No Bookmarks Exist.
9/20/24 Joint meeting of County Council commissioners to order. I know Commissioner Schellenberger is in the building. Will join 00:00:03
this momentarily then. 00:00:07
You'll join me in the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic 00:00:12
for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. 00:00:19
All right. 00:00:30
So 1234 it's like I have 5. 00:00:32
People who have signed up to speak. 00:00:37
And we'd like to limit this to like 2 to 3 minutes each. 00:00:42
Rick, you were my timer before, but out there, I don't know how effective you would or wouldn't be. So Daniel didn't do that. But 00:00:47
we still love you, and you'll be our timer next time, OK? OK. 00:00:53
Yeah. 00:01:00
Two. OK, so Mr. Chris Pelman. 00:01:02
And if you'll state your address county of residency, that'd be great. 00:01:07
My name is Chris Hellman. I live at 7661 Navelton Rd. In Floyd County. 00:01:12
Thank you. 00:01:19
OK, so I've kind of kept quiet on this whole subject. 00:01:21
The current provider we're using for EMS. One of the issues that has been had with that provider was. 00:01:28
They're utilizing firefighters. 00:01:36
On ambulances, Which? 00:01:39
Depletes their fire coverage. 00:01:41
My concern is that you all are looking at potentially going with another model. 00:01:44
Would emulate that exact same. 00:01:51
Model. 00:01:56
As a firefighter. 00:01:59
Having three people on a fire truck is extremely important. It is important to us as the fire department, as the firefighters are 00:02:01
going to be there fighting the fire. 00:02:06
And to the public. 00:02:12
You, if you have a fire truck, show up with one person. 00:02:14
On the truck, they are completely ineffective. 00:02:18
They are not able to do their job properly to save. 00:02:21
Lives and property. 00:02:25
That's all I've got. 00:02:29
I just want you all to think about that with your old decision. 00:02:31
Thank you very much for being here and speaking. 00:02:35
Diana Mayfield. 00:02:38
I know you've joined us before, but if you'll please give your address. Diana Mayfield, 6408 Brent Drive, Floyd Noms, Floyd 00:02:44
County. 00:02:49
OK, I'm I wrote it down this time so wouldn't forget. 00:02:54
OK, I'm here tonight to ask that as representatives. 00:02:59
For the taxpayers that you slow down and look at all the possibilities and make decisions that are for the betterment of the 00:03:03
community and not self-serving, it is easy to review the part of any proposal that you like and ignore the rest. You need to look 00:03:11
to protect Olive oil county. While the cost may be the largest part. Look at 911 services as well as non-emergency transports and 00:03:18
the cost to cover the entire county not just the hill. 00:03:26
If New Albany and Franklin Township. 00:03:34
To cover the entire county with all the services, not just portions of the county. The public voted you people into office because 00:03:38
they trusted you. Don't breach that trust and rush into any situation that is not better meant for the entire county. 00:03:47
And I did have one gentleman tell me how transparent the boards are. 00:03:57
That all for accounting boards are transparent. I beg to disagree. 00:04:04
I think they're about as transparent as a black garbage bag, so. 00:04:09
I'm it's it's terrible. 00:04:15
You know, one thing that really bothers me is the meetings. The meetings are sometimes 6:00, five, o'clock, 4:45. They seem to be 00:04:19
scheduled when a lot of public can't be here to speak. Utah, stop and look at people who are working today. 00:04:27
There's a lot of them Can't get off work and even get here. 00:04:37
For 4:45 meeting, that's not fair to your public. It's not fair to your constituents at all. You need to make it where all can 00:04:40
attend. 00:04:45
So I think you all need to end up being more transparent and pay more attention to your constituents. Get out there and talk to 00:04:50
them. They're not well, they're allowed to come in here. 00:04:56
I've talked to a bunch of them that would have been here. 00:05:02
But they can't meet the time frame that you all set. 00:05:05
So that might be something you want to consider in the future when you start talking about transparency. 00:05:09
Thank you. Thank you, Chair Bush. 00:05:15
Thank you very much, Sheriff Steve Bush. I just wanted to say a few things on the Advisory Board to this board. We've been at 00:05:21
many, many meetings that are jointly done. A lot of opinions that's come out from this topic, a lot of emotions. 00:05:27
They'll also lost a lot of vetting, still got more to do. So I just want to really just say. 00:05:34
Looking from the past, we're looking from currently into the future that we look at. 00:05:39
As a dispatch, we have to be able to dispatch somebody. 00:06:13
We want to make sure we're prepared to do that one way or the other. So thank you very much. 00:06:15
Thank you, Darrell Mills. 00:06:19
Darrell Mills with New Albany Township, president of the. 00:06:26
New Albany Township Fire Board. 00:06:31
Like take this opportunity first of all. 00:06:34
Take Everybody in this room knows that. 00:06:36
Your Chapel far is under a lot of scrutiny and. 00:06:39
We have a lot of turmoil going on. I won't take this opportunity to thank. 00:06:43
Highlander Fire Department, Georgetown Township Fire Department. 00:06:47
Tri-county and Borden and also New Albany City Fire Department for helping us through these times right now. 00:06:52
We have a lot of legal issues that we're dealing with. I can't really speak for those. 00:06:58
But we're going to upright this fire department, the boards. 00:07:04
Been meeting regularly. I think you all seen me. I've been trying to stay. 00:07:07
On top of everything with your all situation with contract for the ambulance service. 00:07:11
I think most of my conversations have been pretty open with several of you that have spoke to me. 00:07:17
New Chapel. 00:07:24
Fire Department. 00:07:26
Us as a board, we are not in a situation to run our own ambulance service. 00:07:27
I think it needs to be a county wide fire department ambulance service if that's what you do, not just. 00:07:33
Certain areas. 00:07:38
I'm not speaking against any agency here, I'm only speaking on behalf of the Albany Township. 00:07:40
But I think we need a county wide. 00:07:46
Ambulance service that will service New Albany Township residents as well as anyone else. 00:07:49
We don't know what our issues are going to be fiscally. 00:07:55
Trying to straighten out the fire department, but our priority is Fire Protection, not ambulance service. We've never provided 00:07:58
ambulance service. 00:08:02
We've always relied off the county commissioners contract. We don't own ambulances. 00:08:06
I live in New Albany Township. 00:08:11
I'd like to see New Orleans Township protected with ambulance the same as the rest of the county. 00:08:13
Please take that into consideration. I'm open to meetings. 00:08:18
But I think one ambulance service service in the county. 00:08:23
With the county commissioners contract. 00:08:26
It's their choice on who they go with. I want to step on their toes. 00:08:29
But we need to have coverage too. 00:08:33
And I don't know fiscally. 00:08:35
What we're going to be at once we get all this going with our fire services, but right now? 00:08:37
We need a fire service in New Albany Township. 00:08:42
They can say they got one. I saw the interviews. 00:08:45
Right now, we're relying on MO Houston to answer our FAR calls. 00:08:49
So that's our priority right now. 00:08:53
30 seconds. 00:08:55
So I appreciate any support that you all could give us in New Albany Council. 00:08:57
Thank you. Thank you. 00:09:01
Tim Harbison. 00:09:04
I live at 3820 Edwardsville Galena Rd. 00:09:14
I'm a very linear thinker, and so I'm going to tell you right up front. 00:09:19
That this may be oversimplified. 00:09:23
But to me. 00:09:27
Attended meetings, watching the videos. 00:09:29
Something that seems so painfully simple has been so extensively debated. 00:09:32
And I just figured there must be a piece of the puzzle that lots of us in the audience do not see. 00:09:38
Ameripro $1.5 million price tag and I watched the video of the last. 00:09:46
Meeting of the Council and nobody could tell us for sure how to fund that $1.5 million. 00:09:54
New Chapel. 00:10:04
I'm sorry, they're really not an option. 00:10:06
Clark County neighbor of ours is spending. 00:10:09
Has at least one person with a credit card spending our money on a lot of different things. 00:10:13
And they're under an FBI investigation. 00:10:18
So like I said, oversimplified if you have three choices. 00:10:21
And two aren't viable. You only have one option left. 00:10:28
And like I said, there's probably a piece to this puzzle that I don't understand. 00:10:32
But two of the council members and. 00:10:37
Two of the Commissioners. 00:10:41
Seem to doubt the proposal that the Highlander Fire District put forward. 00:10:42
And they seem to doubt. 00:10:49
The funding that members of their own council put forward. 00:10:51
And yet I haven't seen any of the data. 00:10:55
That backs up their doubts. 00:10:59
On why the funding was incorrect. 00:11:02
Or why? 00:11:05
The professional firefighters and Highlander Fire District could not deliver the service that they offered, so if there's some 00:11:08
data out there that helps you. 00:11:13
Decide that Highlander couldn't do what they say they're going to do more that the funding. 00:11:20
That some of your own council proposed, I think it would help all of us in the audience to know what the data is. Thank you. 00:11:27
Thank you, Bill. 00:11:35
I'm Bill Banta. I'm the chief of the Georgetown Township Fire Department. 00:11:43
I've been up here several times and I've said the same thing several times. Georgetown Township. 00:11:47
Supports the legal process that was inspired by the board by the commissioners through their recommendation to accept the contract 00:11:52
through Maripo looking at at least one year contract. 00:11:57
I've said this several times. 00:12:03
Give yourself a little breathing room and sign the contract on Monday. Start Tuesday to end up resolving this issue permanently. 00:12:04
But again, we've said it several times. 00:12:12
There was a legal process. 00:12:16
And it should be followed. 00:12:18
Thank you. Thank you. 00:12:19
All right, so that is everyone who had signed up. 00:12:22
To speak tonight and we do have one item of new Business Today and that's to continue the discussion of the EMS. 00:12:25
Situation here, so I think. 00:12:34
All of the commissioners attended. 00:12:36
The funding meeting that you all had Monday a week ago, I believe. 00:12:38
And just to give us a starting point of. 00:12:44
For where we are. 00:12:47
You know, a majority of the commissioners did put forward a plan to negotiate with the mayor of Pro. 00:12:50
For coverage for the entire county. 00:12:55
New Chapel was taken off the table. 00:12:59
Primarily because they could not show financial solvency. 00:13:03
And then there was a second proposal or a third put forward regarding how you look at it. 00:13:08
From Highlander Fire Protection District. 00:13:15
To provide EMS service. 00:13:18
But the missing piece to that puzzle, perhaps, is that they're not going to cover the whole county. They're they're covering. 00:13:20
Quote UN Quote The Hill. 00:13:26
So I think that's where we are as kind of a stepping off. 00:13:28
For tonight is at the beginning of your all funding meeting. There was a discussion of. 00:13:32
Of the 1.4 million, which I think is the number we're looking at rather than 1.5. 00:13:39
Where was that going to come from concretely? And there were some leads that were discussed. And there was. And I saw people 00:13:45
taking notes at that meeting and they've said they were going to maybe follow up with looking at that. And then there was the 00:13:49
discussion of Highlander, so. 00:13:53
I guess my first jumping off point is. 00:13:58
Was there any further looking into the funding of the Commissioners proposal? 00:14:01
For the county wide coverage from America Pro for 1.4 million. 00:14:07
I I think there's been lots of discussions and. 00:14:14
Ideas that are still being. 00:14:20
Processed and. 00:14:23
Making sure they're viable options. 00:14:26
I think everything we had on paper. 00:14:31
Showed us. 00:14:34
75% there. 00:14:38
Available. Not that we agreed upon it, but. 00:14:41
Available. 00:14:44
To do you know funds that could be made available I. 00:14:47
I think the. 00:14:55
The sticking point? 00:14:57
Is probably. 00:14:58
How long do we want to try to negotiate this contract? 00:15:02
And what happens? 00:15:05
After the contract what what type of planning? 00:15:07
Goes into the the after. 00:15:12
Yeah, one concrete update from that from discussions with the Mayor Pro is that you know we that RFP originally was for three 00:15:15
years. 00:15:18
And they are not willing to go below 2 years. 00:15:22
But it seems like there is we have to go to two years. 00:15:27
And I know that. 00:15:30
The there was also discussion about the commissioners meeting halfway or trying to find some funds for that as well and. 00:15:34
So I think, Mr. Love. 00:15:41
Had discussed at least. 00:15:45
Two potential issues out of Jason, do you want to comment on that? Yeah, I think one of the issues that we we discussed where 00:15:47
there was some money available was the where we had set aside for broadband. 00:15:52
Broadband coverage. 00:15:58
So I think there's about $600,000. 00:16:00
Available in there that we can use to offset that so. 00:16:04
If I have to choose between broadband and emergency services while I choose emergency services. 00:16:09
Well, since we're talking about broadband. 00:16:14
We initially had $1,000,000 set aside. 00:16:17
And over the years we have. 00:16:20
We have given up 400,000. 00:16:23
200,000 like for the building turn 1000 for I'm not sure what it was but I am totally against. 00:16:26
Using that 600,000 for the for EMS. 00:16:32
I live about Greenville and Lafayette. We have a lot of areas out there. I still have broadband. 00:16:36
Y'all be you might be OK. 00:16:43
Adjacent Georgetown and Franklin. There's a lot of areas out there, too. 00:16:46
And but this money has been reserved for broadband and I am totally against that. I think we're just cutting our cutting nose off 00:16:50
spotter face with that. 00:16:54
And it's only just a one time, just a one time give. 00:16:59
And so if you're looking at two year contract, what are you going to do to supplement that the the second year? 00:17:03
So I'm told against using. 00:17:09
I think the people. 00:17:11
In Floyd County, that out in the rural areas that don't have broadband. 00:17:13
I think they would be outraged. 00:17:17
Well, I think that as time has gone on, I think technology kind of. 00:17:20
Runs pretty quickly. I mean, I can't even walk out of the phone store without getting a new phone already. And you know, the truth 00:17:24
is, is that we're at a point where. 00:17:28
You know, there's plenty of options out there. High speed options with satellite servers such as Star Link. 00:17:31
That somebody could pay for, you know, so. 00:17:36
I really, I'm really not sure you know, as far as on a local level how much we should be. 00:17:39
Paying for people's broadband when we have emergency services that need funded. So that's just my opinion. 00:17:45
Well, the. 00:17:51
The Indiana Broadband Association, I talked with one of them today and they've got two rounds coming up. 00:17:53
First one will be sometime in July of this year and the second will be fourth quarter or next year. 00:18:00
And you know, it's a long process because they're looking at. 00:18:07
They're comparing the address that they have are the ones that been reported that want to make sure that they got the database 00:18:11
right. So it's you know it it it's a it's a slow process. 00:18:15
But again, they have plans. 00:18:20
To work with the. 00:18:22
To work with the with the providers and. 00:18:25
They are. They'll be putting their plans together and and when they look at that, they're looking at how much. 00:18:28
How much money will be will be? 00:18:34
Will be provided and not only by the by the provider, but also local match. 00:18:38
From the from local government and so we need to have skin in the game and we don't have that money there. We don't have skin in 00:18:45
the game. 00:18:48
Well, if we're looking at different sources, I will. 00:18:55
Consider a broadband just because, as I said, I'd rather have areas not covered by broadband than not covered by ambulance. We 00:18:58
have other options. Like I said, I'll look at and listen to lots of other options. Doctor Harris, did you join us after we began? 00:19:04
OK. Sorry I didn't. I didn't see you there. 00:19:13
So. 00:19:17
All right. So any other leads on? 00:19:21
Coverage for the entire county. 00:19:25
With the Ameriprro. 00:19:27
Contract that was approved for that was suggested, are we talking one year or two years, so we need to have at least two years. 00:19:30
Of funding and so. 00:19:38
I I would love to see. 00:19:41
What Danny thinks the numbers look like for a two year funding. 00:19:43
When we're 75% there, if he could put those on the board because I don't know what they are. 00:19:47
We talked about him in our Monday night meeting. Can we can we have you put him on the board for us? 00:19:53
If you think we're there, I mean, because I'm really, I'm just being serious. I don't know how we're going to use, I don't know 00:19:58
where 75% of it's going to come from. 00:20:03
If if we have it, I'm. 00:20:09
That's that's a great thing for a two year period. From my recollection, you all had discussed CARES ACT money. 00:20:12
Yes, we have, and there is a discussion as to whether that should go just for the Highlander Fire Protection District or to the 00:20:18
Ameripro, right, that is, Mr. Bagshaw stated. A good portion of that has been earmarked for the health department and their new 00:20:23
home in 2026. 00:20:28
Yes, so. 00:20:34
So again, options there's options for using. 00:20:37
That CARES Act money that was already set aside for something, or the ARPA money that was already set aside and I don't have. 00:20:41
Or the Legacy Foundation Foundation was mentioned Money. 00:20:50
Which we would have to get into the umm. 00:20:54
The principal Thank you, the principal for. 00:21:01
Again. 00:21:05
All options, but have we talked with and done any? 00:21:07
Further homework on the I believe I even heard someone stay under their breath, maybe off microphone about an EMS lip tax. 00:21:11
So what? It probably didn't get into the minutes. 00:21:19
I've stayed on the record. It needs to be part of the discussion. 00:21:23
If you're gonna have a service. 00:21:26
And you want to have ongoing funds for that service whether it's county wide EMS, whether it's privatized? 00:21:29
Whether it's stitched together from the different fire districts doing. 00:21:35
Which really are the only three options. 00:21:39
Then you have to have some sort of ongoing funding for that and. 00:21:41
So I think that needs to be. 00:21:45
On the tables. 00:21:49
I don't disagree if that's the way we want to go. I don't see any other way to fund this. 00:21:51
Besides a EMS tax if we want to go this direction. 00:21:57
Which means you have to put it in place this year, I believe. 00:22:02
In order to start collecting it next year. 00:22:06
And again, we'd have to talk with our financial people about the timing of how that tax would work. 00:22:09
I would tell you I probably in all sincerity talked to no less than 100 people constituent like outside of these meetings and I'm 00:22:17
sure everybody else has to and we had one speaker. 00:22:22
At the last meeting, I can't recall his name, but he stood up there and said that that seemed to be the most logical. 00:22:29
You know, talked about it. I think his estimation was $39.00 a person in the county. 00:22:36
Four to five people that I talked to. 00:22:43
We're saying that that seems to make sense. I do get people that balk at that and I get that. 00:22:45
If you're going to do that, you have to have a non reverting fund where that money goes. 00:22:52
Towards EMS and everybody EMS. 00:22:56
People need to be able to see where their tax money goes, OK? 00:22:59
So CARES Act Money 1.1 million Riverboat 125 Reporter 350. Is that a new one that was not discussed previously? 00:23:03
OK. So and then it'll be an ongoing. 00:23:13
50 to 70,000 per year. 00:23:15
Can you explain? 00:23:18
When we got the new Lao. 00:23:21
Software. 00:23:24
And after an internal audit. 00:23:25
Funds. 00:23:27
Shifted back to the general fund, they were left in an account. 00:23:28
Within the Recorder's office, and it was, it was found. That's about. 00:23:32
6-7 years worth. 00:23:37
Of it just kind of rolling over. So that's a one time. So that was not discussed at the last meeting it was not and then Mr. 00:23:39
Bagshaw discussed rainy day fund. 00:23:43
At the last meeting to correct. 00:23:47
And there'd be a range on that anywhere from. 00:23:50
Dale, you recall what you. 00:23:54
I suggested possibly the first year, but. 00:23:57
If we really wanted to tap into rainy day, I mean, we could fund it. 00:24:00
Earmark raining day for the next two years, but you believe down pretty. 00:24:04
Drastically right? They need to be replenished. 00:24:07
So. 00:24:14
I'm owing the math there there's there's. 00:24:18
If you had the rainy day at the bottom of that, then there's more than enough to cover for two years of that. 00:24:20
So if we want to get into those are a couple of things on there that I I'm just I just need to point out. 00:24:29
Number one, the legacy. 00:24:35
It's really up to the legacy board whether they give us that or not. We have no. 00:24:37
Say and whether we get that we have a say in in the lump sum portion. If we choose the lump sum portion, we do. 00:24:42
And we could. 00:24:49
Get that? 00:24:50
And that. 00:24:52
And like I said in the last meeting. 00:24:54
I see no reason. 00:24:56
That the Legacy Foundation would not approve this because what greater legacy? 00:24:58
And for the Betterment County, then public safety. 00:25:02
I agree, but I'm just, I'm just pointing it out. And the other thing is. 00:25:06
Only part of the let's see, you've got the budget. 00:25:12
We've already had to pay New Chapel five months of that. 00:25:18
So. 00:25:24
So not all the 220 is there. 00:25:25
For this year, will we be there next year? 00:25:29
I mean, I understand, but yes, I mean potentially right. 00:25:32
Could be. 00:25:38
Would you mind adding the rainy day at the bottom there to sort of range please? 00:25:40
What's the current balance? The current available balance minus the Care Act money that implied is 2.8 million. 00:25:48
I saw. 00:25:56
Mr. Steve Burks enter the room gate. 00:25:58
You sit on the legacy foundation, would you have any comment on that? I mean I sit on that as well and I know that historically 00:26:02
we've talked about that the funds should not go towards. 00:26:06
What should be a budgeted? 00:26:11
Fund item correct, but but I don't think that's written into the charter. 00:26:14
And I I'm not trying to put anybody on the spot, I'm just trying to have an informal meeting and you might have information useful 00:26:21
to us. 00:26:24
An informal formal meeting, I would refer to Mr. Striegel or Miss Hendricks, who's in the audience, but my understanding is. 00:26:28
The legacy board simply grants money. 00:26:35
Of the interest off that. 00:26:40
There can be a supermajority. 00:26:46
That can say we will. 00:26:48
You know, we'll have. 00:26:50
That 400,000, whatever it was up there. 00:26:52
Toward this and so. 00:26:55
The purpose of the legacy board is simply to grant. 00:26:57
Money to nonprofits. That's the entirety of our of our Rd. It's not just nonprofits, but, well, what I'm saying. We're the grant, 00:27:04
Grant Turbors. 00:27:09
That's the entirety of our responsibilities when it gets into the nuances of taking money from there. 00:27:14
Then it only comes back to the Council. 00:27:22
And there may have been some legislation that's changed. That's my understanding as the Chairman of the board. 00:27:25
Thank you. 00:27:31
Krishna Kumar Pvt. Ltd. 00:27:35
I think there's another option that I brought up at our last meeting and no one seems to continue. Not going to bring this up. I 00:27:38
guess it's one no one wants to address, but. 00:27:43
I think we need to ask the Commissioners to come to the table with this. 00:27:49
And look at this I. 00:27:53
Then it's benefit study that we had completed. We for some reason have not had this meeting to review this to get some 00:27:55
comparisons. 00:28:00
I've done some rough numbers on this, trying to get us into an average of. 00:28:05
These other numerous counties were involved in this. 00:28:09
And I see potential savings of pension of 282,000 a year. 00:28:13
Which would grow. 00:28:19
With interest every year. 00:28:20
And in addition, healthcare contributions from. 00:28:23
The employees would be. 00:28:27
528,000. 00:28:30
These are just some rough numbers. So we're talking over $800,000 a year. We're talking pretty much half this budget. Yet no one 00:28:32
wants to discuss this. I can't get anyone else on page to at least bring this up to discuss. I I I get such a big number. We 00:28:38
really have to address this. Let's set a meeting. I'm. I'm all for set a meeting. Well, the commissioner's gonna have to be 00:28:44
involved in this. So they have to prove it. So they're not gonna they're not gonna be open to this. It's it's already when. When 00:28:50
did that study come back? 00:28:56
4-6 weeks ago, OK, I mean. 00:29:03
Yeah, I thought the impression was so opinion. I I certainly I have never. I have not received any invitation to come to a 00:29:06
meeting. I'm happy to do that. I've asked to have this meeting, but yet I still got no response. I've been wanting this meeting. 00:29:12
I mean, I I. 00:29:20
Have you emailed me on that? 00:29:21
Not you, no. 00:29:24
So so. 00:29:27
Let's get to do for our next joint meeting. This one was the next joint meeting is when. 00:29:27
Well, the next schedule, right, I think at the end of the month as is, but you know. 00:29:33
We may be having joint meetings weekly between now and. 00:29:36
And the resolution of and we really want to make sure that the. 00:29:41
The vendor that did that study can be at that meeting, so we need to. 00:29:46
Understand when that's going to happen. I mean it's it is at the same time. 00:29:52
Place that has been scheduled for for a couple months. Yeah, I don't remember when that is. I'm trying to look on my calendar. 00:29:57
20 3rd I think 23rd or 4th. Oh, there it is. That's 4:00. 00:30:06
So. 00:30:14
Jim, I just asked you, you said half a million in healthcare. Can you kind of give me just a real quick how you'd rather have that 00:30:16
study and have them confirm some of these numbers, these are just some rough numbers I'm having employees what they would help, 00:30:21
what they would continue to contribute? 00:30:25
To the plan. 00:30:31
I need their confirmation from them. I'm these numbers I have may not be exact I'd rather have that but I'm I'm Sanders potential 00:30:33
there so we at least should be addressing it so we can we get a consensus that we will at the 4:00 meeting on April 23rd have a 00:30:38
vendor available. 00:30:44
Can you reach out? 00:30:51
I think Michelle's here somewhere. 00:30:52
Maybe not. I'll. I'll make sure that she reaches out to him. 00:30:55
And we have that discussion. 00:30:59
OK, so I mean that discussion. 00:31:02
Will take place. 00:31:05
Right now I will tell you that that is very, very promising money for the 2025 budget and beyond, but. 00:31:08
Trying to put something in place now that's effective June 1st. 00:31:18
We still need to take a deep dive into these numbers. 00:31:22
It is the only option on the table right now that covers the entire county. 00:31:27
And I know that we will want to have a discussion. I know that there are folks who. 00:31:32
I hope that people want to go into these numbers a little bit more, but if not, I know that there are some here they're going to. 00:31:40
Talk about the Highlander Fire District proposal. That's cool, but I do want to bring. 00:31:45
Mr. Rick Fox forward. 00:31:51
To discuss. 00:31:53
The that option before we get into the numbers part of it. 00:31:55
So does anyone else have anything to say or suggest about? 00:31:58
These possibilities at this point in time, I don't think that the legacy foundation money is going to. 00:32:03
Be available within the next. 00:32:11
52 days, whatever we have left either. 00:32:13
So again, what do you have that's actually available in the? 00:32:16
We can, we can move funds and. 00:32:20
Reimburse, I believe. OK. 00:32:23
I believe they call for a monthly. 00:32:25
Cash payment. 00:32:28
Right. Yeah. So it's understood. 00:32:30
I I think. 00:32:33
Before we make any final decisions, we may want to get Baker Tilly to look at. 00:32:35
Using rainy day funds. 00:32:41
To do to to do this because. 00:32:44
I don't know this for sure, but there is a suggested. 00:32:48
Amount that you should have on hand. 00:32:54
Just like you would have at home, you know, three months of cash or three months of savings. 00:32:57
And we may be below that if we. 00:33:04
Start using up our rainy day funds. 00:33:09
To support this, I'm not suggesting that we shouldn't. I'm just suggesting we may need to get Maker Chilling. It is a suggestion, 00:33:12
yes, and this is the contract is paid monthly. 00:33:17
We went years and years and years with. 00:33:23
800,000 to $1,000,000 in there, and I'm not suggesting that we that we rate the rainy day fund. 00:33:27
But I. 00:33:34
My understanding was it was suggested to keep it up. 00:33:37
At the 10% of expenses level for. 00:33:40
Ratings. Umm. Uh. 00:33:44
And I don't think bonding rates do get impacted and and we do need cash on hand because our levies only come up in once every six 00:33:46
months. 00:33:51
So if you're not careful. 00:33:57
With your cash. 00:34:00
Right. I'm just suggesting we may need to get our financial guys to understood. 00:34:02
I know where you come from. So I noticed the EMT lid isn't on the board up there yet. 00:34:09
You probably don't want to be the one that has to put it up there, right? 00:34:13
I will officially put it on the table for discussion. I thought we were talking about things that were available now, so I 00:34:19
understand. Well, that's the same thing with the down the road you could have. 00:34:24
The health insurance. 00:34:31
And the. 00:34:33
What was they look for? 00:34:34
It's intentional and we really don't know where the savings is on that. 00:34:36
But it belongs out there. 00:34:45
Because, you know, my thinking on this has has. 00:34:51
Evolved to the point where I think that. 00:34:55
That needs to be part of the conversation. I mean, I really think we need to sign with the mayor pro for one to two years, but we 00:34:57
have a task force to look at county wide EMS. 00:35:01
To see if that is financially the best way to go and if so, then how do we fund it and that's probably going to be. 00:35:06
The best way to do that in an ongoing fashion? 00:35:13
And that would allow us to. 00:35:16
Form of service from the ground up, but Rick, do you want to? 00:35:18
Where can I? 00:35:23
We brought this my engine earlier today, so. 00:35:27
Rick, Fox County Attorney. 00:35:32
I'm here to specifically speak with regards to EMS services. 00:35:35
With respect to the Highlander Fire District. 00:35:41
In my opinion, the ordinance or charter of the Highlander Fire District does not authorize EMS services. 00:35:46
In fact, it is the commissioners that have the statutory authority to authorize franchise our contract for emergency medical 00:35:54
services. 00:35:59
In support of that, I just want to go through briefly with regards to the ordinance and some other authorities that support that 00:36:04
opinion. 00:36:08
To start with, in terms of. 00:36:15
The ordinance under Section One, it speaks specifically. 00:36:19
The following purposes for which the Highlander Fire District was established. 00:36:25
And under a Fire Protection fire extinguishing all fires B. 00:36:30
Fire Protection, including identification and elimination of all potential and actual sources. 00:36:36
Of fire hazard. 00:36:43
And see other purposes or functions related to Fire Protection and fire prevention. 00:36:45
And nothing was said about. 00:36:53
Emergency services and under the statute. 00:36:56
Fire services and emergency services are two separate entities, 2 separate things. 00:37:00
Moving on, what I call the authorization clause. 00:37:10
The ordinance says once fully functioning, commencing January 1, 2024, it will be the purpose and function of the Highlander Fire 00:37:14
District to effectively exert jurisdiction over and govern fire services throughout the district. 00:37:23
So the purpose and function. 00:37:32
And jurisdiction. 00:37:35
Is to govern over fire services. 00:37:37
Nothing was said about. 00:37:40
Emergency services. 00:37:43
And. 00:37:46
You know when you talk about purpose, function, and jurisdiction, that pretty much covers the gambit with regards to what you're 00:37:48
authorizing. 00:37:52
The assumption clause that I call that's under. 00:37:59
Subsection D Other emergency Services. 00:38:03
It says that Fire Protection shall be timely assumed and fulfilled by the Board of Trustees. Doesn't say anything about emergency 00:38:08
services. 00:38:12
Being assumed by the Board of trustees. 00:38:17
Also says this procedure is hereby implemented consistent with the Statute. 00:38:22
To assimilate and integrate the Lafayette Township town of Greenville. 00:38:28
In Greenville town. 00:38:33
Floyd County within the territory and jurisdiction of this ordinance. 00:38:35
Moving on to Section 9, I'm sorry, Section 10 of the ordinance. 00:38:45
It states. 00:38:50
And authorizes purchase of firefighting equipment. 00:38:53
There's no authorization for the purchase of emergency services equipment. 00:38:57
And by the same token, the very next section, section 11 Payment. 00:39:03
Of line of duty. 00:39:08
Healthcare expenses for firefighters. 00:39:10
Is authorized. 00:39:14
There's no provision made for. 00:39:15
Authorizing emergency services personnel with respect to their health care expenses. 00:39:18
So EMS is not mentioned once in the whole ordinance. 00:39:25
It's just not authorized. 00:39:32
And there is a statute out there that when we talk about what? 00:39:34
Who has authority with regards to handling these matters? 00:39:42
That's Indiana Code 16-31-5-1. And it states that a governing body of a county. 00:39:46
By the governing body's action or any combination, may do the following Establish, operate, and maintain emergency medical 00:39:55
services. 00:39:59
Authorized franchise or contract for emergency medical services. And so that's the county commissioners. 00:40:05
They're the ones that are the legislative body and have the authority to do that and they can do a combination of that. 00:40:15
But they are the source of where we head with regards to. 00:40:24
Who's going to handle emergency services? 00:40:28
I'd also like to cite as a Supreme Court case, Anderson versus ******* 42 NE 3rd 82. This was decided in September 1, 2015. 00:40:31
And this is a case that came out of the. 00:40:44
The Brown Circuit Court. 00:40:49
And what it says is that the Indiana legislature has expressly granted county legislative bodies the authority to create and 00:40:53
thereby to amend under the Indiana Fire District Act. 00:40:59
Under the Indiana Home Rule Act. 00:41:06
Boards of county commissioners are authorized to amend a Fire Protection district, even if such amendment dissolves the district. 00:41:09
That means the commissioners have the authority to make the ordinances that they made and extend what authority authorities they 00:41:18
want to the fire districts. 00:41:23
And again, statutorily, they're responsible for how emergency services. 00:41:28
Play out. 00:41:34
And so. 00:41:35
Any questions with regards to that? 00:41:38
So let me ask you Rick, so that was you're not talked earlier, so you've not had a chance to look at New Albany Fire district or 00:41:43
Georgetown either, have you? 00:41:48
It seemed that the Highlander Fire District was looking to provide EMS services for. 00:42:01
For Lafayette Greenville, I'm not sure if they were going to expand the services somewhere else, but the the point I'm making is 00:42:10
that. 00:42:16
I don't believe they have the authority to do that. It is the commissioners that have the statutory authority and you know, even 00:42:21
if a case was made that. 00:42:26
There was authority somewhere in the ordinance, which there isn't, but. 00:42:32
You know, in terms of making the case, the Commissioners have the right to amend that pursuant to the Supreme Court case. 00:42:38
So you know, whatever the commissioners decide to do, that's. 00:42:44
That's where we need to head. 00:42:49
So currently with commissioners discretion, so currently with Highlander providing ambulance ServiceNow, are you saying that 00:42:52
they're doing that outside of the ordinance? 00:42:58
Yes. So you're saying that they are doing this improperly? 00:43:04
Well, it's outside the ordinance. So how do we fix this? 00:43:09
Also till until we fix this, what? 00:43:13
What's your advice on that then? 00:43:16
Well, I don't know. That's that's a question I hadn't been asked to. 00:43:18
You know you have a number of options. You most certainly. 00:43:22
Can take one of the one they. 00:43:26
I guess quickest options would be number. 00:43:28
Number one will be to review New Albany Township. 00:43:31
In Georgetown. 00:43:34
Ordinances. 00:43:37
And then review them and see if they have that included and if they don't. 00:43:39
Then we need to. 00:43:44
Bring them all up to speed and get them all on the same page. You can amend the You could amend everyone of the ordinances to 00:43:46
include fire and EMS and then everyone of them have the ability. 00:43:52
To do that if you if you so choose. 00:43:59
If you did that, then you probably don't need county wide ambulance service. 00:44:02
If you will. 00:44:08
But the County Council would probably need to step in and do some funding out with guests, because I wouldn't think that. 00:44:10
The fire districts themselves would have the funds to be able to support. 00:44:18
That joint effort. 00:44:22
Because I know they're using the majority of their funds for. 00:44:25
For fire purposes. 00:44:28
If there's a nuance here, correct me if I'm wrong. I mean if we go to correct these. 00:44:30
Which I'm not opposed to doing. I think there's a nuance between supportive services and standalone EMS services. 00:44:35
And I think you get into standalone EMS services and. 00:44:44
You need to have boards that then answer to the public. 00:44:48
And with merge to the funding that I mean I think all of these services. 00:44:53
Otherwise, they're open to misinterpretation. Well, it says EMS, so I'm going to run with that and do. 00:44:59
Whatever. I feel like that. 00:45:04
Mandate is, I think it has to be defined with regards to that, I think on behalf of the taxpayers. 00:45:06
The system that we had been operating under, you are having the taxpayers are paying for EMS coverage. 00:45:13
From two different sources for the same territories. 00:45:22
And that's not a benefit to the taxpayers. 00:45:26
So I think the Commissioners need to decide. 00:45:30
Where we're going to head with regards to this. 00:45:34
Get that worked out and then in conjunction with the County Council funding. 00:45:38
I see two more. 00:45:44
Important distinctions and. 00:45:46
The other fire boards do not wish. 00:45:52
To have EMS service. 00:45:54
That's not in their purview. They want to concentrate on Fire Protection. 00:45:57
Fire service. 00:46:02
They don't wish to pursue emergency medical services. 00:46:04
The other point is. 00:46:09
There's a big difference. 00:46:12
Emergency medical service and first response. 00:46:14
And I'll leave that at that. 00:46:20
So to your point, Danny, a little bit, you know. 00:46:23
I think it's very evident that fire departments are struggling with their budgets nowadays. I mean, they're no different than our 00:46:27
own homes. 00:46:31
Their spinning power is less now than what it was. 00:46:35
A few years ago, I mean. 00:46:38
Wasn't a couple of meetings ago we talked about. 00:46:40
The rescue that Louisville Fire Department undertook on the 2nd St. Bridge. 00:46:44
And. 00:46:49
You know, after after all the details of rescue were out, it wasn't just a few days later and. 00:46:51
We found out that, you know, the little fire department firefighters were working without a contract for nine months. 00:46:56
That there were $34 million in deferred maintenance behind apparatus schedule. 00:47:02
Was behind and the root of the rope. 00:47:09
That was used during the rescue was 10 years old, which is a violation. 00:47:11
In FBA 1858, Believe that's what it is, but. 00:47:15
You know, it wasn't just not too long ago either that we had New Albany Township and. 00:47:19
And Highlander both come up and say. 00:47:24
They wanted permission to. 00:47:27
You know, go for the Max Levy with our district but. 00:47:28
You know we're that's just for we haven't united the EMS component yet and that's one of the dangers with with firing miss is that 00:47:32
if you implement it wrong you have essentially 2 entities that are competing for the very same budget. 00:47:38
Dollars, just because you have EMS, that's a meeting that your budget's going to significantly grow. 00:47:44
You know so. 00:47:49
I think going forward, at least this time, you know. 00:47:51
Having a solution that fixes the problem for everyone in the county. 00:47:55
Is obviously probably a standalone EMS system. 00:47:59
And we already have quite a bit of actionable data we've already. 00:48:02
Receive between the Fitch study that we've paid for. 00:48:06
The RFP that the EMS Advisory Board came up with. So I do think we have some good data moving forward so. 00:48:10
Look forward to conversations to come. 00:48:16
So what do we as Commissioners do to resolve this this? 00:48:20
Discrepancy or whatever. You need to decide how you want to advance EMS services in Floyd County. 00:48:24
I think you're looking for. 00:48:34
A solution for the moment, just so that we're not. 00:48:36
Any sort of. 00:48:40
Jeopardy. Is there a? 00:48:41
Patch we can put on the all three amendments saying support services or first responder services. 00:48:43
Short of. 00:48:50
Putting putting the limit on starting their own EMS. 00:48:51
I think I. 00:48:57
I'm not trying to put words in, no. I understand you're looking for a shorter term solution and then we obviously need a longer 00:48:58
term solution now, but we don't want. 00:49:02
Anybody in limbo right now? 00:49:07
To me, it just bothers me that we keep putting these guardrails, guardrails to be so. 00:49:09
So specific, you know, and we're talking about public safety, we're talking about. 00:49:15
Come on, people's lives, you know. And we want to be so, so. 00:49:21
Drip just drill down that. No, we can't use that word. We can't use that word and we talk about EMS. 00:49:26
We're talking about providing service for people that have that have a critical time in their life, Okay. 00:49:32
And for us to be? 00:49:38
We need effect, but I think it also needs to. 00:49:40
It needs to be. 00:49:43
Forward-looking. 00:49:45
OK. Because we have got to do something here within that we've got what, 50 days, something like that, you know? 00:49:46
But that's why I say we need to get together. We need it, We need to get a fix in here, but it also needs to be able to. 00:49:53
To be forward thinking. 00:50:01
You know, I think what we've come up with. 00:50:03
Is both of those things having a majority of the commissioners? I realize you were on the dissension on that. 00:50:05
Have proposed that we. 00:50:11
Go forward with the mayor pro. 00:50:13
See if we get a two year contract covers the whole county. It doesn't leave anybody uncovered. 00:50:15
Which the other proposal did. 00:50:21
And well, it did. It didn't have no, I understand, you know, so we covered the whole thing and then we really did down. 00:50:24
But putting a task force together for your EMS doesn't mean that we're going to have county wide EMS, but it gives U.S. data to 00:50:32
actually see whether or not that. 00:50:36
Makes more safety sense, financial sense over continued privatization. 00:50:41
So I think the short term. 00:50:47
And again, governmentally, generationally speaking, A2 year contract is the short term solution. The forward thinking part of this 00:50:50
is. 00:50:53
Getting uh. 00:50:57
All of the parties together right now. 00:50:58
We have two of the three departments who've not even been brought to the table for the discussion. 00:51:01
Question. I have a question for Rick's. 00:51:08
You you provided a state statute report in regards to what the fire department's. 00:51:12
Primary duties are in the state of Indiana. 00:51:18
Fire prevention and Fire Protection. And you referred to a local ordinance, is that right? 00:51:21
I started with the local ordinance that the commissioners passed in 2022. 00:51:27
Which gives. 00:51:33
The powers. 00:51:35
They have authorized to the Highlander Fire District, which are kind of mimic the state statue services. That's what they 00:51:37
authorized. 00:51:41
Fire services, Fire Protection. 00:51:46
So what constituted the fire service I guess is the question that clarified clarifying question. 00:51:49
Well, fighting fires. 00:51:56
So far, prevention, Fire Protection. 00:51:59
It's it's to the exclusion of emergency services where you draw the line. I don't have the answer to that. 00:52:02
Emergency medical service, because they are emergency services, emergency services. 00:52:10
OK, So what? What? Vehicle extrications? Hazmat. Swift Water Rescue? Bolt Water Rescue? 00:52:15
That's in or out. 00:52:22
Are they allowed to do that? 00:52:25
Who is they? The fire department. 00:52:27
There we're talking medical services. 00:52:29
So but what I'm saying is is. 00:52:33
You we're talking by ambulance services. That's what we're talking about. 00:52:36
But you're saying that they don't necessarily have the ability to do that per the evidence? 00:52:41
The other functions that are not in statute or if I'm clarifying your ordinance, the other things that the fire departments do, 00:52:45
they're not specifically as stated in the ordinance. Are they allowed to do those? 00:52:50
They're not allowed to do anything that they haven't been authorized to do by the ordinance. Does the ordinance allow them to do 00:52:59
vehicle extrications? 00:53:03
Water rescue, swift water rescue or hazmat. 00:53:10
I have a well, you're Doctor Harris seems to be burning a come up to the microphone. If you don't mind though, I just have a 00:53:13
clarifying question on that. 00:53:17
I I it's. 00:53:22
Hi, I'm Tom Harrison, County Health Officer, also member of the university advisory for the. 00:53:25
Uh, doctor, for many years I I have. 00:53:30
Not to disagree with my esteemed colleague Rick here, but I do have concerns about this very. 00:53:34
Interpretation the ordinance. There are some major fire functions that include extrication brands brought out, includes hazmat, 00:53:41
and includes basic first responders in the first aid. But if you define this fire department as somebody who just sprays water on 00:53:48
something that's burning, I'm afraid that that is an overly restricted view. Now granted, it it, it fits. 00:53:56
You know the. 00:54:04
Rejection issues regarding power based. 00:54:06
But, and it also addresses the issue that the solution, whatever solution the support comes out there, is body comes out there. 00:54:10
Has to fit the whole account. 00:54:18
But the concern here is that we're painting ourselves into a box with a very restricted view of what fire can do. 00:54:19
Especially in an era, overall there's there's there's fewer actual fires. 00:54:28
Etcetera. 00:54:34
Wildfires are up. 00:54:37
The issue in this context though is that we're painting our fire. The only time they leave the building is if something burning 00:54:40
like that's not a lot of the runs, especially in this area, our rescue education. So that that's my concern with with this narrow 00:54:45
interpretation. 00:54:51
And as such, the ordinance should be modified. 00:54:56
To allow the Mars services to take out care of everything besides just fighting fires. 00:55:00
And I think, I think, I think. 00:55:08
Yeah, with this, with this just coming up. 00:55:13
To our attention today, literally I think all three Commissioners correct me if I'm wrong and. 00:55:19
Attorney Fox. 00:55:24
Open to looking at Georgetown and Ulney Township and making sure that we come up with. 00:55:26
Something that. 00:55:32
Broadens that interpretation a little bit, but not to the extent that they can have a standalone EMS service without the. 00:55:34
Authorization of the Commissioners in each case. 00:55:40
I think also one key, key important distinction is is that. 00:55:44
Providing auto extrication has this materials and all. That's not necessarily a certification from the state that you have to 00:55:49
receive. Emergency medical services whether it be transport or non transport is a certification process through the state. 00:55:55
And I appreciate your comments, but I don't like you were a little bit away from the mic and the, but I just. 00:56:03
I did hear that you thought it should. Whatever we come up with needs to service the whole county rather than. 00:56:08
That's correct. And you know the one of the things that has been grossed here a couple of times. 00:56:14
Is the concept of a freestanding service. 00:56:20
That way we avoid the whole fire district, the whole fire war board concept. Where we do this, we don't. 00:56:25
Despite fires, you know we can't try again. Fires real fire. You know, we, you know this stuff like that. You know, if you 00:56:33
establish A freestanding independently, invest, I'm not sure it's going to cost. 00:56:38
We don't have that number yet. That's certainly that may be a sticking point, but it's an option that should be considered as we 00:56:44
look at Firebase DMS. 00:56:48
But I think that the take home message you know from. 00:56:52
Today's and whatever course of action is chosen. 00:56:55
It has to fit Franklin Township as well as it's New Orleans Township. 00:56:58
And I think that there are difficulties and advantages to each mode of the service, but we have to have ambulance coverage. 00:57:04
Thank you. First, so some some sort of parallel track is probably the right answer. 00:57:12
The other thing is like I got my mic here, is that the funding ultimately should be sustainable. 00:57:19
You know, we can throw money at a problem fairly easily and we see that in the health department we're startup issues, but then we 00:57:27
have problems sustained approach. 00:57:30
And so, however you know, whatever. 00:57:35
Smorgasbord, you know, choice. You get to fund it. It has to be able to sustain this and keep it going. 00:57:38
And preferably without depleting the other potential funds in the future. 00:57:44
So I think that's something that also needs, needs to look at and we all get, nobody wants new taxes. 00:57:49
But there have been attacks like levies placed in the past for Fire Protection for other things in different counties. 00:57:57
And as long as we're within the state guidelines, I think that that's something that. 00:58:04
Should look at even the exemptions for certain subpopulations that. 00:58:09
Yeah, that was an estimate that came from someone, but that seems to be in line with some I've heard from other counties of 00:58:19
comparable size. 00:58:23
Disabled veteran benefits. It can be single households and parent households benefits and things like that. You can you can adjust 00:58:30
that overall fee to take care of that risk groups to be unfairly packed by additional funding or tax real quickly Would you also 00:58:36
include transport and non transport services. 00:58:42
With with English, I think you'd have to look at that. I think the primary issue. 00:58:49
As an emergency physician, the primary issue is emergency transport. 00:58:56
That also includes emergency transfer. 00:59:01
And we have a heavily that requires tertiary neurocare. That person needs to get to Baptist university as fast as possible. 00:59:04
Something with a polytronicism for you. 00:59:09
So, so that's that's the. 00:59:14
Absolute basic services, the government organization. 00:59:16
Is emergency transport and transfer. 00:59:22
The other runs actually pay fairly well and my supposition would be is that someone will come in whether it's Premier Pro or. 00:59:26
Each Apple, the next generation or whatever, that some service would come in and scoop up those runs because those runs are 00:59:35
proper, generally paying runs to the property. 00:59:40
But I think, you know, from a governmental administrative perspective, we got to solve emergency transport and emergency transfer, 00:59:46
correct? 00:59:50
And you know, we'll get estimates to provide the additional service. But you know, we want this, we want a public service. 00:59:55
Solution here. 01:00:03
Rather than a nursing home transfer solution, that's that's. 01:00:05
Hate to be that way, but that's something they can work out with another man in the service. OK, but you know, it's a duty. Of the 01:00:11
citizens of Boyd County, all 80,000 of them deserve emergency transport and transfer function. I appreciate your comments. We need 01:00:16
to begin winding down because there is a meeting that follows this one and I do want to give everybody a chance to come down from 01:00:21
the line. Either way, I just wanted to wrap. 01:00:26
I just want to wrap up with a quick comment and that is. 01:00:34
You know, the task here was to take a look at ambulance services opposite the ordinance. 01:00:37
And you know, for ambulance services you have to have certifications, you have to have certain types of certified equipment. 01:00:43
It's a big deal and that has not been authorized under the statute, not only the equipment, the purchase of the equipment or the 01:00:50
people being involved. 01:00:55
You know, in terms of all the other things, Brad, that you brought up, those things I think, you know, in the purview of the fire 01:01:00
department and you can always take it all the way out to the end, the cat in the tree, that's what you always see the, you know, 01:01:06
firefighters get the cat out of the tree. So you know, I would say that's probably within their purview. 01:01:13
OK. Jim, you want to start at your end or no? Denise had a question I just when you were negotiating with Ameripro, was there any 01:01:21
discussion about how much it would cost just to provide? 01:01:28
Service to the New Albany Township, yes. And they were not able to get that back to me because this. 01:01:35
The dispatch we had a. 01:01:41
They asked for data and your system was down for. 01:01:43
X number of hours that came back up, and anyway, that data has just gotten back over to Ameripro today. 01:01:47
So I don't have a specific, you know, to do that. Of course it was going to. 01:01:54
Need less equipment, right? 01:01:59
Is going to be probably 2 ambulances and a chase car rather than three and and one. 01:02:01
They're already providing service down in New Albany, in New Albany and they may already have possibly trying to have some intra 01:02:08
local discussion with. 01:02:13
The city about possible backup for the system. 01:02:18
One of the unique problems that we discussed is just geography, which. 01:02:22
I'm under Fire Protection is right in the middle of. So now we've got two ambulances. We're going to have one on the East End of 01:02:26
the county, one on the West End of the county and. 01:02:30
How do you traverse that and? 01:02:35
Without aid. 01:02:38
Within those areas as well, so. 01:02:40
Anyway, I OK, so it has been Will you send those numbers out when you get those? Yeah, when I get them. And in advance in the next 01:02:44
meeting, so. 01:02:49
Thank you. Dale, you want to go or or Jim, you guys want to who wants? Well actually a couple things just. 01:02:54
To Brad's point, and my little logical brain, EMS is not. 01:03:04
Fire and EMS. 01:03:10
Typically there's a I'm not a firefighter. 01:03:12
They want to be a firefighter, but it seems to me like firefighting has A at least a perception of what they do. 01:03:15
And then EMS is not part of that purview, whether it's extraction, whether it's. 01:03:22
Exciting things off the bridge. 01:03:29
That's just a model logical mind. There is a definite distinction and another point. 01:03:32
Is not to correct, but doctor Harris said 80,000 citizens of Floyd County, the cities, probably half of that and they've already 01:03:37
got their ambulance. 01:03:42
Provided by Ameriparo, so we're not providing for 80,000 citizens. 01:03:48
Were provided for like 40. 01:03:52
303540 That's all. 01:03:54
He's helpful for the future. 01:03:58
That's the point, in fact, all of those people involved in building 40 countries. 01:04:01
They do, but Floyd County don't provide ambulance service for them. Fair enough. We need to. 01:04:07
Continue on so. 01:04:13
Grant. 01:04:16
Yeah, there's a lot here, but we've got a top constraint. 01:04:17
Just something to note 301's. 01:04:21
Aimless providers in the state of Indiana and four or 148 of those are fire based EMS 39 are private providers because nomination 01:04:25
of some other ones in there, I can send that data out. 01:04:31
But obviously the fire department is doing something right. 01:04:37
And I would say that the sparkle definitely. 01:04:41
Is in the EMS business where they recognize it or not, whether it's just first responder or they go? 01:04:44
As so far so far as to get EMS numbers and transport, they're definitely doing something right. We should not overlook what we've 01:04:50
already invested in. 01:04:55
In that as far as the task force, I think you mentioned that a couple of times. 01:05:00
We have an EMS Advisory Board. I don't know if that's the task force you're referring to, but I would I don't necessarily think 01:05:04
when another layer of bureaucracy in government use what we have and. 01:05:09
Task that EMS Advisory Board with more data. 01:05:14
Disagree with you on that. I think they're unique qualifiers that we need on that task force that we don't have right now. Right 01:05:19
now we've got we're very, very heavy with very, very expertise people in emergency medicine and fire transport. But we don't have 01:05:24
actuaries, we don't have lawyers we don't have. 01:05:30
Insurance providers and we really need to be holistic in our look on that. So we probably take a couple people from the. 01:05:37
Advisory boards. Put them in there as kind of the backbone of the. 01:05:44
Task force, but we need more input from from different realms of expertise. 01:05:49
So I'm going to stay focused on the dollars because I think. 01:05:58
That are. 01:06:03
Our role in this whole. 01:06:06
Discussion as County Council. 01:06:09
We're talking spending $3 million over a two year period, which I don't see how we could possibly finance. 01:06:12
Without a new let tax. 01:06:21
I'm not opposed to that, although I do tell you that I think we have another solution. 01:06:25
That versus the $3,000,000 we could do for. 01:06:32
Over the next two years, somewhere around 1,000,000. 01:06:38
And I thought that was worth looking at. 01:06:42
For our taxpayers to. 01:06:47
Not have to raise taxes. 01:06:50
At least for the next two to three years. 01:06:53
Versus having to raise taxes to to cover this $3,000,000 so. 01:06:57
That's my role in this whole thing and it seemed like a viable solution to me for a very viable solution to me. 01:07:03
For a reasonable. 01:07:12
Dollar amount. 01:07:17
So that that's all I wanna say. 01:07:19
So I'm going to make a couple comments when in regards to the fire based EMS. 01:07:23
Percentage to the state, I think. 01:07:29
I think there's a difference when you start lumping everything together with between like the volunteer rescue squads and the 01:07:31
volunteer departments and the professional departments. So it may make that number seem a little bit higher than what it really 01:07:34
is, but. 01:07:38
You know, I also want to say that I I think our firefighters that that do not do transportation, they're more than just first 01:07:43
responders, I. 01:07:48
I think they provide very critical life saving. 01:07:53
Skills to patients I've seen it first hand for. 01:07:58
30 years. So just because you don't have an ambulance doesn't mean that you don't provide. 01:08:01
Outstanding care to patients until EMS gets on scene and a lot of times you ride in with the patients and the Mississippi to the 01:08:07
hospital if they're critical. So just wanted to. 01:08:12
Point that out and. 01:08:17
I do like the idea of the. 01:08:19
Of solving the problem for everyone in the county. I mean one of the things that we. 01:08:21
We forget to talk about is that Franklin Township does not have. 01:08:25
A fire district. Nor does it have its own fire department. 01:08:29
It receives its services from a department in Harrison County and I believe they get some backup from Georgetown, whether it be 01:08:32
automatic aid or mutual aid, but. 01:08:36
I think we're long past time to solve this for everybody. And you know, I can envision the system here in Floyd County that does 01:08:40
solve the problem that is very modernized with a lot of modern equipment, maybe even a community paramedicine program that's being 01:08:46
pushed really hard through the state. And you know, quite honestly, I think we might have some equipment that's already available, 01:08:51
you know, through Highlanders that we can utilize. So that'll. 01:08:57
Takedown The opportunity to have to procure. 01:09:03
A bunch of equipment. So that's all I got. 01:09:06
Thank you, John. 01:09:09
I'll be brief. I want to. 01:09:10
Echo Denise's comments. I do also want to. I know Connie at the last meeting you mentioned that last year, I think I literally 01:09:12
transported six. Well. 01:09:17
On April the 1st when y'all had your meeting. 01:09:23
At 610, Highlander transported. 01:09:26
A person, and they met. It was Squad. 01:09:31
61 which I believe is new. 01:09:35
At a church and then transferred that patient over so they were in the process of transporting. 01:09:38
That same day at 9904 in the evening. 01:09:44
They have, I guess, a mutual aid with Clark has Clark's fire on here. 01:09:49
And so they they transported that person to to Clark County. 01:09:55
And then at 10:24 that night. 01:10:00
Squad one responded. 01:10:05
And they transported. I'm sorry, Squad three responded. 01:10:08
And they transported that patient to Baptist Health East, so Highlanders does transport. 01:10:12
Thank you, Jim. We'll go with you and then down this way. 01:10:21
Tony, I'm gonna get you in a second here. 01:10:25
OK, well I personally still back the calendar fire based EMS service. Yes, I know it doesn't cover the whole county, but if you're 01:10:28
already in talks and options of covering the rest of the county with Mayor Pro pointed this out the last meeting. But looking at 01:10:36
these ambulance fee schedules between Highlander Fire District and Ameripro, Mayor Pro is almost double. 01:10:43
Getting some rough numbers. I don't know how exact these are from the. 01:10:52
Personnel department here, just for our own insurance plan. It looks like almost every. 01:10:57
Coverage for the Hollander fire base will be covered under our plan, but that has almost looked like they took it out of their 01:11:02
book because that's about what the rates are. Ameripro is almost double S We're talking out of the pocket expenses. 01:11:08
For these individuals, and a lot of them are in the situation where they can afford these. 01:11:14
As far as funding though, I am not in support of rating. 01:11:19
Lafayette and Greenville funds out of the Hounder Fire district. This is a county wide expense needs to come from the county so I 01:11:24
need kind of boat that's going to. 01:11:29
Pull those funds out of there because we've already had a merger Lafayette Township already. 01:11:33
Recognized a increase in their. 01:11:39
Fire district taxes and if we start raiding these coffers, that means our district is going to pay additional. 01:11:42
Taxes, and that's even providing services for Georgetown and. 01:11:51
Part of Franklin, which is not even being covering the cost of this, so I'm totally opposed to that. 01:11:56
I'm not for fair based. I'm just not. 01:12:08
We are reactive because of things that have happened. 01:12:12
With local companies and the private companies, so everybody's. 01:12:16
Emotions are high. 01:12:24
They know that we need to react in a hurry, but we really need to sit back again. I don't think that my Township that I live in, 01:12:26
I'm at large and represent the entire county, but. 01:12:32
I live in Franklin. 01:12:38
I think I deserve a point service too. I. 01:12:40
That's a huge deal for me and I hate this thing, but I'm gonna throw it out there. 01:12:44
You get what you pay for. 01:12:51
Sometimes. 01:12:54
Tony. 01:12:59
Are you still with us? 01:13:00
I am. 01:13:05
Any comments? 01:13:08
Sure. I just like to say that. 01:13:11
For me it's still hard to see this private provider option coming together. 01:13:15
Without raising taxes. I think I stated that our last meeting and I was opposed to that and and just really opposed. 01:13:21
For us to be moving. 01:13:30
Money that we've already appropriated for. 01:13:33
For different projects. 01:13:37
Movement that money out of our coffers. 01:13:40
As well as the. 01:13:45
Being opposed to raiding the rainy day fund and umm. 01:13:48
I just think that the fire based EMS option is better. 01:13:53
For several different reasons, and I also think that. 01:13:58
During this whole process, we've kind of downplayed the role of firemen. 01:14:03
And the job that they do in the services that they render and I think that it's very important that we keep in mind that they risk 01:14:07
their lives every day and they provide. 01:14:13
A great service. 01:14:21
For our community. 01:14:23
And to keep us safe. 01:14:24
And I guarantee that if any of them were called to where we are or in a position to where we needed. 01:14:27
Medical. 01:14:36
Assistance that they would render that medical assistance and we would be grateful. 01:14:38
Thank you, Ian. 01:14:45
Yeah, just. 01:14:47
Briefly. 01:14:49
I agree with what Tony just said about their. 01:14:52
They're gonna render 8 if they're called on. That's just what these guys do. That's how they're built. 01:14:54
And I applaud them for that. 01:14:58
And. 01:15:02
They're they're the good guys. That's. 01:15:04
So I salute them. I would love to see us. 01:15:07
Fund mayor pro. 01:15:14
And get the task force in high gear and I think the task force needs to include. 01:15:17
Along with everyone you mentioned. Um. 01:15:24
Members from council and commissioners to discuss. 01:15:29
How we're going to pay for this going forward? 01:15:33
We can. I'm not going to speak out of turn, but I think we can get. 01:15:37
Definitely. The rest of this year paid for. 01:15:43
Whether you know it's help from you guys? 01:15:46
Or not, and then we can start working on a. 01:15:49
25. 01:15:52
We can't. 01:15:55
We we pushed this off to the last minute again. 01:15:57
And we just cannot do that anymore. 01:16:00
With 50 days. 01:16:02
I don't. 01:16:06
Firebase is ready to go in 50 days. I just don't think I know that. 01:16:09
They think that they can do it and. 01:16:14
They would try their best, but John, I've got a. 01:16:17
I've got a call that somebody sent me with a CAD number that says. 01:16:20
A fire truck showed up with one guy on it because. 01:16:25
The rest of them were on an ambulance, so I just it's gonna get stretched too thin. Where was that at? It was it was Hollander. It 01:16:27
was Hollander. It was Hollander. Fire responded to a box alarm at Azalea Hills. 01:16:33
One person on Q11 just. 01:16:39
I don't even know what all that means, but you can't have one person on a fire truck. So we need time to get this right. We can't 01:16:42
make a bad decision that the next generation is going to pay for. 01:16:47
We talked about retaining people in our community and how we lose young people and it's things like this that. 01:16:52
Drive people away because. 01:17:00
It's a it's a mishmash. It's a potpourri of services and. 01:17:03
We've got to get this one right. 01:17:08
And that's why I'm in favor of. 01:17:11
Signing with the mayor pro. 01:17:15
Two years Max. 01:17:18
And even even having whatever system we come up with. 01:17:20
Running with training wheels for the last six months. 01:17:26
The two systems running together, if that's even possible, to make sure we're good to go. 01:17:29
When the new system takes over. 01:17:36
That's all I've got. 01:17:38
Well #1 thanks everyone for being here. 01:17:40
In the audience tonight, Tony, thank you for joining us as you can and the board here. I really appreciate the tone of this 01:17:44
meeting. 01:17:47
I think everybody wants resolution of this. 01:17:51
So with the options that are on the table, there's really no way to fund any of them without. 01:17:56
Taking money from somewhere. 01:18:02
You know, with the Highlander it was gonna be 800,000, like 800,000 tears money at least, right? And. 01:18:03
That was allocated somewhere with ours. There's there's other allocations, so there's no way to do it with. We're spreading the 01:18:09
butter really, really, really, really thin here. 01:18:13
I think an EMS lit tax needs to be. 01:18:20
Part of the discussion because I think it solves the whole thing for the whole county for all time. 01:18:23
There are some obviously disadvantages to throw in the order tax around. There are advantages to it too. I mean, the council would 01:18:29
have that in service now they don't pay a balance building. 01:18:33
You know, if if they come for a run for Danny and his insurance doesn't cover it all, well. 01:18:38
The county picks up the tab on that, so you're not bankrupting people because they can't afford the service that's there. 01:18:44
I'd like to see us focus on getting the mayor pro in place for two years between the task force together and. 01:18:50
Again. 01:18:57
Really, purposefully and thoughtfully putting together. 01:18:59
Experts from many many different realms on this. 01:19:03
Yes, take some folks from our EMS Advisory Board, but also build in the business part of it we need to do the actuaries that we 01:19:07
need to kind of say which numbers. 01:19:12
Makes sense. So I I've not made a decision between. 01:19:17
Long term fire based and. 01:19:21
Privatization, because I don't think I've seen the data yet. That tells me very, very clearly which one. 01:19:24
All is superior on that I. 01:19:29
Our next meeting is scheduled for April 23rd. We may have one before then information warrants that would. 01:19:32
Would you all like for there to be a representative from Mayor Pro there to discuss, or just for Q and AI can have someone? 01:19:39
In here for that. 01:19:48
Or can remote them in at least in case they have some questions and. 01:19:51
But otherwise I. 01:19:55
I. 01:19:57
What are you getting from the, from the Commissioner standpoint, what are you, what message are you receiving from the Council? 01:20:00
Because I I guess. 01:20:03
Hear me my understanding, if I'm in your shoes, I would want to know what the councils willing to fund as you go forward with 01:20:07
negotiations with the mayor pro. 01:20:11
And if I understand it right. 01:20:16
I don't know that the majority of the council is willing to fund a private provider contract countrywide. 01:20:19
Well I think Denise hit on it. You know if if there's if, if the issue is forced and. 01:20:25
And Highlander Fire Protection District. 01:20:33
Has a pathway to go out on its own so to speak and you have the funding to do that then we still have to fund these other. 01:20:37
Uncontracted folks. 01:20:45
You know. 01:20:48
If our number that we're working with now is 1.4, I don't see that dropping into. 01:20:50
It's still going to be a high six figures, right, because you're going to be taking out transports that they're not going to be 01:20:55
able to run for part of their subsidy and that type of thing. So yeah, at some point we need a rock bottom number so that we know 01:20:59
what we're working with. I guess my question is that's what needs to be settled moving forward and I would, I would suggest if we 01:21:04
can. 01:21:08
Maybe we have a joint meeting before the 23rd, I believe is what you said, because this is. 01:21:13
Quickly approaching that, we need to have a resolution. 01:21:18
I personally would like to move that timeline up. 01:21:21
That's I'm just one person, but maybe we need to keep this ball rolling. I think we had penciled in one as possible on the 18th. 01:21:23
The the other thing that I might request is that. 01:21:33
We really do get Baker Tilly involved here. Number one, what is the tax? How much will it? 01:21:37
Provide. 01:21:45
We need to see those numbers and if we start. 01:21:46
Diving into these other funds, what does that really look like and what does that do? We need to know the ramifications before we 01:21:50
just jump into signing a contract. 01:21:55
We need to understand and Baker telling is our is our guys now and he they need they need to tell us. 01:22:02
Tomorrow morning or this evening in April 18th, just to see how many we can get. 01:22:12
I don't think there are any other. 01:22:17
Meeting schedules we're trying to do. 01:22:20
You know what time? You know what time, 'cause I have a commitment that evening, so we can move it up to 4430. That'd be great. 01:22:22
But four 4:30 is fine. I to to our speaker's point earlier, there is no perfect time because I have third shift workers that want 01:22:27
to be here, and I'm sure this was called. 01:22:32
Literally because Danny and I both thought we could get most people here because you all had a meeting coming up afterwards and 01:22:39
worked out. 01:22:42
At least. 01:22:46
For the elected officials and I get and we've got a good group of people here too. 01:22:48
But we're never going to give the time that fits for everybody, so. 01:22:51
April 18th, 4:30. 01:22:56
Motion to adjourn. 01:23:01
Can we adopt that first? OK. Is that what you want to do? 01:23:03
OK, send that out either this evening or tomorrow morning, April 18th, 4:30 and do the advertising, everything like that and then 01:23:10
we'll entertain France. Motion to adjourn. So. 01:23:14
All right, the the County Council meeting will start in approximately 5 minutes. Give everybody a chance to stretch your legs and 01:23:20
use the facilities. 01:23:25
Link
Start video at
Social
Embed
* you need to log in to manage your favorites
My Favorites List
You haven't added any favorites yet. Click the "Add Favorite" button on any media page, and they'll show up here.
* use Ctrl+F (Cmd+F on Mac) to search in document
Unable to preview the file.
* use Ctrl+F (Cmd+F on Mac) to search in document
Unable to preview the file.
9/20/24 Joint meeting of County Council commissioners to order. I know Commissioner Schellenberger is in the building. Will join 00:00:03
this momentarily then. 00:00:07
You'll join me in the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic 00:00:12
for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. 00:00:19
All right. 00:00:30
So 1234 it's like I have 5. 00:00:32
People who have signed up to speak. 00:00:37
And we'd like to limit this to like 2 to 3 minutes each. 00:00:42
Rick, you were my timer before, but out there, I don't know how effective you would or wouldn't be. So Daniel didn't do that. But 00:00:47
we still love you, and you'll be our timer next time, OK? OK. 00:00:53
Yeah. 00:01:00
Two. OK, so Mr. Chris Pelman. 00:01:02
And if you'll state your address county of residency, that'd be great. 00:01:07
My name is Chris Hellman. I live at 7661 Navelton Rd. In Floyd County. 00:01:12
Thank you. 00:01:19
OK, so I've kind of kept quiet on this whole subject. 00:01:21
The current provider we're using for EMS. One of the issues that has been had with that provider was. 00:01:28
They're utilizing firefighters. 00:01:36
On ambulances, Which? 00:01:39
Depletes their fire coverage. 00:01:41
My concern is that you all are looking at potentially going with another model. 00:01:44
Would emulate that exact same. 00:01:51
Model. 00:01:56
As a firefighter. 00:01:59
Having three people on a fire truck is extremely important. It is important to us as the fire department, as the firefighters are 00:02:01
going to be there fighting the fire. 00:02:06
And to the public. 00:02:12
You, if you have a fire truck, show up with one person. 00:02:14
On the truck, they are completely ineffective. 00:02:18
They are not able to do their job properly to save. 00:02:21
Lives and property. 00:02:25
That's all I've got. 00:02:29
I just want you all to think about that with your old decision. 00:02:31
Thank you very much for being here and speaking. 00:02:35
Diana Mayfield. 00:02:38
I know you've joined us before, but if you'll please give your address. Diana Mayfield, 6408 Brent Drive, Floyd Noms, Floyd 00:02:44
County. 00:02:49
OK, I'm I wrote it down this time so wouldn't forget. 00:02:54
OK, I'm here tonight to ask that as representatives. 00:02:59
For the taxpayers that you slow down and look at all the possibilities and make decisions that are for the betterment of the 00:03:03
community and not self-serving, it is easy to review the part of any proposal that you like and ignore the rest. You need to look 00:03:11
to protect Olive oil county. While the cost may be the largest part. Look at 911 services as well as non-emergency transports and 00:03:18
the cost to cover the entire county not just the hill. 00:03:26
If New Albany and Franklin Township. 00:03:34
To cover the entire county with all the services, not just portions of the county. The public voted you people into office because 00:03:38
they trusted you. Don't breach that trust and rush into any situation that is not better meant for the entire county. 00:03:47
And I did have one gentleman tell me how transparent the boards are. 00:03:57
That all for accounting boards are transparent. I beg to disagree. 00:04:04
I think they're about as transparent as a black garbage bag, so. 00:04:09
I'm it's it's terrible. 00:04:15
You know, one thing that really bothers me is the meetings. The meetings are sometimes 6:00, five, o'clock, 4:45. They seem to be 00:04:19
scheduled when a lot of public can't be here to speak. Utah, stop and look at people who are working today. 00:04:27
There's a lot of them Can't get off work and even get here. 00:04:37
For 4:45 meeting, that's not fair to your public. It's not fair to your constituents at all. You need to make it where all can 00:04:40
attend. 00:04:45
So I think you all need to end up being more transparent and pay more attention to your constituents. Get out there and talk to 00:04:50
them. They're not well, they're allowed to come in here. 00:04:56
I've talked to a bunch of them that would have been here. 00:05:02
But they can't meet the time frame that you all set. 00:05:05
So that might be something you want to consider in the future when you start talking about transparency. 00:05:09
Thank you. Thank you, Chair Bush. 00:05:15
Thank you very much, Sheriff Steve Bush. I just wanted to say a few things on the Advisory Board to this board. We've been at 00:05:21
many, many meetings that are jointly done. A lot of opinions that's come out from this topic, a lot of emotions. 00:05:27
They'll also lost a lot of vetting, still got more to do. So I just want to really just say. 00:05:34
Looking from the past, we're looking from currently into the future that we look at. 00:05:39
As a dispatch, we have to be able to dispatch somebody. 00:06:13
We want to make sure we're prepared to do that one way or the other. So thank you very much. 00:06:15
Thank you, Darrell Mills. 00:06:19
Darrell Mills with New Albany Township, president of the. 00:06:26
New Albany Township Fire Board. 00:06:31
Like take this opportunity first of all. 00:06:34
Take Everybody in this room knows that. 00:06:36
Your Chapel far is under a lot of scrutiny and. 00:06:39
We have a lot of turmoil going on. I won't take this opportunity to thank. 00:06:43
Highlander Fire Department, Georgetown Township Fire Department. 00:06:47
Tri-county and Borden and also New Albany City Fire Department for helping us through these times right now. 00:06:52
We have a lot of legal issues that we're dealing with. I can't really speak for those. 00:06:58
But we're going to upright this fire department, the boards. 00:07:04
Been meeting regularly. I think you all seen me. I've been trying to stay. 00:07:07
On top of everything with your all situation with contract for the ambulance service. 00:07:11
I think most of my conversations have been pretty open with several of you that have spoke to me. 00:07:17
New Chapel. 00:07:24
Fire Department. 00:07:26
Us as a board, we are not in a situation to run our own ambulance service. 00:07:27
I think it needs to be a county wide fire department ambulance service if that's what you do, not just. 00:07:33
Certain areas. 00:07:38
I'm not speaking against any agency here, I'm only speaking on behalf of the Albany Township. 00:07:40
But I think we need a county wide. 00:07:46
Ambulance service that will service New Albany Township residents as well as anyone else. 00:07:49
We don't know what our issues are going to be fiscally. 00:07:55
Trying to straighten out the fire department, but our priority is Fire Protection, not ambulance service. We've never provided 00:07:58
ambulance service. 00:08:02
We've always relied off the county commissioners contract. We don't own ambulances. 00:08:06
I live in New Albany Township. 00:08:11
I'd like to see New Orleans Township protected with ambulance the same as the rest of the county. 00:08:13
Please take that into consideration. I'm open to meetings. 00:08:18
But I think one ambulance service service in the county. 00:08:23
With the county commissioners contract. 00:08:26
It's their choice on who they go with. I want to step on their toes. 00:08:29
But we need to have coverage too. 00:08:33
And I don't know fiscally. 00:08:35
What we're going to be at once we get all this going with our fire services, but right now? 00:08:37
We need a fire service in New Albany Township. 00:08:42
They can say they got one. I saw the interviews. 00:08:45
Right now, we're relying on MO Houston to answer our FAR calls. 00:08:49
So that's our priority right now. 00:08:53
30 seconds. 00:08:55
So I appreciate any support that you all could give us in New Albany Council. 00:08:57
Thank you. Thank you. 00:09:01
Tim Harbison. 00:09:04
I live at 3820 Edwardsville Galena Rd. 00:09:14
I'm a very linear thinker, and so I'm going to tell you right up front. 00:09:19
That this may be oversimplified. 00:09:23
But to me. 00:09:27
Attended meetings, watching the videos. 00:09:29
Something that seems so painfully simple has been so extensively debated. 00:09:32
And I just figured there must be a piece of the puzzle that lots of us in the audience do not see. 00:09:38
Ameripro $1.5 million price tag and I watched the video of the last. 00:09:46
Meeting of the Council and nobody could tell us for sure how to fund that $1.5 million. 00:09:54
New Chapel. 00:10:04
I'm sorry, they're really not an option. 00:10:06
Clark County neighbor of ours is spending. 00:10:09
Has at least one person with a credit card spending our money on a lot of different things. 00:10:13
And they're under an FBI investigation. 00:10:18
So like I said, oversimplified if you have three choices. 00:10:21
And two aren't viable. You only have one option left. 00:10:28
And like I said, there's probably a piece to this puzzle that I don't understand. 00:10:32
But two of the council members and. 00:10:37
Two of the Commissioners. 00:10:41
Seem to doubt the proposal that the Highlander Fire District put forward. 00:10:42
And they seem to doubt. 00:10:49
The funding that members of their own council put forward. 00:10:51
And yet I haven't seen any of the data. 00:10:55
That backs up their doubts. 00:10:59
On why the funding was incorrect. 00:11:02
Or why? 00:11:05
The professional firefighters and Highlander Fire District could not deliver the service that they offered, so if there's some 00:11:08
data out there that helps you. 00:11:13
Decide that Highlander couldn't do what they say they're going to do more that the funding. 00:11:20
That some of your own council proposed, I think it would help all of us in the audience to know what the data is. Thank you. 00:11:27
Thank you, Bill. 00:11:35
I'm Bill Banta. I'm the chief of the Georgetown Township Fire Department. 00:11:43
I've been up here several times and I've said the same thing several times. Georgetown Township. 00:11:47
Supports the legal process that was inspired by the board by the commissioners through their recommendation to accept the contract 00:11:52
through Maripo looking at at least one year contract. 00:11:57
I've said this several times. 00:12:03
Give yourself a little breathing room and sign the contract on Monday. Start Tuesday to end up resolving this issue permanently. 00:12:04
But again, we've said it several times. 00:12:12
There was a legal process. 00:12:16
And it should be followed. 00:12:18
Thank you. Thank you. 00:12:19
All right, so that is everyone who had signed up. 00:12:22
To speak tonight and we do have one item of new Business Today and that's to continue the discussion of the EMS. 00:12:25
Situation here, so I think. 00:12:34
All of the commissioners attended. 00:12:36
The funding meeting that you all had Monday a week ago, I believe. 00:12:38
And just to give us a starting point of. 00:12:44
For where we are. 00:12:47
You know, a majority of the commissioners did put forward a plan to negotiate with the mayor of Pro. 00:12:50
For coverage for the entire county. 00:12:55
New Chapel was taken off the table. 00:12:59
Primarily because they could not show financial solvency. 00:13:03
And then there was a second proposal or a third put forward regarding how you look at it. 00:13:08
From Highlander Fire Protection District. 00:13:15
To provide EMS service. 00:13:18
But the missing piece to that puzzle, perhaps, is that they're not going to cover the whole county. They're they're covering. 00:13:20
Quote UN Quote The Hill. 00:13:26
So I think that's where we are as kind of a stepping off. 00:13:28
For tonight is at the beginning of your all funding meeting. There was a discussion of. 00:13:32
Of the 1.4 million, which I think is the number we're looking at rather than 1.5. 00:13:39
Where was that going to come from concretely? And there were some leads that were discussed. And there was. And I saw people 00:13:45
taking notes at that meeting and they've said they were going to maybe follow up with looking at that. And then there was the 00:13:49
discussion of Highlander, so. 00:13:53
I guess my first jumping off point is. 00:13:58
Was there any further looking into the funding of the Commissioners proposal? 00:14:01
For the county wide coverage from America Pro for 1.4 million. 00:14:07
I I think there's been lots of discussions and. 00:14:14
Ideas that are still being. 00:14:20
Processed and. 00:14:23
Making sure they're viable options. 00:14:26
I think everything we had on paper. 00:14:31
Showed us. 00:14:34
75% there. 00:14:38
Available. Not that we agreed upon it, but. 00:14:41
Available. 00:14:44
To do you know funds that could be made available I. 00:14:47
I think the. 00:14:55
The sticking point? 00:14:57
Is probably. 00:14:58
How long do we want to try to negotiate this contract? 00:15:02
And what happens? 00:15:05
After the contract what what type of planning? 00:15:07
Goes into the the after. 00:15:12
Yeah, one concrete update from that from discussions with the Mayor Pro is that you know we that RFP originally was for three 00:15:15
years. 00:15:18
And they are not willing to go below 2 years. 00:15:22
But it seems like there is we have to go to two years. 00:15:27
And I know that. 00:15:30
The there was also discussion about the commissioners meeting halfway or trying to find some funds for that as well and. 00:15:34
So I think, Mr. Love. 00:15:41
Had discussed at least. 00:15:45
Two potential issues out of Jason, do you want to comment on that? Yeah, I think one of the issues that we we discussed where 00:15:47
there was some money available was the where we had set aside for broadband. 00:15:52
Broadband coverage. 00:15:58
So I think there's about $600,000. 00:16:00
Available in there that we can use to offset that so. 00:16:04
If I have to choose between broadband and emergency services while I choose emergency services. 00:16:09
Well, since we're talking about broadband. 00:16:14
We initially had $1,000,000 set aside. 00:16:17
And over the years we have. 00:16:20
We have given up 400,000. 00:16:23
200,000 like for the building turn 1000 for I'm not sure what it was but I am totally against. 00:16:26
Using that 600,000 for the for EMS. 00:16:32
I live about Greenville and Lafayette. We have a lot of areas out there. I still have broadband. 00:16:36
Y'all be you might be OK. 00:16:43
Adjacent Georgetown and Franklin. There's a lot of areas out there, too. 00:16:46
And but this money has been reserved for broadband and I am totally against that. I think we're just cutting our cutting nose off 00:16:50
spotter face with that. 00:16:54
And it's only just a one time, just a one time give. 00:16:59
And so if you're looking at two year contract, what are you going to do to supplement that the the second year? 00:17:03
So I'm told against using. 00:17:09
I think the people. 00:17:11
In Floyd County, that out in the rural areas that don't have broadband. 00:17:13
I think they would be outraged. 00:17:17
Well, I think that as time has gone on, I think technology kind of. 00:17:20
Runs pretty quickly. I mean, I can't even walk out of the phone store without getting a new phone already. And you know, the truth 00:17:24
is, is that we're at a point where. 00:17:28
You know, there's plenty of options out there. High speed options with satellite servers such as Star Link. 00:17:31
That somebody could pay for, you know, so. 00:17:36
I really, I'm really not sure you know, as far as on a local level how much we should be. 00:17:39
Paying for people's broadband when we have emergency services that need funded. So that's just my opinion. 00:17:45
Well, the. 00:17:51
The Indiana Broadband Association, I talked with one of them today and they've got two rounds coming up. 00:17:53
First one will be sometime in July of this year and the second will be fourth quarter or next year. 00:18:00
And you know, it's a long process because they're looking at. 00:18:07
They're comparing the address that they have are the ones that been reported that want to make sure that they got the database 00:18:11
right. So it's you know it it it's a it's a slow process. 00:18:15
But again, they have plans. 00:18:20
To work with the. 00:18:22
To work with the with the providers and. 00:18:25
They are. They'll be putting their plans together and and when they look at that, they're looking at how much. 00:18:28
How much money will be will be? 00:18:34
Will be provided and not only by the by the provider, but also local match. 00:18:38
From the from local government and so we need to have skin in the game and we don't have that money there. We don't have skin in 00:18:45
the game. 00:18:48
Well, if we're looking at different sources, I will. 00:18:55
Consider a broadband just because, as I said, I'd rather have areas not covered by broadband than not covered by ambulance. We 00:18:58
have other options. Like I said, I'll look at and listen to lots of other options. Doctor Harris, did you join us after we began? 00:19:04
OK. Sorry I didn't. I didn't see you there. 00:19:13
So. 00:19:17
All right. So any other leads on? 00:19:21
Coverage for the entire county. 00:19:25
With the Ameriprro. 00:19:27
Contract that was approved for that was suggested, are we talking one year or two years, so we need to have at least two years. 00:19:30
Of funding and so. 00:19:38
I I would love to see. 00:19:41
What Danny thinks the numbers look like for a two year funding. 00:19:43
When we're 75% there, if he could put those on the board because I don't know what they are. 00:19:47
We talked about him in our Monday night meeting. Can we can we have you put him on the board for us? 00:19:53
If you think we're there, I mean, because I'm really, I'm just being serious. I don't know how we're going to use, I don't know 00:19:58
where 75% of it's going to come from. 00:20:03
If if we have it, I'm. 00:20:09
That's that's a great thing for a two year period. From my recollection, you all had discussed CARES ACT money. 00:20:12
Yes, we have, and there is a discussion as to whether that should go just for the Highlander Fire Protection District or to the 00:20:18
Ameripro, right, that is, Mr. Bagshaw stated. A good portion of that has been earmarked for the health department and their new 00:20:23
home in 2026. 00:20:28
Yes, so. 00:20:34
So again, options there's options for using. 00:20:37
That CARES Act money that was already set aside for something, or the ARPA money that was already set aside and I don't have. 00:20:41
Or the Legacy Foundation Foundation was mentioned Money. 00:20:50
Which we would have to get into the umm. 00:20:54
The principal Thank you, the principal for. 00:21:01
Again. 00:21:05
All options, but have we talked with and done any? 00:21:07
Further homework on the I believe I even heard someone stay under their breath, maybe off microphone about an EMS lip tax. 00:21:11
So what? It probably didn't get into the minutes. 00:21:19
I've stayed on the record. It needs to be part of the discussion. 00:21:23
If you're gonna have a service. 00:21:26
And you want to have ongoing funds for that service whether it's county wide EMS, whether it's privatized? 00:21:29
Whether it's stitched together from the different fire districts doing. 00:21:35
Which really are the only three options. 00:21:39
Then you have to have some sort of ongoing funding for that and. 00:21:41
So I think that needs to be. 00:21:45
On the tables. 00:21:49
I don't disagree if that's the way we want to go. I don't see any other way to fund this. 00:21:51
Besides a EMS tax if we want to go this direction. 00:21:57
Which means you have to put it in place this year, I believe. 00:22:02
In order to start collecting it next year. 00:22:06
And again, we'd have to talk with our financial people about the timing of how that tax would work. 00:22:09
I would tell you I probably in all sincerity talked to no less than 100 people constituent like outside of these meetings and I'm 00:22:17
sure everybody else has to and we had one speaker. 00:22:22
At the last meeting, I can't recall his name, but he stood up there and said that that seemed to be the most logical. 00:22:29
You know, talked about it. I think his estimation was $39.00 a person in the county. 00:22:36
Four to five people that I talked to. 00:22:43
We're saying that that seems to make sense. I do get people that balk at that and I get that. 00:22:45
If you're going to do that, you have to have a non reverting fund where that money goes. 00:22:52
Towards EMS and everybody EMS. 00:22:56
People need to be able to see where their tax money goes, OK? 00:22:59
So CARES Act Money 1.1 million Riverboat 125 Reporter 350. Is that a new one that was not discussed previously? 00:23:03
OK. So and then it'll be an ongoing. 00:23:13
50 to 70,000 per year. 00:23:15
Can you explain? 00:23:18
When we got the new Lao. 00:23:21
Software. 00:23:24
And after an internal audit. 00:23:25
Funds. 00:23:27
Shifted back to the general fund, they were left in an account. 00:23:28
Within the Recorder's office, and it was, it was found. That's about. 00:23:32
6-7 years worth. 00:23:37
Of it just kind of rolling over. So that's a one time. So that was not discussed at the last meeting it was not and then Mr. 00:23:39
Bagshaw discussed rainy day fund. 00:23:43
At the last meeting to correct. 00:23:47
And there'd be a range on that anywhere from. 00:23:50
Dale, you recall what you. 00:23:54
I suggested possibly the first year, but. 00:23:57
If we really wanted to tap into rainy day, I mean, we could fund it. 00:24:00
Earmark raining day for the next two years, but you believe down pretty. 00:24:04
Drastically right? They need to be replenished. 00:24:07
So. 00:24:14
I'm owing the math there there's there's. 00:24:18
If you had the rainy day at the bottom of that, then there's more than enough to cover for two years of that. 00:24:20
So if we want to get into those are a couple of things on there that I I'm just I just need to point out. 00:24:29
Number one, the legacy. 00:24:35
It's really up to the legacy board whether they give us that or not. We have no. 00:24:37
Say and whether we get that we have a say in in the lump sum portion. If we choose the lump sum portion, we do. 00:24:42
And we could. 00:24:49
Get that? 00:24:50
And that. 00:24:52
And like I said in the last meeting. 00:24:54
I see no reason. 00:24:56
That the Legacy Foundation would not approve this because what greater legacy? 00:24:58
And for the Betterment County, then public safety. 00:25:02
I agree, but I'm just, I'm just pointing it out. And the other thing is. 00:25:06
Only part of the let's see, you've got the budget. 00:25:12
We've already had to pay New Chapel five months of that. 00:25:18
So. 00:25:24
So not all the 220 is there. 00:25:25
For this year, will we be there next year? 00:25:29
I mean, I understand, but yes, I mean potentially right. 00:25:32
Could be. 00:25:38
Would you mind adding the rainy day at the bottom there to sort of range please? 00:25:40
What's the current balance? The current available balance minus the Care Act money that implied is 2.8 million. 00:25:48
I saw. 00:25:56
Mr. Steve Burks enter the room gate. 00:25:58
You sit on the legacy foundation, would you have any comment on that? I mean I sit on that as well and I know that historically 00:26:02
we've talked about that the funds should not go towards. 00:26:06
What should be a budgeted? 00:26:11
Fund item correct, but but I don't think that's written into the charter. 00:26:14
And I I'm not trying to put anybody on the spot, I'm just trying to have an informal meeting and you might have information useful 00:26:21
to us. 00:26:24
An informal formal meeting, I would refer to Mr. Striegel or Miss Hendricks, who's in the audience, but my understanding is. 00:26:28
The legacy board simply grants money. 00:26:35
Of the interest off that. 00:26:40
There can be a supermajority. 00:26:46
That can say we will. 00:26:48
You know, we'll have. 00:26:50
That 400,000, whatever it was up there. 00:26:52
Toward this and so. 00:26:55
The purpose of the legacy board is simply to grant. 00:26:57
Money to nonprofits. That's the entirety of our of our Rd. It's not just nonprofits, but, well, what I'm saying. We're the grant, 00:27:04
Grant Turbors. 00:27:09
That's the entirety of our responsibilities when it gets into the nuances of taking money from there. 00:27:14
Then it only comes back to the Council. 00:27:22
And there may have been some legislation that's changed. That's my understanding as the Chairman of the board. 00:27:25
Thank you. 00:27:31
Krishna Kumar Pvt. Ltd. 00:27:35
I think there's another option that I brought up at our last meeting and no one seems to continue. Not going to bring this up. I 00:27:38
guess it's one no one wants to address, but. 00:27:43
I think we need to ask the Commissioners to come to the table with this. 00:27:49
And look at this I. 00:27:53
Then it's benefit study that we had completed. We for some reason have not had this meeting to review this to get some 00:27:55
comparisons. 00:28:00
I've done some rough numbers on this, trying to get us into an average of. 00:28:05
These other numerous counties were involved in this. 00:28:09
And I see potential savings of pension of 282,000 a year. 00:28:13
Which would grow. 00:28:19
With interest every year. 00:28:20
And in addition, healthcare contributions from. 00:28:23
The employees would be. 00:28:27
528,000. 00:28:30
These are just some rough numbers. So we're talking over $800,000 a year. We're talking pretty much half this budget. Yet no one 00:28:32
wants to discuss this. I can't get anyone else on page to at least bring this up to discuss. I I I get such a big number. We 00:28:38
really have to address this. Let's set a meeting. I'm. I'm all for set a meeting. Well, the commissioner's gonna have to be 00:28:44
involved in this. So they have to prove it. So they're not gonna they're not gonna be open to this. It's it's already when. When 00:28:50
did that study come back? 00:28:56
4-6 weeks ago, OK, I mean. 00:29:03
Yeah, I thought the impression was so opinion. I I certainly I have never. I have not received any invitation to come to a 00:29:06
meeting. I'm happy to do that. I've asked to have this meeting, but yet I still got no response. I've been wanting this meeting. 00:29:12
I mean, I I. 00:29:20
Have you emailed me on that? 00:29:21
Not you, no. 00:29:24
So so. 00:29:27
Let's get to do for our next joint meeting. This one was the next joint meeting is when. 00:29:27
Well, the next schedule, right, I think at the end of the month as is, but you know. 00:29:33
We may be having joint meetings weekly between now and. 00:29:36
And the resolution of and we really want to make sure that the. 00:29:41
The vendor that did that study can be at that meeting, so we need to. 00:29:46
Understand when that's going to happen. I mean it's it is at the same time. 00:29:52
Place that has been scheduled for for a couple months. Yeah, I don't remember when that is. I'm trying to look on my calendar. 00:29:57
20 3rd I think 23rd or 4th. Oh, there it is. That's 4:00. 00:30:06
So. 00:30:14
Jim, I just asked you, you said half a million in healthcare. Can you kind of give me just a real quick how you'd rather have that 00:30:16
study and have them confirm some of these numbers, these are just some rough numbers I'm having employees what they would help, 00:30:21
what they would continue to contribute? 00:30:25
To the plan. 00:30:31
I need their confirmation from them. I'm these numbers I have may not be exact I'd rather have that but I'm I'm Sanders potential 00:30:33
there so we at least should be addressing it so we can we get a consensus that we will at the 4:00 meeting on April 23rd have a 00:30:38
vendor available. 00:30:44
Can you reach out? 00:30:51
I think Michelle's here somewhere. 00:30:52
Maybe not. I'll. I'll make sure that she reaches out to him. 00:30:55
And we have that discussion. 00:30:59
OK, so I mean that discussion. 00:31:02
Will take place. 00:31:05
Right now I will tell you that that is very, very promising money for the 2025 budget and beyond, but. 00:31:08
Trying to put something in place now that's effective June 1st. 00:31:18
We still need to take a deep dive into these numbers. 00:31:22
It is the only option on the table right now that covers the entire county. 00:31:27
And I know that we will want to have a discussion. I know that there are folks who. 00:31:32
I hope that people want to go into these numbers a little bit more, but if not, I know that there are some here they're going to. 00:31:40
Talk about the Highlander Fire District proposal. That's cool, but I do want to bring. 00:31:45
Mr. Rick Fox forward. 00:31:51
To discuss. 00:31:53
The that option before we get into the numbers part of it. 00:31:55
So does anyone else have anything to say or suggest about? 00:31:58
These possibilities at this point in time, I don't think that the legacy foundation money is going to. 00:32:03
Be available within the next. 00:32:11
52 days, whatever we have left either. 00:32:13
So again, what do you have that's actually available in the? 00:32:16
We can, we can move funds and. 00:32:20
Reimburse, I believe. OK. 00:32:23
I believe they call for a monthly. 00:32:25
Cash payment. 00:32:28
Right. Yeah. So it's understood. 00:32:30
I I think. 00:32:33
Before we make any final decisions, we may want to get Baker Tilly to look at. 00:32:35
Using rainy day funds. 00:32:41
To do to to do this because. 00:32:44
I don't know this for sure, but there is a suggested. 00:32:48
Amount that you should have on hand. 00:32:54
Just like you would have at home, you know, three months of cash or three months of savings. 00:32:57
And we may be below that if we. 00:33:04
Start using up our rainy day funds. 00:33:09
To support this, I'm not suggesting that we shouldn't. I'm just suggesting we may need to get Maker Chilling. It is a suggestion, 00:33:12
yes, and this is the contract is paid monthly. 00:33:17
We went years and years and years with. 00:33:23
800,000 to $1,000,000 in there, and I'm not suggesting that we that we rate the rainy day fund. 00:33:27
But I. 00:33:34
My understanding was it was suggested to keep it up. 00:33:37
At the 10% of expenses level for. 00:33:40
Ratings. Umm. Uh. 00:33:44
And I don't think bonding rates do get impacted and and we do need cash on hand because our levies only come up in once every six 00:33:46
months. 00:33:51
So if you're not careful. 00:33:57
With your cash. 00:34:00
Right. I'm just suggesting we may need to get our financial guys to understood. 00:34:02
I know where you come from. So I noticed the EMT lid isn't on the board up there yet. 00:34:09
You probably don't want to be the one that has to put it up there, right? 00:34:13
I will officially put it on the table for discussion. I thought we were talking about things that were available now, so I 00:34:19
understand. Well, that's the same thing with the down the road you could have. 00:34:24
The health insurance. 00:34:31
And the. 00:34:33
What was they look for? 00:34:34
It's intentional and we really don't know where the savings is on that. 00:34:36
But it belongs out there. 00:34:45
Because, you know, my thinking on this has has. 00:34:51
Evolved to the point where I think that. 00:34:55
That needs to be part of the conversation. I mean, I really think we need to sign with the mayor pro for one to two years, but we 00:34:57
have a task force to look at county wide EMS. 00:35:01
To see if that is financially the best way to go and if so, then how do we fund it and that's probably going to be. 00:35:06
The best way to do that in an ongoing fashion? 00:35:13
And that would allow us to. 00:35:16
Form of service from the ground up, but Rick, do you want to? 00:35:18
Where can I? 00:35:23
We brought this my engine earlier today, so. 00:35:27
Rick, Fox County Attorney. 00:35:32
I'm here to specifically speak with regards to EMS services. 00:35:35
With respect to the Highlander Fire District. 00:35:41
In my opinion, the ordinance or charter of the Highlander Fire District does not authorize EMS services. 00:35:46
In fact, it is the commissioners that have the statutory authority to authorize franchise our contract for emergency medical 00:35:54
services. 00:35:59
In support of that, I just want to go through briefly with regards to the ordinance and some other authorities that support that 00:36:04
opinion. 00:36:08
To start with, in terms of. 00:36:15
The ordinance under Section One, it speaks specifically. 00:36:19
The following purposes for which the Highlander Fire District was established. 00:36:25
And under a Fire Protection fire extinguishing all fires B. 00:36:30
Fire Protection, including identification and elimination of all potential and actual sources. 00:36:36
Of fire hazard. 00:36:43
And see other purposes or functions related to Fire Protection and fire prevention. 00:36:45
And nothing was said about. 00:36:53
Emergency services and under the statute. 00:36:56