the vicinity. 01:57:09
#7. 01:57:12
The plan you development can't be immediately and adequately served by existing public facilities. 01:57:13
#8. 01:57:20
Planned unit development does preserve natural and historic resources to extent possible. 01:57:21
#9 The planned unit development will not be interest to the public health and safety and general welfare. 01:57:27
#10 The written commitments will be required. The applicant shall provide a schedule for phasing the construction of the project. 01:57:33
A schedule for the completion of all phases. 01:57:37
We'll provide it to the Planning Commission. 01:57:42
#11. 01:57:44
The petitioner will be. 01:57:46
Required. 01:57:48
To meet conditions. 01:57:49
Please specify those conditions a the number of apartments of development. 01:57:51
Shall not exceed 125 units. 01:57:56
Be for secondary approval, provide additional screening of dumpster on. 01:57:59
Dumpster. 01:58:03
On lot 1 between dumpsters and roadway provided light at entrance. 01:58:04
Locations where there are none. 01:58:10
Meet suffer buffer zone. 01:58:12
Buffer Yard 2 standards. 01:58:15
For adjoining residential youth on the South side. 01:58:17
With a ball. 01:58:21
That completes my appointment. That's not complete my brother. 01:58:25
I gotta read something over here. 01:58:29
Upon careful review, the Floyd County Planning Commission hereby. 01:58:31
Makes a favorable recommendation to the County Commissioner concerning the petitioner planned unit development at the beating held 01:58:34
on the 10th of February, 2025. 01:58:38
All right, we have a ballot. 01:58:44
Any discussion on that ballot? 01:58:46
I need a second. 01:58:48
I'll second. 01:58:51
We do have a second. 01:58:52
Any further discussion if none? 01:58:54
We need a vote all signify that agreed by aye. 01:58:57
Aye. 01:59:00
Those opposed. 01:59:02
Aye. 01:59:03
All right, well, let's say this show of hands and approve it. 01:59:04
Which one are you doing? 01:59:08
4. 01:59:10
Just making sure I heard you right. 01:59:11
1234. 01:59:13
OK. 01:59:15
All right. 01:59:16
So if we need somebody to do. 01:59:19
I will adjust. 01:59:22
Ballot. 01:59:24
To no recommendation. 01:59:25
So you're just bringing a motion for number? Yeah, it's not your ballot. 01:59:28
Well, it's on here to 2nd, make no recommendation. 01:59:31
Ending ending Commissioner approval. 01:59:35
Is is it just no recommendation or is it? 01:59:40
Automatically pending Commissioner approval. 01:59:43
It goes to commissioners regardless. 01:59:47
OK, I'll second that. 01:59:49
OK, so we have a motion for. 01:59:52
No recommendation. 01:59:55
Correct, and you're seconded. 01:59:57
Any discussion? 01:59:59
OK, all in favor, say bye. 02:00:01
Raise hands, please. So we got it on record. 02:00:03
OK, we do have 5 or above so that does pass. 02:00:06
All right. Thank you. 02:00:09
All right, it passes no recommendation. 02:00:12
All right, the last. 02:00:17
Is agenda item 6. 02:00:21
Which is FC. 02:00:24
01 Dash, 2505. 02:00:25
I thought that's what we just did. No, I didn't. 02:00:28
I don't know if that was the floor. Huh. It was all four. 02:00:31
It didn't read. 02:00:37
Yeah, 'cause that's. 02:00:41
Yeah, that should have signatures. 02:00:42
Because that should have that as a no recommendation, shouldn't have signatures on it, right? 02:00:47
That one does. 02:00:53
Hey, Nick. 02:00:55
I'm all confused at this point guys. 02:00:58
The 04 ballot has no recommendation but still has a ballot which? 02:01:02
Are you OK with that? 02:01:06
Yeah. 02:01:08
You vote, you voted on it. 02:01:10
Recommendation. 02:01:12
Do you have, do you have agenda item 5? Is that what you? Yeah, that's fine. That's still fine. 02:01:15
You just read Ballot. 02:01:22
Agenda item. 02:01:26
Agenda item 5 + 4. 02:01:28
Gotcha. OK. That was the one you just read. 02:01:30
You read it. 02:01:33
Where's it at? 02:01:35
That's when we just. That's what I just read. 02:01:37
Yeah, I don't think that's right. I'm confused. 02:01:41
Nick, you want help a second. 02:01:43
You skipped. 02:01:49
Is this right? 02:01:51
You have the first 3. 02:01:54
Here we go, you're saying? 02:01:57
You want an 05 now, right? Correct. 02:01:59
That's the one we're on now. 02:02:01
We have to. 02:02:07
Did we approve this one? 02:02:09
OK, so we're on. 02:02:11
That's right. 02:02:23
Do we need to finish signing that? 02:02:26
I need it and I'll move it on. 02:02:30
OK. All right. 02:02:35
So, so Nick on this development plan, I mean, if we're voting no recommendation on. 02:02:36
O2 and 04. 02:02:40
How? How do we How do we vote on it? 02:02:41
On both O2. 02:02:45
That's right. 02:02:47
Yeah, I got a sign. 02:02:49
I bet so that's good. 02:02:52
That's alright, you got it. I'm. 02:02:57
Hey, I'm good. 02:03:01
How do I know what I'm saying? 02:03:02
OK, the next we need a ballot for agenda item 6. 02:03:12
05. 02:03:17
FC-O125-505. 02:03:18
No, I just making sure that. 02:03:24
Where's my wife? 02:03:42
You guys. 02:03:48
This will be. 02:03:51
Subject to FC 01. 02:03:52
25. 02:03:56
Dash O2. 02:03:58
And 04104 1. 02:04:01
That's it, You got it. 02:04:11
And I still need some. 02:04:13
All right, do we have a ballot for Docket FCO 1-25-O5? 02:04:17
Conceptual site plan. 02:04:25
Review by planning director Yes. 02:04:27
Findings #1 Petitioner has met all the veterans standards. 02:04:29
For the district #2A waiver for the development standard. 02:04:33
Requirement is not required. 02:04:37
#3. 02:04:39
Proposed development plan is consistent with the Comprehensive plan because the Floyd County Comprehensive Plan identifies the 02:04:41
area as a commercial growth area. 02:04:45
The proposed planned unit development be mixed-use featuring a commercial element nearest the frontage additional rezoning 02:04:50
assistant with the smart growth principles. 02:04:54
Identified in the plan, specifically mixed land use. 02:04:59
Compact building design, creating a range of housing opportunities, directing development towards existing communities and 02:05:02
preserving open space. 02:05:06
And critical environmental areas as this is an infill development. 02:05:11
#4 The proposed development is consistent with the intent. 02:05:15
Of the district has set forth in Boyd County zoning ordinance because it is a multi family planned unit development district. 02:05:19
District which allows modifications to underlying district. 02:05:26
Standards #4 the proposed development plan. 02:05:29
Does satisfy. 02:05:32
The following development. 02:05:33
Requirements. 02:05:35
And there are. 02:05:36
A is signage, B is access, C is designed D lighting. 02:05:37
Number six, the proposed development is a multi family development development plan does satisfy the requirements for a 02:05:43
recreational space and open space by providing a pool and outdoor gaming area. 02:05:49
And is less than the 25 acres in Toll area. 02:05:55
#7 The proposed developments is located in the Highlander Point District. 02:05:58
The following requirements have been met. Building facades or brick. 02:06:02
And Harding board there are no loading docks, burden dumpsters located to the side and rear of the buildings. 02:06:06
A The building facades that face any adjacent streets have a finished facade. 02:06:12
Be loading docks and trash collector bins are not placed on or along the facade that face. 02:06:17
Any adjacent streets? 02:06:22
See the accommodation is. 02:06:25
Is made for community space where a proposal commercial development. 02:06:27
Has over 100,000 square feet. 02:06:32
Either in combination of buildings or lots and is. 02:06:34
A cohesive commercial project or development D. 02:06:38
Open space requirements for Section 904. The Fern. 02:06:41
Zoning ordinance are met. 02:06:44
Decision. This decision is contingent upon Commissioners approval. 02:06:46
Of SCO 12502 and FCO 1/25/04. 02:06:50
One careful review. The Floyd County Planning Commission hereby approves. 02:06:54
The Petition Development Plan review application at the meeting held on the 10th of February 2025. 02:06:58
Completes my ballot. 02:07:04
All right, we have a ballot. Everybody understands the conditions written on the ballot. 02:07:06
I need a second. 02:07:10
All right, I've got a second. 02:07:14
I would like to. 02:07:18
Note that. 02:07:19
This detailed improvement detailed. 02:07:21
Plan would be contingent upon the rezoning. 02:07:25
He said that. 02:07:29
Not only as a condition, but as a matter of. 02:07:31
Whether it is valid or not. 02:07:34
That's why I made a second. 02:07:37
There you go. So I have I do have a a second. 02:07:40
OK. 02:07:43
All right, all in favor signify by aye. 02:07:46
Aye, show of hands please, on the eyes. 02:07:49
OK, that is. 02:07:52
A majority. So that passes. Thank you, Larry. 02:07:53
All righty, Nick. 02:07:57
Includes the. 02:07:58
Agenda items other than we had something on here about the overlay. 02:08:00
Can we, can we push, push that down the road? 02:08:04
Please I need to. 02:08:07
I really need to. 02:08:10
I need to. I gotta be honest with you. 02:08:12
OK, OK, let's get these signed before we adjourn. 02:08:16
Because that is. 02:08:19
That is no old business, new business. 02:08:21
Complete for tonight. 02:08:24
Appreciate advice, patience. 02:08:26
Need a motion for adjourned. Yeah, don't, don't leave till you sign though. I need a motion to adjourn motion. 02:08:29
OK, any a second so moved. 02:08:34
Favor signify by. 02:08:37
All right. Thank you very much. 02:08:39
Oh. 02:08:44
scroll up